Phillip Burrin- Interpretation 3

Planning?

Role of Hitler

Significance of Barbarossa

Significance of Himmler/ Other organisations

August '41, the Final solution began to change from a possibility to a reality

  • Conceivable to suggest that all soviet jews were, from this point on, condemned to die. 
    
  • Conceivable to suggest that the SS has an open-ended extermination order- the nature of which would develop over time. 
    

Was the decision to kill Soviet Jews the result of the decision to kill all Jews under Nazi control?

  • If genocide has been decreed in Summer ’41, then the policy towards Jews in the Reich should have made that apparent. 
    

Goerings order of 1941 contains nothing that makes it the 'smoking gun'

  • The hour of death for the Jews could have come, but nothing could be less certain. 
    
  • Identifies that the time had come to extend the scope of Heydrich’s mandate to the whole of Europe. 
    
  • Other departments should be consulted and invited to ‘participate’. 
    
  • Solutions envisaged were, strictly, emigration and evacuation. 
    
  • Before he did anything, Heydrich was to consult Goering. Things still at the stage of proposals. 
    
  • Formalised the way Heydrich had been acting since 1939. 
    

Eichmann wrote that the order of July 1941 had been drafted by his department and signed by Goering

Heydrich stated at Wannsee that he had been given the order by Goering on the instruction of Hitler

Proves that nothing had yet been decided

If Hitler had wanted to entrust the extermination of the Jews to Heydrich, he would not have issued an order via Goering.

None of the evidence from Sumer 41 indicates that the extermination had been decided on

Evidence

  • Final solution remained the deportation of Jews to reservations. \
    
  • Heydrich’s request to the ministry of Justice- that martial law should apply to Poles and Jews- shows that he did not think that the FS was imminent.
    
  • “Expect that in the future” is a vague and non-specific phrase.
    
  • Goering’s plans for the Jews to be moved into to work camps- Jews condemned to death to be hanged- shows that they were intended to leave Nazi Europe.
    
  • If extermination had been decided on, he would not have needed to express himself about the hanging of them.
    

Eichmann's meeting on the 13th of August about 'half caste' Jews

Elaboration

  • At stake was the deportation of vast numbers of persons. 
    
  • Eichmann recived support for an interdepartmental task force that would give a European-wide definition of ‘the Jew’.
    
  • Concerns about modifying the (too generous) definition of the Jew given at Nuremberg in 1935.
    
  • In the minds of the party experts and Eichmann, mid-August the deportation of Jews was the official policy.
    

September 1941.

Höppner proposed to expand an organisation which deported Jews to the General government to the entire Reich- and to make it responsible for ‘post war’ deportation.

  • ‘Definitive solution to the Jewish question’
    
  • “Was the goal to guarantee them permanently the sure promises of life or was it to exterminate them completely?”. 
    

July and August 1941, Death preparations made by Himmler's department for Soviet soliders- not Jews.

Process development

  • Sachsenhausen, August 41. A fast method was needed for killing 18,000 soviet prisoners due to arrive there.
    
  • Shot via an evil ‘measuring device’ contraption. 6,500 murdered.
    
  • September at Auschwitz, Zyklon B used to kill soviets.
    

SS Killing process

July and August, death preparations made by Himmler’s department for Soviet soldiers, not Jews.

  • Sachsenhausen, August 41. A fast method was needed for killing 18,000 soviet prisoners due to arrive there.
    
  • Shot via an evil ‘measuring device’ contraption. 6,500 murdered.
    
  • September at Auschwitz, Zyklon B used to kill soviets.
    

click to edit

Two measures came in 1941 to seal the doom of the Jews.

  • Badges in August.
    
  • Deportation to the east ordered in September.
    
  • Both decisions came from Hitler himself.
    

Hitler's orders

Two measures came in 1941 to seal the doom of the Jews.

  • Badges in August.
    
  • Deportation to the east ordered in September.
    
