Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
BELIEFS: significance of religion and religiosity in the contemporary…
BELIEFS: significance of religion and religiosity in the contemporary world
secularisation
WILSON
the process whereby religious thinking practices and institutions loose social significance
post-secularism
general notion that religion in the modern world is going to wein in significance
becoming less influential
MARX
opium, had the dream it would dissapear
WEBER
RATIONALISATION
suggests we begin to explain the world in ways other than religious ways (lean towards science)
post WW2, America saw growth (unscathed in WW2)
BURGER
to trace origins of secularisation, we can go back to protestant reformation
protestantism promotes individualism rather than collective vibes of religion
MLK, individuals have independent connection with god rather than a church body shaping connection
predominantly protestant Western societies second half of twentieth century religion becomes far more private, secularisation
less influence of religion on everyday life
still has role in explaining suffering
(WEBER)
how does religion remain despite secularisation?
US still religious
secularisation thesis suggests it is happening more in developed world
HOWEVER
BURGER
suggests that Western-Europe anomaly, everywhere else still quite religious-
POST-SECULARIST VIEW
descriptive
religiously pluralistic society
now less fundamentalist religious people, accept that other religions have different ways of explaining world
more tentative
this offers choices
e.g. moving religion, leaving religion
secular age- TAYLOR
religion far more optional rather than people just born into it
less 'cradle-catholics'
more people in the world recognise the golden arches than the christian cross
STATISTICS
from 2021 census
5% of the UK go to church twice a month or more
61 is the avg age of a church goer
37.2% england and wales non-religious
2200 churches closed between 2011 and 2021
self report, 2001 census JEDI 4th most popular religion in the UK
if we follow substantive definition of religion, appears UK much more secular HOWEVER not all religi
substantive definition suggests
UK becoming more secular
functional definition of religion
rejects secularisation as religion still exists in diff forms
difficulty measuring secularisation
declining church attendance often used however some people may be religious but not church attending for various reasons
religious commitment may not be external, praying at home or believing without belonging may occur
SECULARISATION HAS NOT OCCURED
HAMILTON 2001
increased religious commitment in the past may be illusion
focus more on the elites
less information on majority of population
may suggest that the past was no more or less religious than the present
restrictions on non religious behaviour on sundays
before trading laws relaxed in 1994 people had little option for activity on sunday
nowadays, people may believe but can't attend church e.g. work on sunday
individualism has increased
GLOCK AND STARK 1968
not enough detail into defining religion so secularisation cannot be accurately measured
evidence can often be used by different researchers for and against secularisation
MARTIN 1978
secularisation should be removed from sociology vocabulary, focus on change of religion instead
SECULARISATION HAS OCCURED
religion losing social authority, less influence over law e.g. same sex marriage legalised in UK in 2014
3% young people say religious, 70% no religion
secularisation in the usa
religion, renewal and choice
against secularisation
two main alternatives to secularisation theory:
theories of late and post modernity
religious market theory
DAVIE 2013
obligation to consumption
, in todays society church more personal choice than obligation
believing without belonging
, religion isn't declining, but becoming more privatised
people more reluctant to belong to organisations but still hold religious beliefs
now have
vicarious religion
which we use like a spiritual health service
minority religious practicing, majority experience religion second hand
people are able to use religion whenever they need
tip of the iceberg analogy- what we see at the top is a minority, but underneath are people who remain attached when needed but don't attend regularly
VOAS AND CROCKETT 2005
believing NOR belonging
evd shows decline in church attendance AND believing
BRUCE 2011
if people not willing to invest time in going to church, this is a reflection of the declining strength of their beliefs
people no longer belong
PM DAVID LYON
trad religion giving way to new age movement
HERVIEU-LEGER (2000)
SPIRITUAL SHOPPING
decline in religion due to cultural amnesia
children used to be taught religion by parents, church, extended family
religion handed down diminishing as this no longer happening
HOWEVER people have a choice to be consumers of religion- spiritual shopping
as a result, two new types of religion emerging
pilgrims follow an individual path in search for self discovery
converts join religious groups that offer a strong sense of belonging, usually based on shared ethnic background or religious doctrine
ALTHOUGH RELIGION NO LONGER ACTS AS SOURCE OF COLLECTIVE IDENTITY, IT INFLUENCES SOCIETY'S VALUES
THE KENDAL PROJECT
oct 2000 and june 2002, study into pop of kendal and modern societys approach to religion and spirituality
fill gaps in knowledge of religion in UK
secondary aim to use findings to test claims about contemporary religion, including idea that 'spiritual revolution' may be currently underway
post-modern religion
LYON 2000
agrees with
DAVIE
believes PM society has three features that change the nature of religion
traditional religion gives way to new age movements
MEDIA AND COMMS
internet creates great opportunities for religious organsiations and individuals to exploit
HELLAND
distinguishes ebtween two types of internet activity
RELIGION ONLINE
top down comms, no feedback or discussion and religious organisations use it to address members
communicating only approved ideas
ONLINE RELIGION
a form of cyber religion that may have no existence outside the internet, non-hierarchal relationships and a sense of comms to explore shared spiritual interests and provide mutual support
while PM see online religion as a radical new alternative that replaces original religion, most users use this for supplememtns to going to the churhc
CONSUMERISM
PM society involves growth of consumerism and the idea we now construct our identities through what we choose to consume
religion has moved to the sphere of consumption
people haven't stopped religion, but just become 'religious consumers' where they can make conscious choices of elements they find useful
GLOBALISATION
now have access to ideas and beliefs from previously remote places and religions
religious ideas have become disembedded
as a result religion becomes de-institiutionalised, removed from their original location in the church
religious ideas become a cultural resource that individuals can adapt
WEAKNESS OF THE NEW AGE
STEVE BRUCE
the problem of the scale
even if new age forms of individualised religion are springing up, would have to be on much larger scale if it is to fill the gap left by the decline of traditional religions
religious market theory
STARK AND BAINBRIDGE 1986
critical of secularisation theoyr and view it as eurocentric
ignores strength of religion in everywhere but europe
1)
people naturally religious and religion meets human needs
overall demand for religion remains constant, even though thedemand for particualr types of religion may vary
2)
human nature to seek rewards and avoid costs
when people ake cjoices, they weigh uo costs and benefits of differnent options available
compensators
religion is attractive because it provides us with compensators when real rewards are scarce or unnattainable
religion compensates by offering supernatural rewards
cycle of renewal
decline>revival>renewal
can be seen throughout history, with some religions declining and others growing and attracting new members
e.g.
