Please enable JavaScript.

Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.

Section 2 Themes, Nietzsche believed that it is the responsibility of the…

- - - - ensures balance—when reason rules, the spirited part obeys, and the appetites are disciplined
    - - is sustained by
        
        Hope
        
        was left in
        
        Pandora's box
        
        False hope (Nietzsche) vs grounded hope (Frankl)
      - fuelled by
        
        passion
        
        helps us stay committed to our purpose, especially when it's hard to do so.
        
        with passion, our purpose becomes a calling, without it, purpose risks becoming an obligation
      - The will to uphold reason’s guidance, even in the face of fear or pain.
    - - The moderation of desires; when the appetites submit to reason.
    - - exemplified by
        
        Plato's allegory of the cave
      - The ability to reason well, make sound judgments, and guide the soul.
  - - - shows up as
        
        Arrogance, narcissism
        
        toxic masculinity
        
        Populism, with its emphasis on strongman leadership, confrontation, and traditional gender norms, often acts as a cultural amplifier of toxic masculinity — promoting dominance, emotional repression, and aggressive masculinity as political virtues.
        
        the name has created a sense shame to be masculine
        
        many people unsure what it means to be masculine
        
        Opportunistic people, like Andrew Tait, can influence confused people
        
        contemptuous masculinity - being better, being superior, being unworthy of acknowledgement
        
        Echo and Narcissus
      - Icarus
      - Vanity
        
        fashion
        
        as a Form of Self-Curation via
        
        becomes a tool for constructing a personal brand rather than expressing authentic identity. The result is a culture in which appearance is not only public but performative, reinforcing external validation over inner values.
        
        aesthetic relocation of identity
  - - - First recognize which part of your soul tends to dominate, then discipline the lower parts through education, habit, and philosophical reflection—so that reason governs and harmony follows
        
        “Know thyself” (aware of flaws) → Discipline thyself (living with integrity) → Rule thyself wisely (living by reason, not by base desires).
    - - The shift from appetitive to spirited is like being shaken awake—painful but transformative
      - the pursuit of admiration replaces the pursuit of virtue.
    - - growing into yourself—slow, deep, and stabilising
  - - - encourages
        
        finding a middle ground between deficiency and excess
        
        EG
        
        Authenticity
        
        as a virtue lying between deceit and arrogance.
        
        Anger and Justice
        
        A protestor who speaks out calmly and consistently against injustice shows virtue (righteous indignation). But someone who either stays silent (deficiency) or resorts to violence (excess) strays from the mean
      - Aristotle believed we become virtuous through practice and conscious habituation, guided by reason and the pursuit of the Golden Mean (balance between extremes).
  - - - confront our assumptions, fostering deeper critical thinking and intellectual humility
        
        aligns with
        
        'Know thyself'—a call to examine the complexities of human nature. By questioning our beliefs and desires, we come to better understand the contradictions, impulses, and potential for virtue within ourselves.
        
        Without self-awareness, it is impossible to consciously direct one’s life; we may appear to make choices, but without understanding ourselves, those choices are guided not by autonomy, but by habit, fear, or social conditioning
  - - - a concept rooted in Eastern philosophy and Hinduism, emphasises discovering one’s purpose through introspection and alignment with one’s true nature. It encourages individuals to look inward, rather than be swayed by external noise or societal expectations
        
        in contrast to
        
        In contrast, Western ideals — particularly among youth influenced by social media — often equate purpose with pleasure or passion. But these are frequently shaped by trends, validation, and comparison, rather than authentic self-understanding. What feels like a calling may in fact be a craving — externally inspired rather than internally realised.
    - - challenges
        
        binary thinking. It reminds us that opposites are interdependent: joy and sorrow, strength and vulnerability, success and failure. One gives meaning to the other. Rather than resisting the 'negative,' Taoism invites us to see value in all experiences.
  - - - performative masculinity
      - shift from values to external - tattoos and muscles
        
        aesthetic relocation of value to appearance
        
        due to
        
        shift from collectivist values (serving family, nation, or community) to individualist values (self-expression, personal success, and identity performance).
        
        shift from shared duty to personal branding
      - William James, Philosopher and Psychologist, War is morally problematic, but it brings out virtues that are essential for the moral health of a society
        
        a way to train toughness, loyalty, and a sense of duty.
        
