Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
REALISM in Crime - Coggle Diagram
REALISM in Crime
RIGHT
MURRAY
About
- He is linked to the New Right perspective and has advocated privatization and personal responsibility rather than state control
- Influenced by ideas of neo-liberal economics which suggests reduced state spending and lower taxation - provides people with more choice and greater independence
Underclass
- He has argued that there is an existence of an underclass in society
- This group exists on the edge of mainstream society, and lack socialisation into norms and values of society
- Decline of traditional family values, with lone parents, high unemployment and dependent on welfare
Family and Socialisation
- He has been critical of welfare dependency - permissive policies that have promoted idleness and illegitimacy
- Suggested that their was an underclass of 'idle young men' being inadequately socialized by lone parents - lacked male role models to discipline
Inadequate Socialisation
- New Right model looks to traditional functionalist gender roles, particularly the instrumental role of father providing discipline
- His argument suggests that in the underclass many fathers shirk responsibility and are absent - leaving their sons to be inadequately
Shadow Economics
- Young males lack motivation and resilience, according to Murray, that is provided by father figures
- Look to earn through working in shadow economies - counterfeit goods, drug dealing, low-level security work
- Gain status through masculinity and not conforming to social norms and values
-
EVALUATIONS:
- Criticised for basing work on negative stereotypes of working-class and ethnic-minority groups
- Ignores structural inequality created by neo-liberal economic policy, including the privatisation of traditional male-dominated industries
- Existence of underclass can be seen to be reductionist view
- blaming the victims and suggesting poverty is a lifestyle choice
-