Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
(9.1) Settlement & ADR - Coggle Diagram
(9.1) Settlement & ADR
Intro to Part 36
The role of Part 36:
- Court and CPR (including Part 36) encourage parties to settle Part 36 of the CPR:
- Describes a kind of offer that a party can make
- Sets out consequences if an offer of that kind is made and accepted
- Sets out different consequences if an offer of that kind is made and not accepted and the matter proceeds to trial (and those consequences depend on the outcome at trial
- Court has wide discretion when awarding costs and will consider behavior of both parties + effort to settle case (CPR 44.2)
- But advantage of Part 36 is that financial incentives contained within it are more certain than the court's general discretion and go beyond what the court can generally order
- Reason for Part 36 - parties who make realistic proposals to settle actions should get more benefit if they are not accepted and turns out in court they should've been accepted
- A party who is 'dragged to trial' should be reasonably 'compensated' and unreasonable party who insists on trial should be penalised
- 'Penalty' is usually adjusting costs, damages and/or interest
When can a Part 36 offer be made:
- Can be made at any stage of proceedings, including before proceedings are issued
- Part 36 offer can be made by either party
example:
- C writes to D 'I will accept £x from you to settle these proceedings' and if the settlement offer conforms with certain other formalities (CPR 36.5) then its valid for Part 36 offer
- D can also write to C words to effect: 'I will pay £y to you to settle these proceedings' and if the settlement offer conforms with certain other formalities (CPR 36.5 and 36.6) then its a valid Part 36 offer
Part 36 - self-contained code:
- Part 36 CPR is a self-contained procedural code governing offers made pursuant to procedure set out in Part 36
- Normal contractual rules of offer and acceptance don't apply -
the rules that govern the Part 36 offer are set out within part 36 itself
Part 36 offers contrasted with Calderbank offers:
- Nothing in Part 36 prevents a party from making an offer in whatever way it chooses, including by making a Calderbank offer:
- Keyword: 'Calderbank offer"
- An offer, usually communicated in writing, and written 'without prejudice save as to costs', such that it cannot be referred to the judge until costs are considered after trial, but ATP can be relied upon. Such an offer does not need to comply with Part 36
- Although the specific consequences of Part 36 do not apply the court will have regard to a Calderbank offer, when it exercises its discretion on costs (per CPR Part 44)
- But if a party wants to avail itself of the specific cost consequences and protection afforded by Part 36 it must make the offer in compliance with the rules set out in Part 36
Making, varying, withdrawing and accepting Part 36 offers
How to make a valid Part 36 offer:
- Within the rules the party making the offer is = 'offeror' | party receiving the offer = 'offeree. Rules (CPR 36.5) state that Part 36 offer must:
- a) Be in writing
- b) Make clear it is made pursuant to Part 36
- c) Specify a a period of not less than 21 days within which D will be liable for the C's costs if the offer is accepted (called the 'relevant period');
- d) State whether it relates to the whole or part of the claim; and
- e) State whether it takes into account any counterclaim
- These rules apply to both Cs and Ds offer. There are 2 further rules that apply to D's offers only (CPR 36.6):
- a) Within limited exceptions, a Part 36 offer by a D to pay a sum of money in settlement of a claim must be an offer to pay a single sum of money
- b) A D's offer that includes an offer to pay all or part of the sum at a date later than 14 days following the date of acceptance won't be treated as a Part 36 offer unless the offeree accepts the offer
- Key word: 'Relevant period' - A period of not less than 21 days, specified in Part 36 offer, within which D will be liable for C's costs if the offer is accepted
- A part 36 offer can be made at any time, + before the issue of proceedings (CPR 36.7(1))
- Note: Part 36 offer can be made by C and D - so rules refer to offeror (could be either C or D)
- Wide definition of writing means party can make Part 36 offer in a letter (usual case)
- If letter is used, somewhere in the letter it should state it is made pursuant to Part 36. Alternatively there's a prescribed form (N242A) which if completed properly means that Part 36 would comply with the rules
- If offer complies with these rules it will be a valid and proper Part 36
Withdrawal of Part 36 offer:
- If offer has already been accepted --> cannot be withdrawn, or its terms changed (CPR 36.9(1))
- If trial already started --> court's permission to withdraw the offer
- Otherwise, has the relevant period expired?
