Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Myths in Psychology - Coggle Diagram
Myths in Psychology
Bullying
Definitions:
- Bullying
- Cyber bullying -
Examples of cyberbullying:
- Flaming - heated, short lived arguments that occur between two or more people; includes rude and offensive language and typically happens in online communication environments such as discussion boards, chat rooms and online gaming platforms
- Denigration - the distribution of false of derogatory messages towards a target, to damage their reputation or friendships
- Impersonation - to have the access to the personal account information of the target and impersonate the target online, uploading negative information that damages the target’s social relationships
- Outing - publicly posting, sending or forwarding personal communications or images that contain personal information e.g. sharing embarrassing photos / videos (including nudes) via text, social media and being tagged on embarrassing photos / videos
- Happy slapping - to publish a video recorded when the victim is filmed undergoing various forms of violence with the aim of humiliating them
- Exclusion - being excluded from online chats or private groups
- Gossiping - spreading rumours about the target via social media, text messages etc
Statistics around bullying - N = 5811 students aged 11, 13, 15 from 37 schools in England:
- 38% of 11 year old boys bullied, 23% cyberbullied
- 33% of 13 year old boys bullied, 17% cyberbullied
- 26% of 15 year old boys bullied, 13% cyberbullied
- 47% of 11 year old girls bullied, 30% cyberbullied
- 36% of 13 year old girls bullied, 22% cyberbullied
- 31% of 15 year old girls bullied, 18% cyberbullied
Perpetrators of bullying -
- 16% of 11 year old boys, 10% online
- 22% of 13 year old boys, 16% online
- 21% of 15 year old boys, 14% online
- 14% of 11 year old girls, 10% online
- 16% of 13 year old girls, 12% online
- 10% of 15 year old girls, 7% online
Measurement issues -
- At younger ages, the methods are principally observations, along with reports from peers, parents or teachers
- Social desirability is an issue in self-report, and parent and teacher reports are not necessarily reliable as adults are not present when bullying happens, making them unaware of subtle forms of it (especially in generation gaps when they may not understand a slang term etc)
Conceptualisation issues -
- Issues with conceptualisation - lack of agreement about what constitutes bullying, how intent to harm and power imbalance are defined and there is no theory of bullying
- Issues with operationalisation - hard to measure intentionality and power imbalance, and there is no firm definition of bullying in existing measures, as well as existing instruments not necessarily measuring bullying
- Ecological validity - survey studies, self-reports, peer reports, adult reports and observational studies are not necessarily generalisable
-
Myth 2 - Bullying and cyberbullying are separate problems (Lazuras et al., 2017)
- Bullying can be seen as a trans-contextual phenomenon, involving both online and offline episodes
- Different forms of bullying can co-occur, children who perpetrate cyberbullying are also involved in other types, including relational and verbal bullying
- Bullying-related behaviours are not fixed - children who are targets of bullying offline may also bully others
- Fluidity between offline and online contexts
Myth 3 - Children who observe bullying want to stay out of the mix (Datta et al., 2015; Machimbarrena & Garaigordabil., 2018; Song & Oh., 2015) - rates for bullying and cyberbullying may vary across studies, depending on the method of assessment
Offline bullying -
- Passive bystanders - 45.4% of children
- Defenders (upstanders) - 48.1% of children
- Reinforcers - (6.5%) - girls are more likely to be reinforcers
Cyberbullying -
- Between 25% and 60% of children witness bullying online
- Defenders - 30.5%
Many children who witness bullying hold anti-bullying attitudes (Salmivalli & Voeten., 2004)
- However, anti-bullying attitudes decrease in early adolescence
- Bullying-related behaviours are not fixed
- Children’s response to bullying situations depend on contextual variables (who is involved; friends v non-friends)
The peer group -
- Group norms increasingly influence adolescents’ behaviour
-> Descriptive norms - what the members of a group do (classroom prevalence of certain behaviours)
-> Injunctive norms - what individuals are expected to do - behaviours that are approved or disapproved in a group
- Due to increasing abstract thinking, adolescents are able to predict their peers’ behavioural responses to bullying and are willing to conform to their peers’ expectations to be accepted in the peer group (Killen & Smetana., 2015)
-
Eysenck and Keane (2010) - critiquing the idea that it takes 10,000 hours to master a skill that came from the ‘Theory of Deliberate Practice’ produced by Ericsson et al (1993)
States that any kind of cognitively complex field sees this consistent pattern that you cannot be good at something until you practice it for 10,000 hours, or 10 years, at 4 hours a day
How is the evidence presented?
- Gladwell uses Mozart, Bill Gates and the Beatles as compelling examples to be persuasive and relatable, so the myth seems feasible
- However, Ericsson (original researcher) says that his research was misinterpreted, and that taking 10,000 hours to repeat the same activity over and over is not sufficient to make someone the top of their field
- Stories are used in media and scientific articles to support an idea or theory
Persuasive technique - telling stories -
- Description is vivid and compelling and so seems more real
- Events have a more personal meaning than a more abstract example so you can relate to them
- The facts or events are presented in a coherent way that lead to an inevitable conclusion
- We prefer consistent beliefs so stories that can explain everything endure, whereas facts that do not fit are forgotten / ignored / changed
-
Narcissism epidemic
What is narcissism?
