Nazism
The Nazi regime has produced a wide historical literature and posed multiple questions, one of which → what Nazism the predictable outcome of German characteristics and tendencies of the era, or was Nazism a momentary abhor-ration and unforeseeable?
Answer: Nazism was the result of historical conjunction of dramatic developments, the great economic depression of 1929 and following year being the decisive one + social economic and political events between the end of the war and 1933
September 1930, hardly one year after the great panic on Wall Street, it jumped to 107 seats, becoming the second largest party in the Reichstag
July 1932 it was the biggest, with 230 seats. It is clear that the internal weakness of the Weimar Republic also paved the way for Nazi rule. This is why we say that Nazism was the product of the Weimar Republic. The rise of Hitler lie in the failures of the Weimar Republic.
1928, Hitler’s party was almost negligible (only 12 seats in parliament → the Nazi party was a marginal phenomenon in a very chaotic situation).
THE WEIMAR REPUBLIC
Born out of military defeat and revolution and went through multiple difficult periods between its establishment until its collapse in 1933
Significance of 1917 Russian Revolution
Democratic regime after years of rural autocracy
An international framework which had a significant inspiring strength
Council of workers and soldiers created and founded, after the Russian model, the German communist party whose leader was Karl Liebknecht
Discontent with the war and the regime were the main causes of the revolts ↓
9 November 1918 - Abdication of Kaiser Wilhelm II and subsequent proclamation of the Republic by NICOLAS SCHEIDEMANN
11 November 1918 - Signing of the armistice with the victorious powers
Communist revolts
Two main left-wing parties: Social democrats (moderate) and Independent Socialists and the Communists aka Spartacus -> more radical
Problem: SD wanted new elections to create a social democracy, a social democratic regime. On the other hand, the communist wanted to create a council soviet republic similar to the one established by the Bolsheviks in Russia.
December 1918 - January 1919
Communist rebellion suppressed by army (gov)
More than 150 dead, including Karl Liebknecht and Rosa Luxemburg
Jan 1919 elections of new republic, results looked traditional: 163 SD, 94 Liberals, 73 Catholics -> formed coalition government
Jan - June -> National Constituent assembly created to draw the Weimar Constitution in Weimar (Berlin too dangerous due to revolts)
Republic was constitutional and fully parliamentary, as the cabinet and every single minister depended on the confidence of the Reichstag, which could bring down governments without producing alternative cabinet
President’s position was greatly strengthened by the fact that he was elected by the people and that he appointed both the HOG and other members of the cabinet. The power of the president, the chancellor and the Reichstag was so great all over the republic that one might be justified in speaking of a decentralised unitary state.
Executive power was in the hands of the president, chancellor and cabinet
Legislation belonged to the Reichstag, partly elected by general male suffrage
Main issue: constitution wasn’t created to deal with emergencies and times of crisis + inexperience ↓
The first article of the constitution is paradoxical as it states that the “German Reich was a republic”, the word Reich refers to an empire, not a republic
Tried to find balance between model of presidential republic and parliamentary republic
President elected for 7 years by universal suffrage
HOG -> depended on the confidence of the parliament (elected every 4 years by universal suffrage holding legislative powers)
IMPORTANT: fundamental relationship between the executive and legislative branches the last years of the Weimar regime witnessed a striking shift away from parliament and towards the president, without any formal change in the Constitution, technically, however, parliament should have been the cornerstone of power ↓
Technically, however, parliament should have been the cornerstone of power → reality: last years of Parliament, the latter lost it’s impact as it decided to give more power to the president → PAUL VAN HINDENBURG
Through ARTICLE 48, parliament gave power to the president - “If public security and order are seriously disturbed or endangered within the German Reich, the President of the Reich may take measures necessary for their restoration, intervening if need be with the assistance of the armed forces. For this purpose he may suspend for a while, in whole or in part, the fundamental rights provided in Articles 114, 115, 117, 118, 123, 124 and 153. If a federal state did not fulfil the duties imposed by the constitution, the president may make use of the armed force to compel the state to do so. (Power to send the national army to a specific federal state to compel it to do something)"
