Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Key debates surrounding the Consiotuion and federalism - Coggle Diagram
Key debates surrounding the Consiotuion and federalism
is the US consitution democratic
Yes
the consitution gurantees the rights fo its ctiizens witha considerabel power to enforce these rights through judical review
United citizens v FEC-
Upheld that Super-PACs were
a form of free speech this has led ot freedom for Super PACs to operate
the preliminary injunction whcih blocked Trump's executive order which ordered the USPS to not deliver postal ballots citing it as an infringment on the 15th amendment
Bostock V clayton county demostrated the pwoer vo the Surpeme clirt to maek sovreign ruligns to protect thr rights e tofu for peopel in the civil rights act
the frequent elections of the House of representative and 1/3 of senate allow for the accurate potlical representation of the people and the creation of a storng electoral mandate for Congress often allowing them to use more oversight over the president
the republican domianted congress under Obama allowed for the congress to confidently strike down his legilsative plans such as the DREAM act in 2012
trump was unable to pass through his bills in 2016 which would have fudned his wall due to strong oppoisition in the Congress. this was due ot h spltis inthe republican aprty nad the prescen fo the democratic party. therefore demsotratign the congress utilisngit mandate
frequency of the elctions foirces presidents to consider public opinion in the middle of their term such as president trump in 2026 who was pressured byu the riesing issue of fuel cost nad th e2026 midterms to sign a hasty deal with Russia to import diesel
the presidency is the onyl directly elected figure int he US government with indepdnet power which allows him to oftne claim a large democratic mandate
the president can oftne use their bull pulpit to demostrate an degree of displeasuere withthe other branches which allwos them to remain acocutnabel tot the public such as Obama's statmetns regarding the isseu sof the united v FEC deiscion
thsi cna maek the presidnet more reponsive to national criis such as Joe Bidne in 2020 who immidatelyt sough to alleiveate Covid as he has been elected on the idea that he would fihg it better than trump which lead to his bill the rescue america plan beign passed with little oppsiton
No
the use of the electoral college seperates the voters from their popualr vote. this can lead to presdient being elcted with a minroity of the popular vote
one elelctorla college vote I
depsite turmp winning under half othe popualtion vote and only 1% more than kamala harris' 48% he reicved nearly 100 more electorla colege votes which secured his victory in the presidental election with very little difficulty
the senate is highyl unrepresentive fo the poeple as it gives euqla representation to all the states whcih leaves people in high popualtion states under presented and those in low popualtion states under presentted
the supreme court has exurbarant powers to block the actiosn fo the demcraticallelected elemtns fo govnermtn they cna evgen create new Legilsation
Obergfel v hodges allowed for gay marriage throughout the US which led to the overruling of legilsaiton in manyt stat adn the creation of new legilsaition elffectively
West virgina V EPA removed reuglatiosn palce by a demcoratically elected government
The new york State rifle nad pistol v bruen was a case raised which overturned the legisaltion in new yormwhich prhibted the concealed carrying of weaponry. this overruoed legilsation created by a democratically elected body
Evaluate the view that the President is the most powerful branch of government rather than Congress and the Supreme court. (30) 2022
yes the presidne tis th emost powerful branch fo govnermtn as the presidne ti snot constrained within his brnach unlike the other branches. Due to this postion he is able to exercise the great power over the govnemrnt as he si aisngualr face and person o tbe assicaoted with his power
the President's exectuvie power is not entirely unchecked as his actiosn within hsi rbanch fo govnermtn are check by the othe rbrnahces fo the governmennt either through congress of the supreme court. these ensure that the president does not exercise his consitutional powers fully unchecked.
the Supreme court has acted to overturn Exectuvie orders ont he president in recent years as they have been able to be overturned through the actionf to eh surpeme court usch as the US v Barabar case which overtuend his 20205 exectuvie order to remove birthright citizenship amd tje 2026 Supreme court intervention to remove his ordero the USPS to not dliver ballots
the OCngress is laso also able to ahcallegn eht epresidnt exctuvie power through their approval and interrogation fo cabient appointements. this allows the Senate to control the appopitn fo cabinet officals such as pete hegseth who was forced to come to a very tight seante cofnriamtion after doubt was throign on hsi qualficiatiosn to be secertary of defence.
