Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Mid Tudors Economy: How accurate is it to say that England experienced and…
Mid Tudors Economy: How accurate is it to say that England experienced and economic and social crisis between 1533 and 1558?
LOA: It is highly accurate to claim that England experienced a significant economic and social crisis between 1533 and 1558. While there were strategic successes in global exploration and trade diversification, these were long-term gains that did little to alleviate the immediate domestic suffering. For the average person, the period was defined by a catastrophic drop in real wages, rampant inflation fueled by the "Great Debasement," and a series of subsistence-level harvest failures.
Failures
-
Social Distress, Enclosure, and Agriculture
The domestic economy was further strained by population growth and government mismanagement of land and social welfare, creating a "crisis" in the standard of living.
The Enclosure Problem: Somerset (under Edward VI) blamed "the selfish greed of enclosures" for social unrest
. He established a commission in 1548 to prevent enclosure and introduced a tax on sheep to deter the practice
. However, this backfired, creating severe financial pressure on small upland farmers who relied on sheep for subsistence
Harvest Failures: The mid-1550s under Mary I represented a peak in the crisis. 1555 saw a harvest failure, and 1556 was the worst harvest of the century due to heavy rain
. This led to a drastic rise in grain prices and necessitated law enforcement against grain hoarders
Vagrancy and Taxation: To combat the rising number of "vagrants" created by economic hardship, the 1547 Poor Law mandated slavery as a punishment for those refusing employment
. Additionally, high taxation to pay for wars against Scotland and France exacerbated the discontent of a population already struggling with a lower standard of living
-
Was it a Crisis?
The Argument for "Crisis": The period was a crisis in terms of domestic stability. The collapse of real wages, the failure of the 1556 harvest, and the relentless inflation caused by Henry VIII's debasement created a level of social misery that justifies the "crisis" label
The Argument Against "Crisis": From a strategic perspective, the government showed resilience. The transition from sluggish cloth exports to the formation of the Muscovy Company and African trade routes suggests an economy in a state of "transition" rather than total collapse
Final Verdict: While the foundations for the Elizabethan "Golden Age" were being laid through exploration, the immediate reality for the English people between 1533 and 1558 was one of undeniable economic and social crisis