Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Skirrid Hill- 'Sheers presents romantic relationships as utterly…
Skirrid Hill- 'Sheers presents romantic relationships as utterly doomed'
THESIS: In Skirrid Hill, romantic relationships are shown as doomed because love is repeatedly undermined by lack of communication.
'Valentine'
Evidence of romantic relationships being utterly doomed as expectations of 'Valentine's Day'.
Lack of communication shown by emotional distance.
Sex= desperate attempt to save their relationship.
'water torture of your heels'
Click of the heels is torturous to him (water torture- more frequent, more painful- implies she has left him before). Shows that their relationship is doomed.
He feels her departure as a physical pain- she has the power, walking away- or he has the power + she is prey.
Link to 'The Farrier'
'The sound of his steel, biting at her heels'
Sequel to 'show'- shows consequence of superficial relationship.
Focuses on lust- futility and superficiality of relationship.
'curve of your hip'
Focuses on her curves + clothes
'holding each other on the hotel bed like a pair of wrecked voyagers'
Attempted to save their relationship by having sex rather than communicating
'That my valentine, will be the one I'll keep'
He's learnt that a relationship will never last is it's only superficial and sexual- such as if romance is only showed on Valentine's day. It is superficial.
'Winter Swans'
'silent and apart' immediately establishes emotional distance and failure to communicate. Breakdown in communication.
The pathetic fallacy mirrors their silence- 'the clouds had given their all'- emotional depletion between the couple, nothing left to say
The waterlogged earth suggests suffocation, mirroring how unspoken tension overwhelms the relationship.
'gulping for breath'
The swans' in-sync movement contrasts sharply with the couple's disunity, highlighting what the relationship lacks.
'tipping in unison'
Swans instinctively cooperate without speech, implying natural, effortless communication the humans cannot achieve.
The speaker notes 'you said' followed by 'I didn't reply', directly foregrounding failed verbal communication at a crucial moment.
The statement 'they mate for life' carriers ironic weight, drawing attention to the fragility of the speaker's own relationship.
The silence after this life creates tension, suggesting avoidance rather than resolution.
The couple's 'slow-stepping' implies hesitation and emotional uncertainty rather than progress.
Reconciliation occurs without words- communication has regressed to basic physical contact.
'our hands...folded'
The simile 'like a pair of wings settling after flight' suggests calm after conflict, but only temporary- relationship is doomed.
Supported by fact that the poem ends without dialogue or resolution, implying the underlying issues remain unresolved.
Sheers suggests that without sustained communication, moments of closeness are fragile- supporting the idea that relationships are ultimately doomed rather than secure.
'Show'
Performance over communication
The relationship is based on looking and being looked at, not speaking, so connection is superficial.
'the models walk'
Objectification blocks understanding
focus on appearance- reduces her to image rather than voice
'high-heeled as curlews'
Observation over interaction- 'we watch' shows passive spectatorship instead of active communication
Emotional distance and separation
She 'slip[s] between the curtains' symbolising missed connection and lack of intimacy
Illusion instead of honesty
'the spell, the artful hocus-pocus'
suggests that relationship is built on fantasy, making it unsustainable.
Paragraph-by-paragraph plan
P1: Valentine- Evidence of romantic relationships being utterly doomed as expectations of 'Valentine's Day'.
P2: Winter Swans- Sheers suggests that without sustained communication, moments of closeness are fragile- supporting the idea that relationships are ultimately doomed rather than secure.
P3: Show- Performance over communication.