Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Chapter 12: Reading, Summarizing, and Critiquing - Coggle Diagram
Chapter 12: Reading, Summarizing, and Critiquing
12.1 Content of a Scientific Research Article
Essential Information: When reading, you must be able to identify four key things: the overall purpose, the experimental approach, the key results, and the significance of the work
The Standard Structure
Introduction: Provides background and introduces the specific problem or "unknown"
Materials and Methods: Highly technical details on how the study was conducted
Abstract: A mini-summary covering the research question, approach, and significance
Results: Delineates all findings, often starting with the most important results
Discussion: Interprets the key findings and their significance, often pointing toward future studies
References: Cite your sources
12.2 Reading a Research Paper
The Directed Way: Instead of reading from start to finish, read the Abstract, Introduction, and Conclusion first to ensure you don't miss the core message
Full Understanding: After the initial overview, reread the entire paper, taking notes on unfamiliar terminology and looking closely at the figures
12.3 Writing a Summary of a Research Paper
Definition: A summary is essentially an expanded version of the Abstract written in your own words
The Five Step Outline
Describe the key findings
Discuss the meaning of those findings
Explain the experimental approach
Conclude with the overall impact and relevance of the study
Describe the main question or purpose
12.4 Critiquing a Research Paper
The Goal: Unlike a summary, a critique evaluates the work, highlighting both the strengths and weaknesses of the research, presentation, and interpretation
Critical Quesitons
Methods: Were appropriate procedures and measurements used?
Results: Were all controls met? Are figures and tables explained clearly?
Introduction: Is the purpose clearly stated? Are the ideas original?
Discussion: Does the work make an important contribution to the field?