Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
9.2 Appeals, Leave to Appeal, Fresh Evidence (S.23 CAA 1968) - Coggle…
9.2 Appeals
Appeal - Crown Court decisions
The Slip Rule - The to rectify mistakes at sentence:
CC has its own version of the 'slip rule' although it only applies to sentences
S.385 Sentencing Act 2020
allows judge to rescind a sentence (or other order) within 56 days of it being made
Judge who passed sentence must be judge who makes the variation . Can be used following sentence on an appeal from the MC. But in this instance the lay magistrates don't need to attend slip rule hearing
Purpose of the slip rule - save time and money + removes need for either party to appeal in cases where a recognisable error has been made in the sentence
Therefore if an appeal, application for leave to appeal, has been decided by the CA then the Slip Rule can no longer be used
cont:
Use of the slip rule is not limited to amending the length of the sentence or correcting minor technical errors, but permits amending the type of sentence or requirements attached to a community-based sentence
Example:
For example, if a defendant presented mitigation that they were the sole carer for a sick relative and on this basis a sentence of imprisonment was suspended, Court can amend this to impose immediate custody if they discover that the mitigation was false
On the other hand, a D who, a week after receiving a community order, obtains work on a nightshift may have a curfew removed to enable this. It would almost certainly be replaced by an
alternative requirement.
Court of Appeal
Grounds
Powers
CA Criminal Division has jurisdiction to hear certain types of case from the CC (non-exhaustive list):
(a) Appeals against conviction on indictment;
(b) Appeals against sentence passed following conviction on indictment;
(c) Appeals against sentence passed on committal for sentence;
(d) References by the Attorney-General of unduly lenient sentences, for offences triable only on indictment and some either-way offences specified by the Home Secretary;
(e) References by the Attorney-General for opinions on points of law following acquittal on indictment;
(f) References by the Criminal Cases Review Commission;
(g) Prosecution appeals against terminatory rulings;
(h) Appeals against rulings made at preparatory hearings in serious fraud cases.
Appeal against conviction or sentence:
These powers of appeal come from the following section of the
Criminal Appeal Act 1968:
Against conviction - ss.1 & 2
Against sentence following conviction on indictment - ss. 9 & 11
Against sentence following committal for sentence - ss. 10 & 11
Leave is required to appeal to the CA. Appellant from the CC need to convince a single judge that their appeal is arguable on merits before it proceeds to an oral hearing before a 2 judge court (sentence appeals) or a 3 judge court (conviction appeals)
If leave is refused by the single judge a party may renew an application for leave orally before the relevant panel
Law and procedure is largely the same for both appeals against conviction and sentence so can be dealt with together
Procedure and Time Limits:
Notice of Appeal (Form NG) must (since OCt 28) be served on the Registrar of the Criminal Division of the CA
Notice must be served within 28 days of the conviction (conviction appeals) and within 28 days of sentence (sentence appeals)
Time limits can be extended - extension must be applied for when serving Form NG, giving reasons for the delay
Whether to permit this is a matter of the Court's discretion. In practice, if Court finds merit in the grounds of appeal they are likely to allow the extension in order to prevent injustice
Duties of Counsel:
Counsel should advise promptly
Oral advice should be given immediately after conviction/sentence
If there's no grounds a negative advice should be prepared and sent to the D's solicitors
If there are grounds, they should be clearly and precisely drafted and sent to D's solicitors
Counsel must draft an Advice, setting out their advice on the merits of an appeal and Grounds, setting out the proposed grounds on which they advise on appeal has merit
Certificate of Trial Judge:
In exceptional cases the trial judge may certify the case as 'fit for appeal'. This is unusual as it would require the judge to consider that they had made an error
It's not really routine application at the end of a trial that you have lost
If a certificate is granted, then leave is not required but counsel do have to comply with the appeal procedure in the usual way
Transcripts:
All CC proceedings are digitally recorded. Transcripts are ordered by the Registrar if they are required in order to resolve the appeal
In conviction cases the summing up and proceedings up to and including the verdict are usually obtained as a matter of course
In sentence cases, the sentencing remarks are obtained and any prosecution opening of facts where the sentence takes place following a guilty plea
Perfecting grounds:
When transcripts are received counsel with be sent a copy and invited to 'perfect' grounds within 14 days i.e. adding references to the transcripts to support the arguments advanced or reconsidering the grounds and perhaps amending/deleting or advancing new ones in light of the transcripts
If counsel does not wish to perfect, they should notify Registrar Perfect grounds should be in a fresh document and clearly marked as such
If counsel decides that appeal is no longer arguable, counsel should advise the appellant's solicitors in writing
This advice should not be sent to the Registrar but the Registrar should be informed
1 more item...
Advice and Grounds must be drafted as 1 document. it should identify any transcripts which are necessary
In practice: keep good notes, keep track of dates and times of any rulings during trial
This allows Registrar to obtain transcripts to assist the single judge and enable counsel to 'perfect' their grounds
Counsel should also provide list of authorities, if they want to rely on any
Counsel should only draft grounds which are reasonable, have reasonable prospect of success and they are prepared to argue before the court
Unmeritorious appeals risk a 'loss of time' order and counsel's positive advice does not guarantee a protection from this
Once Advice and Grounds are received by the solicitor they should be sent to D for approval. Form NG can be signed by solicitor on D's behalf, if they have instructions to do so
Form NG will be sent to Registrar, along with counsel's Advice and Grounds.
CC will send the relevant papers from their file to the CA along with defence appeal documents
This allows Registrar to confirm what happened at the lower court e.g. what sentence has been recorded and when the appellant was convicted
Procedure:
Time limits
Advising on appeal
Certificate of trial judge
Transcripts
Perfecting grounds
Respondent's notice
Consideration of leave to appeal
Renewal
Referral to full court
Attorney-General References
Criminal Cases Review Commission
Appeal to the Supreme Court
Leave to Appeal
Fresh Evidence (S.23 CAA 1968)