        Peaceful societies tend to become soft, self-indulgent, and overly focused on comfort and individualism
        
        Therefore, if war is to be abolished, we must find a “moral equivalent” to war—non-violent ways to cultivate the same stoic and heroic virtues.
        
        Rites of passage, nation building, army service - ways to force our youth to put the group above themselves
  - - - Epictetus: “If you want to improve, be content to be thought foolish and stupid.”
        
        Your worth is determined by your character and choices, not by the opinions of others
    - - we should concern ourselves only with what lies within our power — our thoughts, actions, and character — and accept all else with equanimity
        
        echos
        
        they echo Socrates’ call to ‘know thyself’, Plato’s ideal of reason ruling the soul, and Aristotle’s vision of flourishing through virtue (eudaimonia)
        
        Epictetus wrote, “It’s not things that upset us, but our judgments about things.”
        
        “It’s not what happens to you, but how you react that matters” by Epictetus
        
        radical accountability
    - - internal locus of control by teaching us to take full ownership of our thoughts and actions.
        
        It’s about freedom through responsibility, and peace through rational detachment from what we cannot change.
        
        means taking responsibility for one’s life by focusing solely on what is within one’s power—thoughts, decisions, and reactions. It is a mindset that fosters resilience, accountability, and personal growth.
  - - - You become who you are through your choices
- - - - Plato's Allegory of the cave
  - - - becomes
        
        social capital
      - via algorithmic amplification
        
        Aesthetic conformity
      - in contrast to
        
        Wabi-sabi
        
        beauty in imperfection
      - Pierre Bourdieu, French sociologist, Beauty becomes a form of symbolic capital—something that grants influence and status. Just as wealth or education can buy access, beauty online garners likes, followers, and opportunities.
      - People are attracted to beauty
        
        Plato argued that beauty evokes desire because it hints at a deeper, ideal truth. Physical beauty becomes a powerful draw because it gestures toward perfection. In today’s context, our instinctive pull toward beauty is primal—yet platforms hijack it.
        
        evolutionary aesthetics
        
        While not strictly philosophy, evolutionary theory overlaps here: symmetrical faces and certain body types signal health and fertility. Philosophers like David Hume also note that judgments of beauty often rest on deeply ingrained, shared human responses.
      - Martin Heidegger's concept of "enframing" explains
        
        how social media “enframes" human beings as content. We manage ourselves—our faces, bodies, lives—as resources to be optimized. Beauty becomes a performance, not for art or self-expression, but for algorithmic approval.
      - Jean-Jacques Rousseau, philosopher, Amour-propre – a social, artificial self-love
        
        In a society of comparisons, we start needing external approval to feel worthy. Amour-propre makes us crave admiration. Social media quantifies admiration, pushing us to mould ourselves into its rewarded image—often unrealistic, but algorithmically validated
        
        requiring external validation for our sense of self worth
        
        sacrificing authenticity for approval
        
        opposing
        
        Socrates "Know Thyself"
        
        deeply inflamed by
        
        consumerism
        
        Status through possessions
        
        Endless comparison
        
        Insatiable desire
        
        Dependence on external validation
        
        slaves to public opinion
        
        driving people to seek worth through possessions, appearances, and curated identity
      - Social media platforms exploit our deep-seated attraction to beauty (Plato, Hume), convert it into symbolic capital (Bourdieu), and amplify it through algorithms that reward conformity (Heidegger). As social comparison (Rousseau) kick in, users begin to imitate and internalise these unrealistic standards, making them feel not just desirable—but necessary. Thus, the system doesn’t just show beauty—it reshapes our idea of what beauty should be.
  - - - the domination of
    - - Aspirational identification is when someone models themselves on others they admire
        