  • Both decisions came from Hitler himself.
    

badges

click to edit

  • Goebbels persuaded him that the badges were needed.
    
  • Would eliminate Jewish ‘bellyachers’ and ‘defeatists’ from going unrecognised throughout Germany.
    
  • Linked to the war, Goebbels knew that talk of Jewish ‘defeatists’ would convince Hitler.
    
  • This was not the beginning of the end.
    
  • Measure not adopted in view of an impending deportation.
    

evacuation

click to edit

  • Goebbels asked to deport the Berlin Jews.
    
  • Hitler stated that he would be able to send them to the east immediately after the end of the eastern campaign.
    
  • Beginning of September, Germans in Serbia sought to deport 8,000 Jewish men from the region to spread partisan activity. Eichmann refused.
    
  • 18th September, Hitler wished the Reich and the protectorate to be liberated from the Jews. Himmler asked Greiser to send them to Lodz ghetto for the winter before their being sent further east.
    

These orders meant that the hour of extermination had arrived

click to edit

  • ‘But this would reduce to naught the plan for a total resettlement of the Jews out of the territories occupied by us’.
    
  • Shows that they were at the start of a vast project- which it was feared would face challenges.
    
  • Project involved all territories under the control of the Reich.
    
  • ‘Resettlement’ could mean nothing more than extermination as the Jews in the east- where it was proposed to send the evacuated Jews- were facing extinction at the hands of the Einsatzgruppen.
    

In November 1941, Heydrich assumed responsibility for the supply of Bombs which were subsequently used to destroy a Jewish place of worship in Paris.

  • His comment after this was ‘Only from the moment when, at the highest level, Jewry has been forcefully designated as the culpable incendiary in Europe, one which must definitively disappear from Europe’. 
    
  • Deportation order was, in Heydrich’s own words, also an extermination order. 
    
  • Note the fact that Heydrich specified the time (September 1941) that the order for the ‘deportation’. 
    
  • The Hitlerian language is also significant. 
    
  • Destruction of the Paris synagogues were ‘death notices’, symbolic of the annihilation to come. 
    

EIchmann later claimed that the extermination order came two to three months after the state of the eastern campaign.
Eichmann later claimed that the extermination order came two to three months after the start of the eastern campaign.

click to edit

Heydrich to Eichmann: “The Fuhrer has ordered the physical destruction of the Jews”.

  • Sent to inspect the facilities of Belzec extermination camp.
    
  • Eichmann was fully aware of the extermination project by the end of September.
    

Decision arose from rage he felt at failures of Barbarossa

Eichmann organised the deportation of some German Jews to the Warthegau and Lodz

click to edit

  • Conflict between the SS and the authorities of the Warthegau.
    
  • In one letter in October, Ubelhor wrote that the Gestapo was dividing the Lodz ghetto. One side was to be a ‘Arbeitsghetto’ (for working Jews) the other was to be a ‘Versohnungsghetto’ (Maintenance ghetto).
    
  • Eichmann involved in this reorganisation.
    
  • Working ghetto three times the size of the maintenance ghetto.
    
  • Those in the maintenance ghetto were to be killed.
    

In December 1941, local jews of Posen were gassed in the facilities built for the mentally ill.

click to edit

  • In January, the inactive Jews of the Lodz ghetto took their turn.
    
  • Greiser made some kind of deal with Himmler? I’ll take your jews if I can kill my useless ones.
    
  • However, extermination of the jews did not begin locally and become a wider movement, for in the Lublin area prep to exterminate their jews was also underway.
    

Bouhler's crew were in charge in Lublin

click to edit

  • 24th August 41, Hitler ordered the Euthanasia action to end.
    
  • Hitler does not seem to have had another idea in mind for the Euthanasia crews.
    
  • Many dismissed after the end of the action.
    
  • However, others distributed across the ‘space’ that would develop into the Final Solution.
    
  • There does seem to have been a central decision dated to the end of September/beginning of October.
    

While extermination machinery- in the physical sense- was still under construction, the RSHA moved ahead with deportations.

