Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
9.1 Appeals - Coggle Diagram
9.1 Appeals
-
Summary trial - overview
Trial:
- Trials are only necessary when D pleads 'not guilty' and their guilt needs to be determined by the hearing of evidence. Most D's pleads guilty (around 90% in the MC and 60% in CC)
- Trial in the MC is known as summary trial. Summary trial involve:
- 'summary only' offences (offences that can only be tried in the MC); or
- 'either-way' offences (offences that can be tried in either the MC or the CC) where the magistrates have retained jurisdiction following the allocation procedure
- In the CC a D is tried on indictment. Each indictment has a number of counts reflecting the allegations against D
- The overall process of a trial is the same irrespective of the court its heard in e.g.
- burden of proof
- rules of the admissibility of evidence
- possible inferences which can be drawn under the CJPOA 1994
- how witnesses give evidence and which witnesses
- order of the evidence
- A trial is adversarial, so prosecution will always open the case as it carries the evidential + legal burden of proving the case beyond reasonable doubt.
- If at the close of its case, prosecution has failed to introduce sufficient evidence, then an application of 'no case to answer' can be made
Summary trial - The Bench:
- All summary trials take place before a 'bench' of at least 2 (usually 3) lay magistrates (aka 'justices of the peace') or before a single District Judge
- District judges are professional lawyers. Rather than sitting as part of a bench of 3, District Judge usually sits alone
- Lay magistrates are not professional lawyers; they are unpaid volunteers.
- They receive training to assist them with the law and procedure in the court but also have a court legal advisor to help them
Summary trial - authorised court officer:
- Previously referred to as the justices' clerk, the court clerk or legal advisor
- Authorised court officer will provide assistance to justices of the peace with both the relevant law and procedure when required during the summary trial process
- The authorised court officer takes no part in deciding upon the verdict in a summary trial
- Authorised court officer must be present during a trial judged by a bench of lay magistrates but is not required to be present in a summary trial presided over by a District judge
-
-