Non-clinical personality trait comprising
- Agentic extraversion
-> Grandiose self-importance
-> Drive for leadership, power and dominance
-> Vanity and exhibitionism
- Antagonism
-> Entitlement
-> Exploitativeness
-> Hostility, defensiveness, low empathy (low communion)
- Normally distributed in the general population - not the same as NPD
Signs of narcissism increase -
- Obsessed with fame and reality TV
- Self-promotion and personal ‘brands’ on social media and selfies
- Believe in entitlement to promotion regardless of performance
- Fragility (e.g. FOMO)
Year by year;
- Vanity did not fluctuate significantly
- Leadership decreased over time
- Entitlement increased up to 2007 and then returned to baseline
- Twenge et al (2021) - updated meta-analysis in 2016 and found decline in overall narcissism since recession in 2008 and in years of worse employment
Issues with debate:
- Reification - it’s become a thing -> easy to refer to, less questioned
- Public awareness - people now understand and recognise narcissism better
- Self-fulfilling prophecy - we look narcissism
- Self-interest - media want to attract readers - hyperbole sells
-> Academics also want to attract funders and journal editors
Twenge et al., 2008 -
- Meta-analysis of 85 independent samples of US college students collected between 1979-2006 (including unpublished from authors and society mailing list)
- Measure - narcissistic personality inventory
-> 40 forced choice items
-> Covers range of narcissism facets but yields an overall score
-> Good reliability and predictive validity
-> Dominant scale of trait narcissism until recently superseded by a two-factor questionnaire (NARQ; Back et al., 2013)
- Correlation between mean narcissism score and year of data collection (weighted by sample size, accounting for SDs)
- 65% of students in 2006 scored above the average in 1979-1984 - 30% increase in high narcissists
-> Effect of year significant for women but not for men
Wetzel et al., 2017 -
- Data collected by authors from 1992-2015 in three US universities, age 18-24
- NPI - factor analysis identified 3 facets (using the 26 of the 40 items) - leadership, vanity and entitlement
- Some differences in response tendencies across years (measurement invariance) which was accounted for in main analyses
- Overall narcissism decreased slightly from 1990s-2000s and significantly from 1990-2010s
The message - cause of the narcissism epidemic:
- Individualism and materialism in society
- Self-esteem movement in 1970s USA accidentally boosted narcissism instead
- Parenting trends that put kids on a pedestal
- Self-help / therapy encourages self-focus
- Credit cards and debt accessibility encourage overspending
- Social media
- Visibility of narcissistic role models
Predictive factors - economic conditions
- Economic conditions when coming of age (Bianchi et al., 2014)
- Surveyed 1,572 adults in a research panel, born between 1974-1994 (57% male, 77% caucasian)
- NPI overall score + US average national unemployment rate when each respondent was aged 18-25 (emerging adulthood)
- Regression (controlled for age, gender and education level)
- 1-point inc in unemployment = 0.69 point decrease in narcissism
- Extra analyses
-> Self-esteem did not show the same pattern or change effect on narcissism, nor did gender
-> Economic conditions when aged 26-33
Predictive factors - culture
- No data on change over time in multiple cultures
- Inconsistent evidence on whether narcissism is higher in individualistic cultures
-> Foster et al., (2003, N = 3445) found NPI was highest in USA and lower in Asia/Middle East
-> Fatfouta et al (2021, N = 2754) found leadership and exhibitionism were higher in Asia/Africa than USA / Europe / Australia
-> But English speaking opportunity samples and 74% / 51% were from USA
-> In China, narcissism is higher in those who are only-children, more affluent, urban and individualistic (Cai et al., 2012)
Predictive factors - social media
- Reed et al.., 2018 - examine the relationship between problematic internet use and narcissism over 4-months - test if type of social media acts as a moderator
- N = 74 psychology students in the UK (55 women, 19 men)
-> Power analysis suggested 67 sample but this is not convincing
- Time 1 and 2 (4 months apart, all completed both time-points)
-> Problematic internet use questionnaire (18 items; obsession, neglect and control disorder)
-> Estimate average hours of internet use per day for personal reasons
-> List specific websites/apps/platform in order of frequency
--> Grouped by did / didn’t use visual forms
--> Grouped by did / didn’t use verbal forms
-> Narcissism did not correlate significantly with PIU at T1
-> Regression - dependent variable, narcissism, problematic internet use, visual social media, interaction
-> Narcissism at T2 was positively related in T1 PIU for those who need visual social media but not those who didn’t
-> Opposite analyses (T1 - narcissism -> T2 PIU) had a significant overall regression model but the individual predictor statistics were not reported and there were no interactions
-