Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Voice Controversy Essay - Coggle Diagram
Voice Controversy Essay
Employee Voice
The ways and means through which workers seek to have a say and potentially influence organisational affairs that affect their interests
-
-
Employee influence
a range of mechanisms which enable and at time empower employees, directly and indirectly, to contribute to decision-making in the firm
-
-
-
Power, frames of reference, contested institutions of voice
-
Frames of reference
Unitarist
-
tend to prefer direct, management-designed voice such as suggestion schemes, team briefings and surveys
-
Voice is controversial because these frames clash over how much say workers deserve and whether independent institutions are legitimate partners or unwelcome constraints.
Trade unions
-
Continuous associations of workers who join together to maintain or improve their pay, conditions and working lives.
They play a voice role (representing workers individually in grievances and collectively in consultations and committees) and an economic role by negotiating pay and conditions through collective bargaining
Collective Bargaining
negotiation between unions and employers (or employer associations) where the outcome is not known in advance
Through bargaining, unions can influence wages, working time, job security and the wider wage–effort bargain, helping defend the frontier of control for their members.
Decline of union density and the rise of “anti-voice” strategies, including union-busting and outright refusal to recognise unions, as in Amazon’s multi-million-dollar campaigns against warehouse unionisation in the USA
-
New Trajectories
Wilkinson et al. (2021)
Digitalisation, new business models and diversified workforces change how work is organised and challenge employee rights and responsibilities, while at the same time threatening traditional forms of voice
poor upward communication and weak social dialogue can undermine sustainable organisational development and raise societal concerns about human dignity and worker rights
Voice has become even more controversial as contemporary social, economic and technological (SET) developments reshape work
Gig Economy
Platform-based, often precarious work (e.g. Uber, Deliveroo) where tasks are allocated through apps and employment status is often ambiguous
Platform work mediated by apps such as Uber introduces algorithmic management and opaque rating systems; Uber can deactivate drivers whose customer scores fall below a threshold, effectively dismissing them without conventional procedures
In response, the App Drivers and Couriers Union (ADCU) has used legal action to demand algorithmic transparency, arguing that drivers need access to the data on which their livelihoods depend
-
Hotel chambermaids in Spain formed their own union, Las Kellys, and created a booking platform that lists only hotels complying with agreed standards on pay and conditions
Gig and outsourced workers experimenting with new forms of collective voice outside traditional firm-level arrangements, precisely because standard channels are absent
Fissured Workplace
-
-
Provides flexibility and cost advantages but creates new challenges for law and for traditional voice institutions
Wilkinson et al. (2021) similarly note that outsourcing and global supply chains often marginalise unions and restrict configurations of worker voice in low-cost geographies