POINT- There is scientific support for localisation.
EVIDENCE- Peterson et al. used PET scans and found that Broca’s area was active during reading tasks, whilst Wernicke’s area was active during listening tasks.
EXPLANATION- This supports localisation because, specific tasks produced activity in specific regions, rather than the whole brain being involved. As PET scans objectively measure brain activity in the living brain, they provide scientific evidence for specialised functions, and counter the methodological limitations of evidence such as Broca’s case study.
LINK- However, brain scans can show several areas working together during complex tasks. For example, the motor area is also involved in speech production, when moving the muscles of the tongue and mouth to enable us to speak. Therefore, functions may involve specialised regions working more collectively, as networks, suggesting both localised, and holistic characteristics of the brain.