View that the Reich had to be 'liberated from the Jews' prevailed.

Hitler wanted all Jews out of Germany by the end of 1941, no issues were to stand in the way of this

The SS seemed to be aware that they were embarking on a historic task.

Due to the crowded nature of Lodz, Riga and Minsk were chosen as sites for the deportations.

Passengers to Riga and Minsk shot on arrival at the cities.

Extermination now on the agenda

Plans for a showcase ghetto were set up to show that the Jews were not bench mistreated and to prevent public opposition from building to the plans of the SS

click to edit

Emigration of Jews prohibited as of the 23rd of October.

  • All was orchestrated from September to October 1941.
    
  • Wannsee only recorded a solution already reached.
    

The FS was reached by bringing together several elements

click to edit

  • The experience in deportation matters gained by the RSHA since the autumn of 1939.
    
  • Death techniques developed by the Fuhrer’s chancellery and Heydrich’s men in the USSR
    
  • Distinction between active and inactive Jews in Poland.
    

Trial and error had been reduced to a minimum

Dispatching of Jews to the USSR was primarily due to the pressure exerted by Hitler who wanted to purify the Reich by the end of the year, whether facilities were ready or not

Death camps eventually became concentrated in the General Government and Upper Silesia.

From mid-October 1941, the circle of the initiated would widen

  • Der Sturmer reported that ‘Special measures’ were being adopted in the east thanks to which a ‘large part of the Jewish vermin’ would be exterminated in the near future. 
    
  • Eichmann announced thar the Reich’s Jews would be deported to the east and that those who could not work would be employed there. 
    

In September, Frank still hoped that the Jews would be deported to refuges in deepest Russia.

Wished to ship the jews in the General Government,ent to the east.

Rosenberg was informed of the programme in mid-November at the latest.

On the 18th of November, he stated confidentially that the Jewish question could only be resolved 'by the biological extermination of all the Jews in Europe'.

Goebbels

Hitler's prophecy of 1939 was coming true

Frank

December 16th told one of his aids of the coming massacre.

Eichmann

early November, Eichmann began to prepare for an inter-ministerial meeting on the 'Jewish question'.

The Nazis did consider using Jews for work due to the Labour Shortage. In the end, the machinery of extermination killed them all.

Two major turning points of anti-Jewish policy

  • Massacre of Jews in the USSR assumed the characteristics of a genocide. 
    
  • Decision to deport Jews from the Reich to the east- accompanied by preparations indicating that all Jews under Nazi control would be marked for death.
    

On Hitler's authority that Himmler ordered Einsatzgruppen to exterminate women and children in the USSR.

click to edit

  • Hitler who decided that Reich jews should wear a yellow star.
    
  • Hitler who decided that they should be deported east.
    
  • No reason to doubt that he gave the order for genocide.
    
  • The way Hitler reacted to the Russian campaign may give us some idea as to why he chose to take these steps.
    
  • Focus on Hitler’s perception of things at the time is key. Documentation sufficient to illuminate the context in which the shift to genocide took place.
    

Russian campaign planned in an atmosphere of unprecedented confidence.

click to edit

  • Germans believed that they would make short work of a poorly equipped, poorly led enemy.
    
  • German army would surround soviet troops and crush them before they had time to retreat which would lead to the collapse of the Soviet regime.
    
  • Expected to take a few weeks to a few months.
    
  • Hitler was determined for fast success and a definitive defeat of Bolshevism. ‘We must have early successes. There must be no reversals.’
    
  • Hitler knew, however, that the campaign was a risk. He still has confidence in the army generally and the OKW more specifically.
    

Many things dependent on the success of Barbarossa

click to edit

  • End of the war with Britain.
    
  • End of the war with the USSR (obvs).
    
  • Japan’s being freed from Soviet pressure.
    

First weeks of the campaign in Russia

click to edit

  • Fulfilled Hitler’s hopes.
    
