Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Is flipping effective? (Gang Zhu 2024) - Coggle Diagram
Is flipping effective? (Gang Zhu 2024)
Study Objectives
Effect of FI on academic achievement in K-12
Extent of effectiveness across 27 studies
Factors that influence effectiveness
Review of cross-disciplinary implementation
STEM: Positive effects on problem-solving and active learning
Humanities / Social Sciences: less pronounced effects than STEM
Arts and PE: Difficult to implement in performance-based learning
Benefits
Academic achievement: moderate increase (d = 0.54; "medium" impact) over traditional instruction
Engagement and motivation: active student involvement in learning
Effective use of in-class time: higher-order thinking, cooperative learning, hands-on kinesthetic activities
Individualized instruction: students review and learn at their own pace outside of class
Relationships / connection: personalized interaction between teacher and student
Challenges
Students
Requires self-direction / motivation
Preference toward traditional learning methods
Teachers
Requires extensive resource preparation
Additional training on implementation technologies
Preference toward traditional teaching methods
Technology
Unequal access outside of school (devices, internet)
Institutional infrastructure: internet, learning platforms
Study Methods
Inclusion criteria
K-12
Assessments: teacher designed or standardized tests
Data analysis: compared FI and traditional instruction results
Data collection
27 distinct studies
Effect size calculated using Hedges' g
Variability minimized through random-effects models
Influence of various factors assessed
Study findings
Improved K-12 academic performance; d = 0.54 implies moderate positive gains over traditional instruction
High variation in effectiveness
Greater impact in middle and high grades
Greater impact in STEM areas
Higher quality studies showed more reliable results
Longer LI implementation produced more significant improvements
Key Takeaways
Schools need clear guidelines for FI implementation
Teachers need training in FI resource production (videos) and active learning strategies
Students need personalized resources (tutoring, educational plans) and access to technology