Even before Hitler's rise, many emergency decrees were issued, as Article 48 was considered a necessary, but temporary tool to save the circumstances in times of serious crisis - Article 48 as a stabilising factor
Prior 1933, the Reichstag sometimes gave government full legislative powers by passing enabling acts ENABLING ACTS
Important to remember, second part of the constitution identified rights of German citizens
Some duties -> unexpected for the time - example: duty of the parents to provide a good physical and spiritual education for the children + duty of every German citizens to dispose its property in view of the common good (can see the socialist influence)
Discrimination based on birth or social position were forbidden
The 3 phases
FIRST: 1919-1923 - instability and severe problems
Two main issues
Treaty of Versailles
Signed under the threat of renew hostilities, although the conditions were very harsh
Germany lost almost 1/8 of its territory (Alsace Lorraine)
Damaged amounted to 226 billion
Acknowledge exclusive guilt for the war - historically incorrect and unnecessary humiliating clause
Stab in the back legend, VERY SIMILAR TO MUTILATED VICTORY in Italy - Socialist government, the one of Scheidemann and the Jews betrayed the German army signing the treaty - evidence of anti-semitism prior Hitler
The economy
Inflation -> aggravated by the reparations
January 1923 Ruhr crisis - invasion of industrial part of Germany by Belgian and French soldiers -> point € collapsed -> mark had no value -> barter replaced coinage
SECOND: 1923-1929 - recovery and consolidation
Aka Stresemann period
Stresemann brought vital economic developments → stabilisation of the currency and agreement on war reparations Dawes Plan 1924 - the German industry was able to recover pre war levels
Benefits in the international arena: foreign political relations treaty with Russia 1922, Locarno Pact with Britain (détente effect), France, Italy, and Belgium 1925 and League of Nations 1926
THIRD: 1929-1933 - final crisis
German dependency on American support -> massive unemployment - 60 million beginning 1932
HITLER'S RISE TO POWER
End WW1, 1918 many strongly opposed to the socialist revolution. One of these groups was the GERMAN WORKERS PARTY (fewer than 60 members) → Small party founded by ANTON DREXLER in Munich in January 1919
Difference with Fascism: the Fasci di Combattimento were founded by Mussolini, while the German Workers Party wasn’t founded by Hitler, but by Anton Drexler
Difference with Fascism: The issue of the Italian Jewish population wasn’t a concern in the beginning, -> became such in 1935 after the racial laws. On the other hand, the Nazi regime was anti-semitic since the beginning. Adolf Hitler was against Jews since his youth.
Hitler -> one of many veterans who never accepted German military defeat (stab in the back) -> blamed gov. Nationalism, anti-marxism, and anti-semitism were the strong poles of Hitler's thought since the beginning
Concepts repeated during the first meeting of the DAP -> February 1920 -> 25 points of GERMAN WORKERS PARTY MANIFESTO
Points included: abhor ration of ToV, ideas of greater Germany, expansion towards East and expulsion of Jews from society
1920 Hitler changed party name to NATIONALIST SOCIALIST GERMAN PARTY - as suggested by the name, the party meant to bring together the two greater currents with mass appeal of the 20th century, socialism and nationalism
Importance on anti-capitalism, however, even more important -> anti-Marxist. German socialism despised everything cosmopolitan and supranational. They were prepared to collaborate with the communists temporarily and for tactical reasons, against the Weimar Republic
1921 Hitler became most prominent member of party, however Drextler -> still party leader. Hitler quickly clashed with party leader. Eventually, Hitler overcame Drextler and become party chairman in July 1921
Difference with Fascism: Hitter’s rise to power was very long (1921-1933) compared to Mussolini’s
AS Assualt Squads
Similarity with Fascism: black v brown shirts with similar job
Hitler wanted to emulate Mussolini's March on Rome 1922
600 SA tried to march on Berlin in November 1923 - Munich Putsch or Bear Hall Putsch
Minister of Bavaria, refused to support the putsch → called the police which arrested the SA
Hitler first attempt to power → failure - he was sentenced for treason and was sentenced 5 years to prison, although he served only 1 year in which he wrote Mein Kampf
After 1923 Hitler announced his intention to obtain power by legal means, rather than through violence (not however refraining from street violence) - clear comparison with fascism (Mussolini changing from a movement to a party)
Nazi party took part in Parliamentary election, Hitler himself sit as a candidate for presidency. However, differently from Mussolini, Hitler’s attempt almost laster 10 years and was more difficult and obstructed in his goal (refer to the stable Steersmann era, in which he always got poor electoral performances ).