  • By the beginning of July, the German generals viewed the battle as as good as won.
    
  • Hitler gave free reign to dreams of colonisation, declaring that Moscow and Leningrad would be ‘pulverised’.
    

Hitler'a antisemitism during the campaign

click to edit

  • Hitler’s antisemitism never left during the campaign.
    
  • He had fears for the troops headed for Kyiv’s safety as 35% of Kyiv was Jewish.
    
  • Yet the concept of massacre far from his mind.
    
  • Hitler believed that the worst blow he had dealt the jews at this point was to show that countries could- and should- live without them.
    

click to edit

  • 14th July approved the armament programme that was to begin at the end of Barbarossa.
    
  • Showed that the campaign had lived up to his expectation.
    
  • Did have some doubts, for instance he had underestimated the Soviet troops’ morale.
    
  • 15th of July, he told Oshima (Japanese ambassador to Germany) of the serious surprises he had faced in the USSR. ‘Russians could fight like wild animals
    

The Change

click to edit

  • By the end of July, anxiety was taking on crisis proportions.
    
  • Brauchitsch: ‘The length of the war wore at the nerves’.
    
  • Hitler became obsessed by the time it was taking to win in the USSR.
    
  • Goebbels: 26th July ‘The people must know that Germany is fighting for her life and that we must choose between the total annihilation of the German nation and domination of the world.
    
  • Doubt showed in Hitler’s behaviour.
    

Barbarossa leads to genocide

click to edit

  • On the 22nd of July, Hitler directed the commanders of the rear echelons to employ the harshest methods to impose order on the population.
    
  • The enemy taken in battle were to be killed.
    
  • In the event of opposition. From the population, collective reprisals must be used.
    
  • Suspicious elements to be turned over to the Einsatzgruppen.
    
  • Acts of the SS increasingly mirrored the brutality of the campaign.
    
  • Due to the connection between the Jews and Soviet partisans, the work of the SS Einsatzgruppen would ‘know no bounds’.
    

Croatian meeting

click to edit

  • Hitler urged his Croat counterpart to use the most brutal measures to achieve purification.
    
  • ‘Asocials and criminals must be exterminated; when a country sends its best to risk their lives at the front, it need not spare the scum’.
    
  • Hitler expressed his wish to get them out of Europe, he was ‘indifferent’ as to their specific destination.
    
  • Hitler reaffirmed his intention to concentrate the Jews into a specific territory.
    

August 41

click to edit

  • Prospects became ever darker for the Germans.
    
  • Their goals would not be reached
    
  • Keitel spelled out how bad things were.
    
  • Hitler began to foresee a prolongation of the war.
    
  • Began to use the word ‘hope’ more and more when speaking of the war.
    
  • Hiter had a growing certainty that the war was bogging down.
    
  • Hitler dreamed of a miraculous peace to save him from the trap he had drawn around him.
    

Significance of Barbarossa in changing Hitler's mindset

click to edit

  • His attitude towards the Jews began to harden.
    
  • 8th or 10th of August, he spoke of population evacuations.
    
  • 18th of August, Hitler reiterated to Goebbels his desire to expel the Jews from the Reich (also agreed to an insignia). He referred to their deportation east after the war and stated that the harsh climate would teach them how to live.
    
  • Made references to his ‘prophecy’.
    
  • The idea of extermination was taking shape in proportion to the difficulties encountered in the war in the east, but the final verdict had not yet been reached.
    

Hitler began to ponder more and more on 1918

  • Hitler began to ponder more and more on the Great war, and its conclusion. 
    
  • He told Himmler that, in the event of internal troubles, all concentration camp prisoners should be killed so that no leader would appear to incite masses. 
    

Deportation

click to edit

  • Hitler’s deportation order shows that he did not believe victory to be close.
    
  • He sent them there, in a reversal of his previous decision, to die.
    
  • Hitler’s use of ‘from now on’ in a speech on the 3rd of October 1941 in reference to the Jews appears to show that a decision had recently been made.