Yes per CPR 36.9(1):
- Offer can be withdrawn or its terms changed within the court's permission.
- Offer can also be withdrawn automatically if its terms state so.
- This allows the offeror to make an offer that it is time limited
No per CPR 36.10:
- Any notice of withdrawal/change during the relevant period will take effect at the end of the relevant period
- If they don't serve notice of acceptance during the relevant period (despite notice of withdrawal / change) then offeror can either allow acceptance / reply to the court for permission to withdraw the offer to its terms
- This must be done within 7 days of the notice or if earlier before the 1st day of trial.
- Court may give permission for the original offer to be withdrawn or its terms changed if satisfied that there's a change of circumstances since the making of the original offer that its in the interest of justice to give permission
Consequences of part 36:
- a) It's accepted - you then need to know the consequences of the acceptance;
- b) It's not accepted - you then need to know whether court will impose a 'penalty' after trial because the offeree did not accept the offer, and if so, what the penalty will / might be
How ACCEPT a Part 36 offer:
- Serve written notice of acceptance on the offeror (CPR 36.11(1)) -----> If the case is issued the acceptance also needs to be filed at court
- There's no prescribed form for this - a letter will be sufficient
- Important: An offer remains open for acceptance unless it has been withdrawn (CPR 36.11(2))
- This remains the case even after relevant period has expired, unless offer is expressed to be withdrawn automatically at the end of the relevant period
Consequences of accepting a Part 36 offer:
- Stay - The claim will be stayed and won't continue to trial - CPR 36.14(1)
- Settlement sum - For any Part 36 offer which / includes an offer to pay/accept a single sum of money, D has 14 days from acceptance to pay the settlement amount agreed unless otherwise agreed in writing (36.13(6)), failing which C can enter judgement against D (CPR 36.14(7)
If Part 36 offer doesn't include an offer to pay / accept a single sum of money, then if a party fails to comply with whatever was agreed, the aggrieved party can apply to court to enforce the terms of the offer without the need to start separate court proceedings (CPR 36.14(8)
- Costs - Costs consequences of acceptance depend on when the offer was accepted
If accepted before the expiry of the relevant period:
- C is entitled to its costs of the proceedings up to the date the notice of acceptance was served on the offeror (CPR 36.13(1))
- The rationale for this cost consequences of accepting an offer is that C will receive a sum of money in settlement and has therefore 'won' its claim and so should be entitled to its costs of the proceedings
- This is the case regardless of which party made the offer to settle
If accepted after expiry of the relevant period, then (see CPR 36.13(4):
- a) Court will determine liability for costs unless parties agreed them; BUT
- b) Court must, unless (unless it considers it unjust to do so, order that -
- C be awarded costs up to the date the relevant period expired; and
- The offeree do pay the offeror's costs for the period from the date of expiry of the relevant period to the date of acceptance
- Rationale is that C has 'won' its claim - basically D is making a payment to C and so C should have its costs up to the end of the relevant
- But from the end of the relevant period up to when the offer was accepted, the offeree (which could be the C or the D) should pay the cost as punishment as a punishment for not accepting within the relevant period when it had the chance
Special rules where the offer was made less than 21 days before trial:
- Different rules apply where an offeree accepts an offer but the offer was made less than 21 days before trial. In this situation, if the parties don't agree liability for costs the court must determine liability (36.13(4))
Accepting a Part 36 offer which relates to part of a claim:
- Its possible to make a Part 36 offer which relates to part of a claim only (CPR 36.5(1)(d)). Special rules apply if such an offer is accepted
- If, at the time of acceptance, the C abandons the remainder of the claim ----> C will only be entitled to the costs relating to the part of the claim contained in the offer, unless the court orders otherwise (CPR 36.13(2))
- If at the time of acceptance, the C does not abandon the remainder of the claim ----> the liability for costs will be determined by the court, unless the parties can reach an agreement about the liability (CPR 36.13(4))
-
Others
'Unless unjust to do so':
- As already set out, when the Part 36 consequences are triggered, the penalties will be imposed 'unless the court considers it unjust to do so'
- When deciding what is unjust, the court will take into account (CPR 36.17(5)):
- a) The terms of any Part 36 offer;
- b) The stage in the proceedings when the offer was made;
- c) The information available to the parties;
- d) The conduct of the parties in relation to giving / refusing information for the purposing of enabling the offer to be made/evaluated; and
- e) Whether the offer was made a genuine attempt to settle
- The court's discretion under this provision is much more limited than the court's general discretion under the normal costs rules (CPR 44)
Claimant's or defendant's offer, not accepted - special rules
- Where an offer was made within 21 days of the trial, then even if the applicable 'trigger' set out above is satisfied, there will be no Part 36 consequences unless the court abridges the relevant period (i.e. shortens it)
- This is fair because the relevant period (which is already at least 21 days) had no expired before trial. The offeree did not have a fair opportunity to accept the offer
- The Part 36 consequences also do not apply if:
- a) The Part 36 offer was withdrawn; or
- b) The Part 36 offer was changed so that its terms are less advantageous to the offeree and the offeree has beaten the less advantageous offer
- If a party wants to get the full costs protection of Part 36 then it needs to:
- a) Make the offer more than 21 days before trial. Indeed, the earlier the offer is made, the greater the potential benefits to the offeror; and
- b) Leave the offer open (not withdraw it)
Open C's and D's offers effective at the same time:
- What if both C and D already made Part 36 offers but neither are accepted when the matter goes to trial?