The extraordinary s[pendign when granted such asin the CAREs act 2020 came attached with a specila commitee which was to shadow every Decision made by the predient as was done in 2009 with the ARRAs bill passed in reponse to 2008
the consitution places all exectuvie power int he president which allows him to conrol the whole federal adminstration through exectuvie action
the presdient cna act his policy desicively through exectuvie order such as the 2025 exectuvie order by Donald turmp whcih remvoed all DEI programs form the federal adminsitration
the presdient also has the impleid opoiweras the cheif consoluer due ot thead of state role which can be crticial to allwoign the preidne to bully the other branches into allowign his policy, such as durign the itnail stages of the Covid-19 outbrak with the CAREs act in 2020 and the ealier PATRIOTS Act of 2001 which both gave the president considerabel money in order to rsolve the appreantl nationa crisis
The Congress has weak checks over the presientla powers which allows them to operate independetly over certian issues. this allwos trhe presciendey to dominate the federal government
this is demostrated throught eh president ability to exctuvie their foreign policy without the checks fo the congress beign abel to interfere to any degree. this is demostrated most sotrngly trhrought he 2026 venezeulaan intervention where the president was abel to exectuvie their power as the commander in chief without having to ask congress fo rpermission or even make them aware of the attack
this weak contorl is fruther demostrated throught the weak power which is demostrated in termso fforeign policy negiaotion with the presiden tbeign abel to negioate on a the behalf th eocuntry onyl requrign the seante approval at th every end fo the process uch as at the Iran anti cnulare prolfieration treay meeting in 2018
the COngress is able to exercise stonhger powers fo the presidency through ti spower over domestic affairs. to soem extent it is has also ben abel to force a usage fo Congress in order foreign polkicy mneasn allowing the congress ot limthe presidency effectively
Congress wa abel to effectively prevent the constrcution fo the full Southern border wall in the 2019 governemtn shutdown which allowed for the congress to withhod the funds formt eh president which were required ot creat eh tsotuhern border wall
the OCngrewss is also able check the presidentsd over punlci policy by utilsiign their exclusive power to l;egilsative in order to undermine the president Agneda in public policy such as the refusal to pas the SAVE act in 2026 after turmp asked pbulically for tis passage in the state of the union. this was simairly demostrated throughthe refusla fo the congress to pass the DREAMs act in 2015 which woud have allowed child illegla miggrants freew residence.
the president is able to dominate the Supreme court by his exclsuive pwoer to nomiante it's justices over any other figure int eh govcnermtn which allwos him to ensure a degree of ideological continum.
Due to a degree of luck and Trump's party fo the republciasn controlling the senate he was able to make 3 conservative appoitnemtns whose names were drawn from the national trust conservative list
Biden was able to install Knetajii Brown jackson as the first female blakc Suprem court jsutice and Obaam was abel to instlal two jkustice of a liberal outlook. this allows the presidency to influence the judidary l;ong intot hew furture playign the deisive role in rescison such as the Dobbs v jackosn descion begin won because of turmpian nominees
However, this is limtied as the president has no way of removing these justice remvoign the key ele,tmnf o patroange which is the ability to take it away which leasd to justices often breaking rank with their ideology as they were appointed working to limit the president power over the suprem court.
the US v baraba case was utliamtely decided by a conservative breaking ransk adn joinign the liberal justices in amy coney barrett thereby demostratuign th elack fo predictability for the justices. Simialry ina 2020 LGBT emplyoemtn rights casethe turmpain nommiee gorsuch broek withthe party.
the obergefeld v hodges case furhter dmeostrates how the president cannot count fo justice to always rule in line with their ideolgoies and nominators. the regan nominee kenndye broke rnask with the conservative wing and voted to allow homosexual marriage.