Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Epistemology - Theory of Knowledge (Ancient Philosophical Influences) -…
Epistemology - Theory of Knowledge
(Ancient Philosophical Influences)
Empiricism
Aristotle
Four Causes
Matter
Material cause
- what something is made of
e.g. table is made of wood
Form
Formal cause
- what defining characteristic a thing has, usually form, shape or colour
e.g. table has four legs and a surface
Source
Efficient cause
- what brings the being into existence, who made it and how it was made
*Potentiality
to
actuality
e.g. a carpenter made the table
End
Final cause
(telos: end/purpose) - why it is there, reason for its existence, purpose
e.g. table is for writing on/placing things
Influenced the
teleological argument
, saying that everything has a purpose
Aetion
"reason" or "explanation" that includes "origin"
Process of change
Potentiality
Possibility of achieving something or becoming something (what something could be)
e.g. an acorn has the potential to become an oak tree
(represents an unrealised but possible state)
Actuality
When potential is achieved; it reached its full form or function; fully become what it is meant to be
Actuality is the fulfillment or realisation of potentiality
e.g. an oak tree is the actualised form of the acorn
(represents the achieved, fully developed state)
Aristotle's view in change is the
movement from potentiality to actuality
, driven by final cause (telos), the purpose or goal something is working towards
Aristotle saw
time
as a measure of change/motion (time existing only because there is movement from one state to another
Time (in a sense) is a byproduct of process transition from potential to actual
Time is irreversible as actuality represents fulfillment of potentiality (irreversible progression that reflects the dynamic flow of time
Four causes of the universe
Material cause
- fundamental elements/"prime matter" that make up all things
(Combination of earth, water, air, fire: seen as material basis of the universe)
Formal cause
- structure and organisation of the cosmos, nature of things (e.g. orbiting planets and rotating stars)
Efficient cause
- Movement of celestial spheres maintains changes in the planet’s atmosphere, which maintains the processes of change on the earth.
(Prime Mover/Unmoved Mover is
not the efficient cause as it is not physical
, he also believed that the universe was eternal)
Final cause
- Prime Mover is responsible for the everlasting motion and change of the universe.
Things in the universe are moving towards the Prime Mover (pure actuality); therefore, sustains the pattern of change from actuality to potentiality in our universe. Things move towards their telos (purpose).
apply four causes to the universe
Prime Mover
Endless chain of cause and effect (each moving thing is caused by a moving thing)
Cause of universe must be God - the Prime Mover/Unmoved Mover
Cause which actualises the potential in everything else
Cause without being affected
Being with no potential but "pure actuality" (no potential to change or to be acted upon)
First of all substances
Cause movement and change in all other things,
but not in a physical way
(because it doesn't affect the prime mover itself)
cause change and motion by attracting other things towards itself
Nature of God
Necessary
, existing independently - doesn't depend on anything else, no potential, pure actuality, no capacity for change
Eternal
Perfect
- highest form of good, pure actuality implies God must contain everything that ought to be there, therefore perfect
Immaterial, beyond space and time
- not acted upon, no physical activity, purely spiritual, pure thought
Transcendent
- beyond physical universe
Attraction
- metaphysically draw everything towards itself (from potential to actual)
Telos
- it is the final cause of the universe, therefore being the ultimate reason/purpose for everything else
A posteriori
(after experience), relies on experience and observation to determine its truth
John Locke's "tabula rasa" - blank slate
Synthetic
(relies on senses)
Rationalism
Plato
Where true reality lies within
Theory of Forms
Realm of Forms
An eternal, objective, unchanging realm that contains perfect essence of things
Accessed through a priori logical and intellectual reasoning
Exists independently from the object world
"One Over Many" argument
There must be a single ideal Form that defines every type/group of similar objects
Objects in the physical world are all examples of
"particulars"
(e.g. tree/table)
They share common qualities that make them identifiable
Because they may vary in shape, size, material (but share and fit into the same category of the "Form of XXX"
Form of the Good
Analogy of the Cave
Imagine some prisoners (us) in a cave (reality) who are chained to a wall (Our minds in a state of ignorance)
Can only look in one direction at a wall which appear shadows of real objects moving behind the prisoners
Shadows are all the prisoners have ever known
One day, a prisoner escapes (a philosopher) and is temporarily blinded by the sun (form of the Good), then sees the real world (realm of Forms)
He returns to the cave to explain the truth to the other prisoners, but they didn't understand him and killed him
Plato suggests that experience and senses are mere shadows of the real and that's why observations are purely opinion, not knowledge
Only a priori reasoning involving understanding the forms can give us knowledge
The sun in the cave analogy
Illuminates us to see the world of forms
Highest form
Understanding the form of the good makes it impossible for you to do wrong (rule as a "philosopher king")
Below the form of the good are higher abstract forms e.g. justice and beauty (aspects of goodness)
Definition of Knowledge, opinion and ignorance
Knowledge
A priori
(before experience), based on logic
Analytic
(true by definition)
Derived from Greek "episteme" which means knowledge and "logos" which means reason
Philosophical study of nature, origin, limits of knowledge
Questions how do we know stuff? How do we find knowledge?