        positive when
        
        inspires growth, learning, or resilience
        
        when driven by ego validation—trying to gain approval, status, or feel superior
        
        becomes shallow, performative, and unsustainable.
  - - - erodes
        
        relationships, transforming them into transactional arrangements focused on personal gain over mutual support.
  - - - "social atrophy"
  - - - Authenticity should serve as a bridge—inviting connection, understanding, and trust. But when wielded without empathy or self-awareness, it becomes a weapon—used to assert dominance, express unchecked ego, or mask arrogance as honesty
        
        when weaponised
- - - - The initial argument that Marx must have thought that capitalism is unjust is based on the observation that he argued that all capitalist profit is ultimately derived from the exploitation of the worker.
  - - - leads to
        
        Populism
        
        Trump
        
        Kamala stands for they and them, Donald trump stands for you
        
        Drain the swamp
        
        Used during his 2016 presidential campaign.
        
        He used it to suggest that Washington, D.C. was full of corrupt politicians, lobbyists, and bureaucrats — and he promised to remove them and return power to the people.
        
        Confrontational language - "bad guy", "weird"
        
        After losing the 2020 election, Trump refused to concede, promoting false claims of fraud instead of acknowledging loss. * This reflects an unwillingness to show vulnerability or accept failure
        
        Moves like changing tariffs or undoing previous policies often reflect a desire to reassert power rather than pragmatic governance
        
        described as
        
        "Horse loose in a hospital" - John Mulaney
        
        credulous, emotive, resentful, uneducated, uninformed mass turn to charismatic leader that can represent them - turns populism into a variation of despotism
        
        Oversimplification of issues
        
        Migrants are coming to take our jobs - populism view. Intuitively feels correct, but doesn't take into account all the variables.
        
        The slogan ‘Four legs good, two legs bad’ from Orwell’s Animal Farm exemplifies the dangers of oversimplifying complex issues into binary oppositions. It reduces nuanced political, ethical, and social dynamics into a black-and-white narrative, which is a common tactic in populist rhetoric
        
        promotes
        
        supports
        
        Nationalism
        
        when militarised
        
        honor is used not just to reward, but to recruit and restrain.
  - - - promises
        
        Happiness
        
        West
        
        Bad is a means to a good end
        
        "Take the good with the bad"
        
        East
        
        flow with good and bad (Yin and Yang)
      - prioritises
        
        Comfort and convenience
        
        hedonic treadmill
      - in contrast to
        
        Buddhism
        
        Inner peace vs endless consumption
        
        the perpetual desire for more, better and new things is a source of suffering, not satisfaction
        
        weathered and wrinkled
        
        textured and porous
      - fuels
      - pleasure economy
      - shiny new things
        
        New things dazzle with their sheen, reflecting the world without truly knowing it. Old things, by contrast, have absorbed the world—they are etched with stories, worn by use, and steeped in memory.”
- - - - Erich Fromm, a social psychologist, argued that we have shifted from “being” to “having” as the basis of identity in modern life.
  - - - Modern liberalism
        
        Massively expanded state power
        
        facilitates
        
        Equitability (public schools, housing etc)
        
        provides the framework to pursue
        
        Humanitarianism
        
        1 more item...
        
        Equitability is central to modern liberalism because it transforms freedom from a privilege of the few into a right for all. It ensures that liberty, opportunity, and dignity are not just theoretical ideals, but lived experiences—especially for those starting from disadvantage.
        
        structural disadvantage (long standing barriers in society) and individual disadvantage (personal conditions)
        
        grounded in
        
        Kantian Ethics
        
        1 more item...
        
