Lecture 2: Critical Thinking in Psychology PSYC 1500

Critical Thinking in Psychology

A rational process that avoids preconceptions, gathers evidence, and evaluates alternatives to reach conclusions (Smith, 2002)

Key Traits of Critical Thinkers

Flexibility

Identifying biases and assumptions

Avoiding oversimplification

Skepticism

Logical inference

Separating facts from opinions

Evidence-based reasoning

Role of Media in Psychological Research

Media conveys research findings to the public but may lack proper understanding, leading to misrepresentation.

Examples of headlines showing potential inaccuracies in media portrayal (e.g., stress and cannabis use, the effects of makeup on self-esteem).

Case Study 1: Self-Injury and Online Content

Background on Self-Injury (NSSI)

Common in adolescents and young adults; associated with mental health issues (depression, anxiety, trauma).

NSSI is often depicted in YouTube videos, with graphic images showing cutting and burning.

Study Findings

Videos were favourably viewed but often lacked warnings

The majority were melancholic or educational rather than promoting NSSI

Concerns about potential triggering effects for those vulnerable to NSSI.

Study Limitations

Only examined 100 videos, not the actual long-term impact

Implications

Need for more resources and a cautious approach rather than banning such content

Case Study 2: Sexual Assault Resistance Education (SARE)

Prevalence of Sexual Assault

High rates of sexual violence against women, especially in university settings

Linked to mental health issues and academic difficulties.

SARE Program

12-hour program teaching risk assessment, self-defence, and sexual boundaries to first-year university women.

Study Results

46% reduction in completed rapes and 63% reduction in attempted rapes after one year.

Study Limitations

Conducted only at three universities in Canada, and challenges in scaling the program to other settings

Implications

The program was successful but raised concerns about placing responsibility on victims rather than perpetrators

Media vs. Research Findings

Media simplifies research findings and can mislead the audience due to its need for sensationalism or simplification.

Critical thinking is necessary to analyze media reports and assess their accuracy against original research

Importance of Critical Thinking in Academia

Developing critical thinking skills is essential throughout one's academic career, especially in assignments like research papers

Critical thinkers evaluate evidence, avoid biases, and draw conclusions from well-examined data.