THE LEGAL REVOLUTION
First year of Hitler's regime - legal, as it had the pretence to be legal and revolution as it effectively destroyed the Weimar Republic -> end of phase constitutional democracy crashed and replaced by Nazi totalitarianism
Event 1 - Reichstag fire - 27th February 1933
Fire took place a few days before the first Nazi elections (recall the importance of the first elections for an authoritarian regimes, after the appointment by the president) and used the fire as a pretence, Hitler casted the blame on the Communist
Hitler used this event to suspend multiple articles of the constitution - the day after the fire, he issued a emergency presidential decree, thanks to Article 48
Decree issued was called the Protection of People and State: “Articles 114, 115, 117, 118, 123, 124 and 153 of the Constitution of the German Reich are suspended until further notice." t is therefore permissible to restrict the rights of personal freedom [habeas corpus], freedom of (opinion) expression, including the freedom of the press, the freedom to organise and assemble...
CRUCIAL: None of the suspended articles were never reestablished for the following 12 years
Despite the destruction of much of the opposition and the climate of fear, the Nazi party failed to achieve an overall majority → Elections on 5th March 1933 - Hitler’s party only received 43.9% of the votes
IMPORTANT point of this act: laws may be enacted by the government of the Reich. With this act, the legislative power was transferred to the Reich, to the government (Hitler) -> this was a COMPLETE POLITICAL TAKEOVER
1933 November 12th elections - Hitler received 95% of the votes -> we can state the after this date, Germany was officially a one-party state - similarity with Fascism, people votes for a finalist from the Führer list = Fascist big list elections 1924
To achieve majority & radically reduce power of the Reichstag, Hitler's next move was another emergency decree -> an Enabeling act 1933 - Law to Remedy the Distress of the People and the Reich: "Laws enacted by the government of the Reich may deviate from the constitution as long as they do not affect the institutions of the Reichstag and the Reichsrat. The rights of the President remain unaffected”
Institutional aspect of the legal revolution = complete, following the successful elections. However, the revolution itself had yet to be completed -> night of the long knives
Within the Nazi party, there was a threat posed by the unruly SA and its leader, ERNST RÖHM, who wanted a new revolution and the Army’s incorporation into the SA
Similarity with Fascism: some members of the Camicie Nere were more radical compared and wanted to further purse the revolution
Röhm and Hitler -> disagreed. Hitler couldn't unite the SA with the army, as he needed the latter's support in his forthcoming moves -> outcome: Röhm was liquidated and later killed in NoLK
On the NoLK, about 100 dead -> Röhm, all the other leaders of the SA, and many old rivals of Hitler, including the minister of Bavaria - Röhm's killing within the party was justified killing of Röhm within the party, by Hitler sharing some accusations about Röhm's homosexuality, something which wasn’t well considered in the party
Difference with fascism: Mussolini wasn’t so careful of anticipating the rivals and their moves, he didn’t eliminates the most radical black shirts or the leaders who wanted to oppose his power (sometimes he tried to move them away, Africa). There wasn’t and Italian long knives. Mussolini has a strong internal opposition which he didn’t take care of.
HItler as a president 1934
After Hindenburg's death, 2nd August, Hilter forced gov to pass a law uniting the functions of HOS and HOG in just one office → Hitler succeeded Hindenburg as President of Germany
CRUCIal: act violated the Constitution and the Enabling Act which stated that the rights of the president were to be unaffected → considered as the final formalistic respect of the constitution -> MARKED THE END OF THE LEGAL REVOLUTION
Crowning achievement of Hitler’s rise to power was the replacement of the army oath of loyalty to the constitution with a new oath of loyalty to Hitler - October 1934
IMPORTANT: too simplistic to attribute Hitler's success merely to the improved €. For the first time in many years, public order was restored, situation people hardly remembered -> gave country impression of being ruled by an effective government
THE ORGANISATION OF THE NAZI STATE
Separation of power -> radically rejected
Executive power: all in hands of AH, who was HOS and HOG. More importantly, he was gov as all ministers and cabinet -> no effective power (met less and less frequently as the dictatorship continued)
CRUCIAL: Hitler’s acts of government didn’t require the countersignature, as he was accountable to no-one
Legislative power: in hands of AH -> Führerprinzip → Hitler’s word was law (Führerbefehle); everyone is responsible to Hitler and he was responsible to no one. According to this principle, the word of the Füher is above any law - principle was written in Mein Kampf
- Nazi officials -> afraid of taking decisions without Hitler, as he had last word
- Hitler's pronouncements -> oral -> more difficult to "guess" wish -> scholars believe that the final order to exterminate the Jews was given orally as there is no written document stating such order
Judiciary power: hands of AH, he was the Supreme Judge -> could intervene in ordinary admin of justice and dismiss judges he disliked
If a sentence, despite becoming final, was considered to be contrary to the Nazi ideology, the party officer, could write a claim and bring it to the Führer’s attention, allowing the process to be re-opened. Frequent technique for intervening in court's operation -> complaint of nullity
Abolition of federal system
It was obvious that the concentration of all authority at the centre of the Reich would affect its federal structure: in no time Germany was turned into a unitary centralised state. The separate governments and parliaments of the Lander - with their different political colouring - were abolished.The Lander themselves became provinces of the Reich and were placed under the authority of a lieutenant, usually the highest regional party leader (Gauleiter).