- (1) You just need to consider each offer in turn. Consider the examples already provided where the D's offer was £2 mil and C's offer was £3.5 mil
- (2) If judge awards £4mil then as the C has won the same or more than their offer (of £3.5mil) the C's offer takes effect and Part 36 applies (CPR 36.17(4)). The D's offer has no effect as the C has won more than the D's offer (of £2mil)
cont:
- (3) If judge awards £3mil then neither offer has any effect. C's offer (of £3.5mil) has no effect as the C has not won the same or more than their own offer. The D's offer (of £2mil) has no effect because the C has not won the same or less than the D's offer. Costs are likely to be awarded in this situation under the normal principles (CPR 44.2)
- (4) If the judge awards £1mil then as the C has won the same or less than the D's offer (of £2mil), the D's offer takes effect and Part 36 will apply (CPR 36.17(3)). C's offer has no effect as the C has not won the same or more than their own offer (of £3.5mil)
ADR Reasons, types and choice
Types of ADR:
- Negotiation
- A communication process between parties taht is intended to reach a compromise/agreement to the satisfaction of both parties
- Mediation:
- A confidential process intended to facilitate the resolution of disputes through the medium of an impartial 3rd party - the mediator.
- Each party (usually legal representatives) will be present in the same location but in different rooms
- Mediator will move between the rooms delivering settlement offers and guiding each party to reflect on those offers and the alternatives to reaching an agreement
- Mediator has no authority to make any decision which is binding on the parties.
- If mediation does not end in an agreed resolution, content of the mediation will remain confidential and won't be made known to the court
- Arbitration:
- Process by which a dispute is reolved by an impartial adjudicator whose decision the parties to the dispute have agreed will be final and binding
- By agreeing to arbitrate disputes parties are agreeing to oust the jurisdiction of the court to hear the matter, and to give the jurisdiction to a different impartial party (the adjudicator) instead
- The question of whether to arbitrate or not arises at 2 key stages;
- a) When negotiating a contract the parties may decide to include an arbitration clause in their agreement to cover disputes that arise in the future; or
- b) When a dispute has arisen, the parties can choose to deal with it by way of arbitration (i.e. where there's no arbitration agreement in their underlying contract)
- Can be a long + formal process governed by rules and statute
- Advantages: privacy, easier enforcement in certain jurisdictions, choose specialist to determine dispute, flexibility of arbitration to adapt to needs of parties and dispute
- Med-arb:
- Mediation/arbitration is a process where initially parties will try to resolve any dispute by mediation. If it does not result in satisfactory resolution of the matter, matter will move on to an arbitration pursuant to which is a binding determination will be made
- Early neutral evaluation / expert appraisal / expert evaluation:
- Process where an independent party is appointed by the parties. Independent party will provide a non-binding assessment of the matter(s) referred to it
- Parties will have to pay them for time+costs. Assessments provide an impartial 'opinion' which might usefully influence the parties in future settlement discussions
- Independent party could be a lawyer, but alternatively could be an expert in a relevant matter - like medical/engineering expert
- Expert determination:
- Where an independent expert on the subject matter is appointed by the parties to determine the dispute
- The procedure is determined by the contract between the parties
- This form of ADR is especially suitable for disputes requiring a technical knowledge, but may not be suitable if the parties wish to be fully heard and there's issues of credibility
- Conciliation:
- Involves independent neutral 3rd party in helping parties resolve their dispute. The process is usually facilitative like mediation occasionally involves more evaluation (like ENE)
- Term has no clear meaning so parties must ensure they understand what is involved in any particular conciliation before embarking on it
- Conciliation forms part of a statutory scheme/other regulatory scheme, and that scheme might provide who the conciliator should be, and the process involved. This is unlike mediation, where there's matters purely for parties
Why use ADR
- Court expects parties to explore ADR;
- Court expects parties to act reasonably in relation to considering and engaging in ADR, and can impose sanctions if they don't
- Preserves/creates a better relationship between the parties
- ADR factors business relationships, reputational issues/personal emotions can be taken into account as necessary
- Means process can assist the parties in maintaining a commercial and/or personal relationship.