        Sir Michael Marmot, epidemiologist and public health expert: "do something, do more, do better" and “Why treat people and send them back to the conditions that made them sick?”
        
        through
        
        Social Contract theory
        
        Philosophers like Thomas Hobbes argued that without some form of government or authority with enough control, human life would be chaotic and violent—what he famously called a “state of nature,” which would be “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.”
        
        Hobbes believed the social contract was essential to escape the brutal state of nature.
        
        underpins
        
        democracy’s ability to implement positive freedom and equity by framing state intervention not as coercion, but as a mutual agreement to promote collective well-being and individual flourishing.
        
        aims to
        
        legitimise authority, protect rights, promote justice and the common good, and create a stable society where individuals can flourish — especially through collective agreements that prioritise equity and security.
        
        1 more item...
        
        paternalistic decision making
        
        can slide into control
        
        “If you don't want a man unhappy politically, don't give him two sides to a question to worry him; give him one. Better yet, give him none.”
        — Ray Bradbury, Fahrenheit 451
        
        too much governent power
        
        Neoliberalism
        
        eroded trust in government
        
        Lockdowns
        
        believes
        
        it is both ethically right (moral) and a key role of government (political imperative) to ensure all individuals have access to the conditions necessary for self-development—starting with the satisfaction of basic needs such as food (physiological), safety, and belonging, as outlined in Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs, and progressing toward higher-level goals like self-esteem and self-actualisation.
        
        Freedom to flourish - positive freedom
  - - - supported by
        
        Free will
        
        Compatibilism
        
        Practical freedom - You’re free if you act voluntarily, even though your desires are shaped by life, culture, biology, etc.
        
        within the confines of
      - in contrast to
        
        Determinism
- - - - Economic activity increasingly exploded the confines of local communities to a degree that would have stunned our historical predecessors, for example, while the steamship, railroad, automobile, and air travel considerably intensified rates of geographical mobility.
  - - - Big Tech, GAFAM (Google, Amazon, Facebook, Apple, Microsoft)
- - - - The credit theory of money
        
        Money is essentially a promise or IOU—a form of credit. Its value comes from social trust, not from a physical object.
        
        Fiat currency
    - - Bitcoin
  - - - Selfishness and Greed, morally suspect
- - - - The ideal first step to learning
        
        when you have epistemic humility, you are open to new knowledge and correction
        
        sparks curiosity
        
        Removing your ego gives way to honest self-assessment
        
        this is where metacognition begins - thinking about your thinking
        
        “You can't fill a cup that's already full.”
- - - - Automation vs Augmentation
    - - automation of data driven and repetitive tasks
        
        still be a need for skills AI can't replicate - empathy, judgement, in person communication
        
        in the future
        
        social and communication skills will be in high demand
- - - - expressed by
        
        communism
        
        the state eventually "withers" away and everyone manages things collectively
        
        in reality
        
        “There are no solutions—only trade-offs.” – Economist Thomas Sowell
        
        n China, the pursuit of social unity and cohesion has created a tightly controlled society, one in which dissent is discouraged and conformity is valued. While this may foster stability and national strength, the trade-off is significant: such cohesion can be exploited by those in power, allowing the leadership to benefit economically—sometimes at the expense of the very population they claim to serve.
        
        why?
        
        3 more items...
        
        “All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.” – Animal Farm
        
        socialism
        
        bridges the gap between capitalism and
        
        “the dictatorship of the proletariat”
        
        in reality becomes
        
        "the dictatorship over the proletariat", eg The Chinese Revolution of 1949 and the Chinese Communist Party
      - Manners
        
        Ralph Waldo Emerson, Good manners are made up of petty sacrifices
        
        decline due to
        
        Egalitarianism & Anti-Hierarchy
        
        informality or disrespect being seen as signs of equality.
        
        Expressivism & Therapeutic Culture
        
        Emotional expression > social restraint
        
        results in
        
        Politeness is viewed as repression, and bluntness as authenticity.
        
