Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Status of terms - Coggle Diagram
Status of terms
Innominate terms
Definition - Terms that are neither predefined as conditions nor warranties at the time of contract formation.
Core approach - The remedy depends on the actual legal effect and consequences of the breach, asking: Has the innocent party been deprived substantially of the whole benefit of the contract?
-
The Hong Kong Fir Case (1962) - A ship charter required the vessel to be seaworthy. The ship was unavailable for 18 weeks of a 2-year contract.
Held - The term was innominate, and since 18 weeks did not deprive the charterers of substantially the whole benefit, they could only claim damages, not terminate.
Reardon Smith Line v Yngvar Hansen-Tangen (1976) - A tanker's hull/yard number description differed, but the physical ship was identical to specifications.
Held - Innominate term; no substantial loss of benefit occurred, so termination was unjustified (damages only).
Conditions
Definition - A condition is a fundamental, major term that goes to the direct heart of the contract. Breaching a condition renders the contract meaningless.
Remedies for breach - Entitles the innocent party to the fullest range of remedies: repudiate (terminate) the contract and claim damages.
Poussard v Spiers and Pond (1876) - An opera singer was unable to attend the opening performances due to illness. Her performance was central to the production, making it a condition. The producers were legally entitled to terminate her contract and hire a replacement.
Warrenties
Definition - Warranties are minor, secondary, or ancillary terms. If broken, the main contract can still continue.
Remedies for breach - The sole remedy for a breach of warranty is claiming damages; the innocent party cannot repudiate the contract.
Bettini v Gye (1876) - A singer missed three days of pre-performance rehearsals due to illness. Attending rehearsals was ancillary to the main obligation of performing the show. The term was a warranty, so the producer was entitled to damages but could not terminate the contract.
Evaluation
-
Traditional Rigidity
Pre-classifying rigid conditions/warranties provides total commercial certainty up front, but can lead to unfair results if a trivial breach of a condition allows full termination.