Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
TMA01.What can historians learn from this document about industrialisation…
TMA01.What can historians learn from this document about industrialisation in the British Isles in the period 1789–1840?
Who - Leeds Cloth Merchants
What - Open letter? Not sure who to????
Where - Leeds in Yorkshore Next door to Lancs, early industrialisation Woollens(p.65 bk1)
When - 1791
Why - in support of machines
-
-
-
Analyse the content - focus on the material that provides information about industrialisation and its impact. nature and impact of industrialisation?
Cotton production increased - and increasing ( Lancs) p.64
advocate use of machines for wool as did for cotton so can produce cheaper prices only with use of machines
-
-
Were Leeds cloth merchants typical? or diff in other regions/trades leading to different persepctive on same experience?
Doc suggests about INDUSTRIALISATIONTell us move to machine is important to merchants because they want to make products at cheaper prices.
- People in cloth industry moving to using machines more. Cotton industry is increasing and has been by move to machines - this is in Lancs.
- Merchants believed only way they can be competitive is by using machines.
- Leeds is competing against other nations, where there are lower taxes and lower labour costs.
- View is it will benefit the the town and inhabitants.
- Economic situation – merchants worried about being left behind, people concerned with wages. Worried there will be a lack of work
-
Document suggest that industrialisation has meant people worried less work for people. and documents suggests this has not been the case and in fact wages have increased and trade increased
Suggests people would not want to go back to the way life was before the machines
Shows us demand for products is increasing – not just local products – shipping to all countries – canals, botas – road network, canals improved???? - Development of turnpikes – mid/late 18th century – meant better transportation.
Historians can learn that there was a push for machine use, but people were concerned about jobs being taken.
Does not tell us – about time after 1791. Does not tell us the views of the working people and what they thought. Does not tell us what happened in other regions. Different regions had diff experience with Industrialisation –
Woollen industry in wales ( p.79) – new methods not adopted – randall – there was resistance from workers at intro of machines. West country declined.
-
Doc says conerns with wkg class but merchants says no worries
CONTEXT/Analysis - intro of factories holding machines meant
- gendered work - some areas of coluntry - women not seen as strong enough (p67)
Textile - female employment but not everywhere (p104)
Women's wages - low( p105), women not able to earn as much as paid less / not able to work at home (p110)
Real wages - were increase in wages due to longer wkg hrs? (p109)
-
In isolation just tells about 1791 and Leeds need to considers if other sources back up. Historian can learn that industrialisation - by comparing with other sources.
Other sources - Birmingham not all places moved to machines - Samuel Schroeder machibe is being used for button making however a man is hoisting the weight and small boys are employed (p.87). This is in contrast to merchants wanting mechanised and work of men being taking over machines.
Worried about competition - Paisley 'spirit of manufacture' (p.88)- very succesful and Spitalfields London lost business, cheap labour (p.89) 1791/1799. Indicates industrialiaction in other areas . 'Inventicve spirit- . Using other spources - not isolated incident ivnetiveness growing willing to take a risk.
Merchants seem confident machines will not impact on workers. Howevere, in other areas - Coatridge, P.91 in Wales. Source published and bias view potentially for employment comission. But Mentions houses and gardens not being looked after - potentoially not enough time as long working conditions, children not at school. Population grown as people gone into cities for work. In source it doesn't give any info re living conditions of working people.
Limitations - only tell us when written can't cover whole period, only from ppint of view of Leeds merchants - good standard of living. Biased towards positive view of machine and keen to beat competition