Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Pros and Cons of using textbooks (Bunting,2018) - Coggle Diagram
Pros and Cons of using textbooks (Bunting,2018)
Structured Learning: Textbooks provide a structured approach to learning with a clear progression of topics.
Consistency: They ensure consistency in the material being taught, which is useful for standardization across different classrooms and schools.
Supplemental Materials: They often come with additional resources like workbooks, CDs, and online materials.
Ready-made Framework: Provides support for the teacher’s planning and offers a coherent package of support materials.
Lack of SLA Theory Integration: There's often a disconnect between textbook content and second language acquisition (SLA) theory.
Cultural Bias: Textbooks may contain cultural biases or fail to represent diverse perspectives adequately.
Not Always Suitable: Materials might not be suitable for the specific goals, level, age, or background of the students.
Linear Approach: The often linear approach used in textbooks might not always be appropriate.
-
Ease of Use: Textbooks are easy to use and do not require technology, making them accessible in all environments.
Portable: They are portable and can be used anywhere, even where there is no internet access.
Ziyoda's experience: pros:students will be able to use independently with them like marking, drawing key points and it will be comfortable to learner
pros:Textbooks is ready-made and saving time in lesson planning and ensuring coverage of key topics.
-
Accessibility: Not all textbooks are accessible to students with disabilities, such as those who are visually impaired.
-
Farangiz's experience: cons: textbooks are expensive, not everone is able to buy them;
textbooks restrict the teacher's skills to teach and use modern methods of teaching
Questions by Bunting
-
-
-
How involved are students in choosing, developing, and using the materials?
Do the extra materials match the original in terms of terminology, level, and topics?
Are the materials used legally, respecting copyright laws?
Teachers need to ensure that supplementary materials are used legally, considering copyright laws and permissions.
-
-
-