        Consumerism & Instrumental Relationships
        
        In a market-driven society, interactions become transactional: "What can you do for me?"
        Manners lose relevance when efficiency, speed, and productivity matter more than civility.
        
        People as means, not ends
- - - - Truthful information
      - Civic solidarity
        
        refers to
        
        shared responsibility, mutual respect, and common purpose
      - Trust in institutions
        
        Trust is the foundation upon which all other democratic norms rest.** When people stop believing in the legitimacy of courts, elections, or parliaments, they disengage or turn to populists who promise shortcuts—often at the expense of justice and liberty.
    - - Pluralism & tolerance:
      - Rule of law:
      - Participation
        
        ensures
        
        democratic accountability
        
        policy and legislation reflect the needs and voices of the broader population, not just those of the most influential or powerful groups
        
        such as
        
        To address rising living costs, the Victorian government introduced a policy to improve rental affordability. This was enforced through legislation limiting rent increases to once per year. The law turns policy into action, creating a more stable and predictable rental market for renters.
        
        Active citizenship—voting, protesting, engaging.
      - Reason & deliberation
      - Equity
        
        Recognises unequal starting points; makes freedom real in practice
      - Equality
        
        Equal moral worth and political voice.
      - Freedom
        
        preserved through
        
        Protected Freedoms
        
        Freedom of speech
        
        Freedom from arbitrary detention
        
        Right to vote
        
        Freedom of association
        
        Freedom of religion
        
        Freedom of the press
        
        split into
        
        Positive freedom: real opportunity to pursue potential.
        
        Linked to Maslow: basic needs (safety, belonging) must be met for self-actualisation.
        
        Through democratic participation, citizens are not only free from oppression, but free to pursue education, expression, and opportunity — the essence of what philosopher Isaiah Berlin termed positive freedom.
        
        Negative freedom: freedom from interference.
        
        The Harm Principle — John Stuart Mill
        
        balances freedom with responsibility. It argues that individuals should be left alone unless their actions cause harm to others. This principle underpins modern debates on issues ranging from freedom of speech to public health, reminding us that liberty is not limitless—it ends where it endangers others.
    - - Horizontal Patriotism
        
        Albanese "progressive patriotism"
        
        in contrast to
        
        Nationalism
        
        Belief in the superiority and dominance of one’s nation
        
        Vertical patriotism
        
        Patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel.” – Samuel Johnson
        
        weaponized to mask self-interest and suppress moral scrutiny
        
        obedience to authority or symbols of the state
        
        loyalty rooted in
        
        solidarity with fellow citizens and democratic values
    - - when people want to be free to pursue whatever they like, without constraint. This reflects the appetitive soul, which seeks pleasure, comfort, and self-indulgence.
        
        it's a regime of unrestrained liberty." – Republic, Book VIII
    - - Social Justice
        
        From the 19th-century women’s suffrage movement through mid-20th-century civil rights and late-20th-century gay rights activism, social justice has evolved to embrace identity politics, which highlights the intersecting and diverse experiences of marginalized groups.
        
        it's symbolic backbone
        
        Martyrs
        
        Nietzsche for existential freedom and chaos. (1844–1900) - went mad
        
        Galileo for scientific truth, (1564–1642) - house arrest
        
        Jesus for spiritual salvation, (c. 4 BCE – 30/33 CE) - crucified
        
        Socrates for rational questioning, (c. 470–399 BCE) - voluntarily drank poison after sentenced to death
        
        Know Thyself
        
        🧠 “The unexamined life is not worth living.”
        
        Socratic method
        
        Indigenous rights
        
        Dreamtime stories - “Wikipedia of the outback”
        
        reduce/reuse/recycle vs “respect/reconnect/replenish”
        
        Posthumanism - Recognizes intelligence, agency, or value in animals, machines, or ecosystems.
        