when established churches decline, leave a gap in the market for sects and cults to attract new followers
religious competition
churches run like a company selling goods in the market
comp leads to improvements in the quality of religious goods on ofer
SUPPLY LED RELIGION
america VS europe- supply not demand
demand for religion increases when there are different sorts to choose from
in contrast, where there is religious monopoly (one church w no comp), it leads to decline
with no comp, church has no insentive to provide people with what they want
europe
most dominated by official state church e.g. church of england with religious monopoly
competetion has been held back and the lack of choice has led to decline
USA
religion thrives as there has never been religious monopoly there
constitution guarantees freedom or religion and the separation of church and state
encourages the growth of a healthy religious market where religions grow or decline depending on consumer demand
FINKE 1997
lifting of restrictions on asian immigration into america in the 1950s led to asian faiths becoming another option that proved popular with consumers in the religious market place
HADDEN AND SHUPE 1988
rise in televangelism in america shows that religious participation is supply led
it opened up competition between evangelist groups
MILLER 1997
compared evangelical mega-churches found in America and South Korea to hypermarkets
with such large congregations they have more resources so are able to offer a vast range of activities to meet the diverse needs of their members
religion in a global context
fundamentalism- ALMOND ET AL
a pattern of religious militancy by which self-styled true believers attempt to arrest the erosion of religious identity and create viable alternatives to secular institutions and behaviour
often seen as a response to secularisation-
BRUCE
New Christian Right
Al Qaeda
CHARACTERISTICS OF FUNDAMENTALISM
conspiracy theories
scriptural literalism
patriarchy
GIDDENS
fundamentalism is both a prodcut of and reaction to modenrity
religious orthodoxy is challenged by the manner in which modern societies undermine traditional world views
BRUCE- two types of fundamentalism
FIRST WORLD/WEST
= changes within e.g. gay marriage, gender equality, causes rise of fundamentalist movements
THIRD WORLD/EAST
= existential threat from outside e.g. modernisation/globalisation, causes rise of fundamentalism
DAVIE- secular fundamentalism
SECULAR FUNDAMENTALISM
- the pushing of secular values onto others with the zeal of a religious zealot
reaction to late contemporary society as religious fundamentalism
world breaking into categories of us vs them
TRUMP "with us or against us
FIRST PHASE
- religious fundamentalism
from the enlightnement to 1980s
secularises all areas of social life- fundamentalism one response
SECOND PHASE-
secular fundamentalism
people pessimistic and anti-religion
so extreme secularisation e.g. france banning religious clothing
cosmopolitanism- GIDDENS and CASTELL
GIDDENS
cosmopolitanism is the product of globalisation, the process opens us up to new ideas, people, tastes etc
contemporary beliefs and spirituality are more about personal journey than collective worship
belief about self-improvement rather than getting to heaven
CASTELLS
post-modernity produces two types of responses
resistance identity
defensive reaction of those who feel threatened
retreat into fundamentalist communities
project identity
the response of those who are forward looking and engage with social movements
HUNTINGTON: THE CLASH OF CIVILISATIONS
globalisation has rendered nationality a meaningless concept
countries across the world breaking up
people are looking for new identities- religious ones
religion has played a part in many global conflicts
9/11 terrorist attacks in the US
identifies 7 civilisations: western, islamic, slavic-orthodox, latin american, confucian, japanese and hindu
each shared cultural history
globalisation has made nation-states less important as a source of identity, creating a gap religion has filled
also globalisation increases contact between civilisations, increasing likelihood of conflict
JACKSON 2006
example of orientalism, western ideology that stereotypes eastern nations and people (esp muslims) as intrustworth, inferior or fanatical 'others'
CASANOVA 2005
huntington's view is simplistic and ignores important religious dicisiions within civilisations he defines such as sunni and shi'a with muslims