On 30 January 1934 a LAW ON THE RECONSTRUCTION OF THE REICH was published transferring the public assignments of the Lander to the Reich, subordinating their governments to that in Berlin and abolishing their parliaments.
CRUCIAL: Citizens' freedoms, human rights and Constitutions were anathema to the Nazis. The very idea of an individual standing up to the state and placing his own interests above those of the nation was monstrous. There was therefore no question of a Constitution that might restrain the Führer: his will was the fundamental law and no other was required. Consequently there was NEVER A CONSTITUTION OF THE THIRD REICH -> such was the inescapable logic of the regime
As the Nazi gospel was expected to transform and inspire the whole of German society -> couldn't limit its impact to the organs of the state. Everything was affected, social life, the arts, science, trade unions and, the media. To achieve this HOMOGENEITY ON A MASS SCALE, old social organisations were dissolved and new, compulsory ones founded. Examples: the press was placed under the control of the propaganda minister, Joseph Goebbels and all liberal professions were encapsulated in Nazi bodies.
The repressive system
In totalitarian regime -> plays fundamental role
Terror institutions
- SS Schuzstaffeln was the protection squad (most important)
1929, HEINRICH HIMMLER was one of the most powerful man in Germany → appointed head of the SS. He expanded and transformed the government (security and policy). SS focused on the racial emphasis of the Nazi ideology and provided the strongest impetus behind the most radical measures of Nazism
30s is was responsible for the Jews persecution and execution in the concentration camps
Emerged in 1925 as a small bodyguard unit to protect Hitler, and some other Nazi leaders
- Gestapo, Geheime Staatspolizei (Secret State Police)
1933 under HERMANN GÖRING → 1936 under the command of HEINRICH HIMMLER
Investigations of cases of treason, espionage, sabotage and criminal attacks on the Nazi Party → Schutzhaft (power to imprison people without the need of judicial proceeding)
Gestapo could even operate above the law whenever the security of the state was considered at risk (issue of interpretation) -> people could be taken away by the Gestapo also during trial, to be then sent to a concentration camp
Anti-semitism
Racial cleansing begun as soon as the legal revolution was completed - 1934
CRUCIAL: Persecution of the Jews assumed two forms: legal and illegal
- Legally - Nuremberg laws of 1935 -> Marriages and extramarital sexual relations between Jews and subjects of German or related blood, marriages between Hews and Germans - IMPORTANT: Proclaimed Jews were subject of the state, not citizens. Difference: subjects only had duties and not rights. Jews were also subjected to public abuse, violence and constant discrimination*
9th November 1938 → Kristallnacht (Night of Broken Glass) thousand of Jews owned stores, synagogue, and shops where smashed and burned throughout Germany by soldiers and party mobs. Jews dead and thousands arrested the following day.
Propaganda
BASE: communication was based on the same symbols repeated over and over. These symbols became clear ideological connections for Hitler’s followers and for the Germans
Swastika is considered a race emblem of Germanism and an anti-semitic symbol, it was against everything which wasn’t Aryan. However, originally -> most ancient symbol of human history (India) -> positive meaning, good luck
The Germany swastika hooks were pointed anti clockwise to represent death
The original swastika hooks were pointing clockwise to represent the rise of the sun
Eagle -> considered a symbol of the power of the 3rd Reich. Eagle ≠ Nazi symbol (Ancient Rome, Holy Roman Empire, US)
Red flag - Mein Kampf - "As National Socialists, we see our program in our flag. In red -> social idea of the movement; in white -> nationalistic idea; in the swastika -> mission of the struggle for the victory of the Aryan man, and, by the same token, the victory of the idea of creative work”
POST WW2 CONSTITUTIONAL SYSTEM
Constitution of the Federal Republic of 1949 made good another shortcoming of the Weimar era by severely restricting the power of the president, thus eliminating the possibility of dictatorial rule.
ARTICLE 20 of the same Constitution called the country a 'democratic and social federal state'
ARTICLE 21 - Parties that combat the 'free democratic basic order' were declared unconstitutional
ARTICLE 100 attributed the review to special constitutional courts