        Human exceptionalism
        
        Nelson Mandela: Spent 27 years in prison for fighting against apartheid in South Africa. His personal life, including his relationships and freedom, was sacrificed for the greater good.
        
        Adam Goodes
        2013 spoke out against racism during a footy game. As a consequence was verbally abused by supporters at every game, led to his early retirement.
        
        the moral foundation of
    - - due to
        
        According to Plato, democracy is dominated by appetites. He describes the common people as “lacking in discipline [and] pursuing mere pleasure of the moment …”
        
        Democracy is appealing because it promises maximum freedom. But when every desire is given equal weight — even foolish or harmful ones — reason is ignored, and order collapses.
      - can lead to
        
        Tyranny
        
        preceeded by
        
        Chaos, eg Capitol Hill riots 2021
        
        Plato's "The Republic" - democracy is fragile when citizens are ruled by desire and emotion rather than reason. In The Republic, he warns that freedom without philosophical discipline (being governed by reason) devolves into chaos—and ultimately tyranny
        
        Populist governments often end in tyranny because their rejection of institutional limits, demonisation of opposition, and centralisation of power create the perfect conditions for authoritarian rule to emerge under the guise of serving the people.
        
        Democracies can be slowly dismantled from the inside by leaders who gain power through democratic means and then erode checks and balances—this has happened historically and recently in several countries.
        
        eg
        
        Hitler and the Nazi Party, rose to power legally (Hitler was legally appointed Chancellor in 1933) and then dismantled democratic institutions from within, turning Germany into a dictatorship.
        
        by
        
        Populism: People vs. Elite. Hitler framed Germans as victims of corrupt elites — Weimar politicians, Jews, and communists — and promised to restore pride and order.
        
        1 more item...
- - - - Temporal (is it imminent) and epistemic (is it really a threat - do they have the capability and intent) considerations are met
        
        Pre-emptive self defence is justified when it meets the above
        
        Israel and Egypt 1967 - Egypt's actions (troop buildup, blockade) constituted an act of war or imminent threat
        
        as opposed to
        
        Preventative self defence - not justified by international law, based on speculation
        
        America and Iraq War 2003
        
        pretext For America going to war
        
        1 more item...
        
        hidden motive (alleged)
        
        1 more item...
        
        Russia and Ukraine War 2022
        
        Israel and Iran War June 2025
        
        If justified, then the use of reasonable force
        
        jus in bello - justice in war - refers to the ethical and legal rules that apply once war has begun
        
        Discrimination - distinguish between combatants and non-combatants (civilians). Attacks on civilians are prohibited
        
        is essential because
        
        seeks to minimise unnecessary suffering, damage, and loss of life during war by imposing ethical and legal limits on how force is used. It ensures that even in the chaos of armed conflict, fundamental human rights and moral responsibilities are preserved
        
        aims to prevent
        
        Premature and opportunistic wars (when temporal conditions not met), as well as avoid wars based on false assumptions or misinformation (epistemic considerations)
        
        ultimately preventing
        
        any state justifying aggression under the guise of vague security threats. This erosion of legal restraint would normalise pre-emptive violence, increasing the frequency of war and destabilising global order. As wars multiply, societies may regress to a more primitive state, where individuals and nations prioritise survival, safety, and shelter above all else — the very base of Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs. In such a world, higher aspirations like education, community, and self-actualisation become impossible. War thus not only destroys infrastructure, but undoes the conditions necessary for human flourishing.
        
        prioritising national self-interest over global cooperation, encouraging states to act unilaterally and opportunistically, thereby increasing conflict and undermining global stability
        
        Global stability is undermined because when nations abandon legal restraint and act on speculative threats, trust between states breaks down, diplomatic solutions are sidelined, and cycles of retaliation and conflict become more frequent.
        
        2 more items...
    - - Often invoked in humanitarian crises, invasions, or threats to peace
    - - EG
        
        Iraq’s government invited U.S. forces to assist against ISIS in 2014.