- Parties can explore emotional dimensions / agree a future trading relationship. Court proceedings don't offer such opportunities
- Less expensive
- An appropriate form of ADR if successful can lead to a resolution at less cost than litigation
- Saves time
- An appropriate form of ADR can lead to a conclusion quicker than litigation
- Greater privacy / confidentiality
- Litigation involves filing documents at court which be accessible by the public, and hearings (including the trial) will generally be public. All forms of ADR already identified are essentially private and confidential
- Less disruption to clients
- Forms of ADR like mediation can be less disruptive to clients - they might not need to search for documents, engage in as many internal meetings or attend court the way they might in the case of court proceedings
- Outcomes that reflect risks
- In non-binding forms of ADR the parties can agree a settlement that reflects the risks to each side. In court proceedings judge cannot decide the claim in such a way.
- Judge must decide each issue and then give a judgement accordingly and cannot discount the judgement sum to take into account the uncertainty that is the right judgement
- Greater control over the process:
- In many forms of ADR, the parties have greater control over the process
- One aspect of control is the ability to choose any 3rd party involved (e.g. an arbitrator/mediator), Parties cannot control the court process in the same way nor choose the judge
- Greater involvement of the parties themselves
- Clients often prefer mediation (e.g.) to litigation as there's greater opportunity to get involved in the process and have their say. Litigation can feel like alienating and detached process for many clients
Which types of cases are not suitable for ADR:
- Very few, in practice most concerns about the suitability of a case for ADR can be overcome if the ADR is properly chosen and timed
- Role of lawyers:
- A legal representative acting in their client's best interests will:
- (1) Ensure their client is fully aware of the options for ADR
- (2) Help their client to pursue any ADR which it wishes to pursue
- (3) Act within the authority to settle granted by the client in any settlement discussions. It's generally prudent to involve the client directly in the final approval of any settlement agreement
-
Discontinuance
Claims can end by:
- Success on the substance, at trial or via an application for summary judgement
- Settlement
Admission
- Judgement following the striking out of the claim/defence (e.g. for failing to comply with court rules)
- Claim is discontinued
Nature of discontinuance:
- Only C can discontinue a claim. C can do so at any time - the C is choosing not to pursue the claim against D any further (CPR 38.2(1))
- C can discontinue part of a claim rather than the whole claim (CPR 38.2(1)). C can choose to discontinue the claim against only 1 D or against all Cs (if more than 1) (CPR 38.2(3))
- Discontinuance has 2 major consequences:
- (1) It ends the proceedings relating to the claim / part of claim discontinued (CPR 38.5(2))
- (2) C is liable to pay D's costs up to the point of discontinuance, unless court orders otherwise (if claim is only discontinued in part then C is only liable for costs relating to part which is discontinued) (CPR 38.6)
- In exceptional circumstances court's permission is needed to discontinued proceedings - generally when C has already received some sort of remedy, like an interim injunction or an interim payment (CPR 38.2(2))
Process for discontinuance:
- File for discontinuance at court (CPR 38.3(1)(a)) - this must be clear which part of the claim is discontinued (if only part)
- Serve a copy on every party (CPR 38.3(1)(b))
- Discontinuance takes effect from the date of service (CPR 38.5(1))
- Upon discontinuance, a costs order is deemed to have been made in D's favour on the standard basis (CPR 38.6 and 44.9(1)(c))