Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
GWST Week 12 - Coggle Diagram
GWST Week 12
Global Health and Climate Crises
"'Cripping’ the World Bank” by Corinne Mason (2015)
How the World Bank “counts” violence and disability
DALY (disability-adjusted life years)
Measures harm by productive years lost to injury, illness, or even death; the Bank uses it to claim violence against women is “inefficient”
“the organization maintains that violence is inefficient” (p. 436)
Mason critiques that DALYs treat disability as a tool for calculating lost productivity, so they ignore women with disabilities and the structures that cause violence.
“disability is merely conceptualized as a state of being that must be overcome” (p. 443)
Crip theory / compulsory able-bodiedness (McRuer)
Being able-bodied is treated as both natural and normal, however it is constantly reinforced and maintained as an idea
“fully abled bodies are most valuable because they are the most productive” (p. 436)
Empowerment: flexible, cheap labor (racialized ableism)
The Bank’s view women’s paid work as a form of empowerment, believing that investing in them is "smart economics"
“is just smart economics.” (p. 441)
The UN recognizes women as important in addressing these issues, but Mason warns that this can place even more responsibility on women to solve these problems.
The Bank also shows racialized ableism by assuming what a “normal” productive body looks like while depending on cheap and “flexible” labor from racialized women in the Third World.
Women are also expected to demonstrate individualiztion by adapting and showing resilience, while larger systems like austerity and SAPs remain unchanged.
“women are required to overcome: to be flexible, to be resilient and to adjust” (p. 444)
Both show how women are expected to take on more unpaid work to deal with crises.
Case study: Ciudad Juárez maquiladoras (Export Processing Zones
Workers are subject to low wages, unsafe working conditions and suppressed labor organizing
There are over 200,000 workers, with over half being women, yet femicide is a known aspect
DALYs treat violence as a “home” issue and miss/ignore violence tied to work
“genderedviolence within labor sites is outside the World Bank’s purview.” (p. 446)
“Women, Gender Equality and Climate Change,” UN WomenWatch Fact Sheet (2009)
Climate change and women (health and daily burdens)
Women unfortunately make up teh majority of the world's poor and have a higher dependence on threatened natural resources
“women are more vulnerable to the effects of climate change than men” (p. 1)
The UN connects women’s vulnerability to their lack of equal access to resources and power, while Mason argues that the Bank expects women to adjust instead of addressing the larger problems.
In the food aspect, women produce 45-80% of food in developing countries yet they are often excluded from decisions on land and resources (pp. 1-2)
Fuel and water collection
Takes 2 to 20+ hours a week, leaving less time for school, income, and rest
“perpetuating the cycle of disempowerment” (p. 2)
"women and girls bear the burden of fetching water"
“women and girls also pay the heaviest price for poor sanitation” (p. 3)
Health and disasters
Floodwater contaminated with arsenic leads to women being judged, while malaria, cholera, and dengue continue to spread (pp. 3–4)
Both address women’s health, but the Bank measures it as lost productivity while the UN frames it as rights and wellbeing
Women have to take on more caregiving responsibilities for sick family members and face unsafe, overcrowded shelters after disasters (pp. 4, 9)
Women as agents of change
Women tend to hold knowledge useful for mitigation, adaptation, and disaster reduction
“effective actors or agents of change” (p. 1)
The four main areas of action are as follows(p. 6): mitigation, adaptation, technology transfer, and financing
Policies should aim to further consider women's specific needs, experiences, and responsibilities.
This includes giving women a voice in decision-making, collecting data that shows how issues affect men and women differently, and providing equal access to loans, resources, and training.
Technology and finance gaps
“Technology is never gender-neutral” (p. 8)
“women do not have sufficient access to funds” (p. 8)