Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
10.0. Financial Reporting Quality - Coggle Diagram
10.0. Financial Reporting Quality
Distinguish between FS quality and quality of reported results
Reporting quality
High quality financial reporting must be decisioin useful
Characteristic
Relevance
Infor presented in the FS is
useful
to users in making decisions. Revelant infor must also be
material
in that knowledge of it would likely affect the decisions of users of FS
Faithful representation
The qualities of completeness, neutrality, and the absence of errors
Earnings quality
Earning quality can be judged based on the
sustainability
of the earnings as well as on their
level
Characteristic
Sustainability
Sustainability can be evaluated by determining the proportion of reported earnings that can be expected to continue in the future
Level of earnings
The importance of the level of earnings is that reported earnings must be high enough to sustain the firm's operations and existence
Effect on evaluation of company value
Low
LOW
financial reporting => BỎ LUÔN, ko đánh giá tiếp
High
HIGH
financial reporting
HIGH
earning quality => increases company value
HIGH
financial reporting
LOW
earnings quality => decrease company value
A spectrum for assessing financial reporting quality
GAAP: decision-useful, sustainable, and adequate returns
GAAP: decision-useful, but sustainable? Low "earnings quallity"
Within GAAP, but biased choices
Within GAAP, but "earnings management" (EM)
Real EM
Accounting EM
Bỏ
Non-compliant Accounting
Fictitious transactions
Conservative and aggressive accounting
Conservative choice
Decrease the firm's reported perfoemance and financial position in current period
Increase the amount of debt reported on the BS
Decrease the amount of revenues, earnings and/or operaring cash flow
Hạn chế và Lợi ích
Drawbacks
Conflicts with the concept of Neutrality
Benefits
Reducing the possibility of litigation (kiện tụng)
Reducing current period tax liability
Reducing the interests of those who have less complete information
Aggressive choice
Increase firm's performance and financial position
Inflate the amount of revenues, earnings and/or operating cash flow
Decrease the amount of expenses reported in the period and/or the amount of debt on the BS
Hạn chế và lợi ích
Accounting bias / Phương pháp và chiêu trò để manipulate FS
Earnings smoothing
Big bath behabior
Presentation choices: dùng non-GAAP/ pro forma earnings (thường loại trừ chi phí bất lợi)
ảnh hưởng dòng tiền: kéo dài phải trả, phân loại dòng tiền (CFO mà ghi CFI)
Motivation
Question to consider whether FS is fraudulent
(1). Whether the reporting encivronment is conductive to misreporting?
(2). Whether a company's management may be motivated to issee financial reports that are not high quality?
Opportunity
weak internal controls
The BOD provides inadequate oversight
Applicable accounting standards provide a large range of acceptable accounting treatments
Motivation
• Mask poor performance
• Boost the stock price
• Increase personal compensationa
• Avoid violation of debt covenants
Increase the probability of exceeding next period’s forecasts
• Meet or beat expectations
Rationalization
4 yếu tố giúp FS minh bạch hơn
Markets
Auditors
Private Contract
Regulatory authorities
Presentation
GAAP requirement for non-GAAP presentation
G
• Display the most comparable GAAP measure with equal prominence
• Provide an explanation by management as to why the non-GAAP measure is thought to be useful.
• Reconcile the differences between the non-GAAP measure and the most comparable GAAP measure.
• Disclose other purposes for which the firm uses the non-GAAP measure.
• Include, in any non-GAAP measure, any items that are likely to recur in the future, even those treated as nonrecurring, unusual, or infrequent in the FS
IFRS requirement for non-IFRS presentation
Define and explain the relevance of such non-IFRS measure
• Reconcile the differences between the non-IFRS measure and the most comparable IFRS measure
Accounting choices and estimate
(có thể dùng để gian dối)
(1) Revenue Recognition
(2) Estimates of credit losses
(3) Valuation allowance
(4) Depreciation methods and estimates
(5) Amortization and impairment
(6) Inventory method
(7) Capitalization
(8) Related-party transactions
(9) Other Cash flow effects
Warning signs
Related to Capitalization Policies and Deferred Costs
Relationship between Cash flow and income
Other Potential Warning signs