Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Topic 7 IDEOLOGY (Modernism - Post-Modernism - Relativism - Meta…
Topic 7
IDEOLOGY (Modernism - Post-Modernism - Relativism - Meta-Modernism)
Defining Ideology
Overview of Ideology
Ideology encompasses values, beliefs, concepts, and theoretical systems
Ideology evolves with societal changes, aiming to explain and shape social reality
Constituent factors
values, belief systems, political concepts, cultural traditions
It guides social, political, and cultural behaviors
Modern dissemination through various media channels, impacting daily life and thoughts
Philosophical Conceptualization of Ideology Discourse
Philosophical Thoughts on Ideology and Ideological Identity
Ideological identity
Individual or group's belonging to an ideology
Some see ideology as the basis of identity, promoting social cohesion
Others argue identity can influence ideology, shaped by individual and social factors
Example
Primitive societies' religious rituals influenced individual and societal identity
Philosophical Analysis of Ideology and Power
Others argue ideology can challenge and constrain power, driving social change
The relationship between ideology and power involves both domination and challenge
Some view ideology as a tool of power, shaping and controlling society
Philosophical analysis aids in understanding power dynamics and socio-political development
Ideology's relationship with power is complex
Example
Political ideologies used to consolidate rulers' legitimacy and restrict freedom of speech
Philosophical Debate on Ideology and Ideological Consciousness
Some view ideology as dominant over ideological consciousness, shaping thoughts and values
Others argue that ideological consciousness can influence and shape ideology, considering individual cognition and choice
Ideological consciousness
Individual's acceptance of ideology
Example
Language ideology shapes language use and structure based on societal projects
Ideology
System of ideas shaping social reality and future development
Different Scholars' Interpretation of Ideology
Chinese Scholars' Views
Critical Views
Overemphasis on political ideology may hinder innovation and social progress
Concerns about ideological homogenization restricting individual freedom and cultural pluralism
Emphasis on traditional Chinese culture's influence on ideology, advocating for its integration with contemporary ideology
Affirmative Views
Socialist ideology with Chinese characteristics is vital for China's stability and development
Emphasize the importance of adhering to socialist ideology for national prosperity
Western and Other Countries' Scholars' Viewpoints
Critical Views
Ideology can be manipulated for political and economic interests, leading to social division and conflict
Warns against ideological homogenization stifling individual freedom and societal innovation
Concerns about globalization's impact on ideology, advocating for mutual understanding and integration while respecting local cultures
Affirmative Views
Ideological diversity fosters social progress, cultural exchange, and pluralism
Ideology remains significant in modern society, impacting politics, social development, and culture
Scholars worldwide present diverse views on ideology, reflecting its complex role in society and providing rich theoretical resources for ideological development and construction
HISTORY OF IDEAS
Modern Era
Humanism
Emphasis on human values and dignity
Development of human rights and democracy
Individualism
Stress on individual rights and autonomy
Challenge to traditional social hierarchy
Secularism
Separation of religion and politics
Promotion of religious freedom and political autonomy
Example
Declaration of Human Rights during the French Revolution
Medieval Era (Dogmatism)
Emphasis on religious doctrines and authority
Persecution of heretics, hindering scientific progress
Church dominance in political and social life
Example
Church's rejection of Copernicus's heliocentric theory
Post-modern Era
Subjectivism
Importance of individual experience in value judgment
Skepticism
Questioning the reliability of knowledge and truth
Relativism
Emphasis on cultural diversity and subjective truth
Example
Foucault's "power knowledge" concept challenging traditional historical narratives.
Enlightenment Rationalism
Background
Advances in Science and Technology
Impact of World Wars
Industrialization and urbanization
Characteristics
Objectivity, rationality, and analytical approach. Emphasizes individualism and hierarchical organization
Development
Emerged in 18th-century Europe, emphasizing reason, science, and freedom
Postmodernism
Characteristics
Anti-realism, subjectivity, skepticism towards modernity. Rejects universal truths and hierarchical structures
Impact
Challenges traditional authority, values, and cultural identity. Blurs boundaries between high and low culture
Background
Arises in the late 20th century amidst social and cultural changes, scientific revolution, globalization, and consumerism
Religion
Gellner's Perspective
Transformation in Modern Society
Religion may manifest more as a cultural phenomenon
Role in Providing Meaning
Despite relativity, religion can still offer meaning and moral guidance
Skepticism of Traditional Beliefs
Postmodernism prompts skepticism of traditional religious beliefs
Conclusion
Religion remains significant in modern society, serving cultural and social functions despite challenges from postmodernism
MODERN
Scholars and Main Ideas
John Locke
Developed principles of liberalism and social contract. Advocated for individual rights and consent of governed. Ideas embedded in modern constitutions and political debates
Jürgen Habermas
Theory of communicative action highlighted role of rational discourse in democracy. Emphasized communication and mutual understanding in political theory
Immanuel Kant
Emphasized primacy of reason. Critical philosophy revolutionized understanding of knowledge and perception. Moral philosophy laid groundwork for ethical theory and human rights
Charles Taylor
Explored complexities of modern identity formation. Highlighted narrative nature of identity and interplay between personal and social structures
Examples
Scientific Revolution
Shift towards empirical observation and rational inquiry. Exemplified by works of Sir Isaac Newton. Pioneered methodological approach to understand universe
Modernist Art
Response to cultural shifts of Enlightenment. Embraced abstract and fragmented perspective. Challenged traditional aesthetic values and explored new styles and themes
Foundational Principles of the United States
Influenced by Enlightenment ideals of liberty, democracy, and science. Emphasized checks and balances, protection of individual freedoms
Meaning and Explanation
Characteristics
Emphasis on reason, science, and individualism
Rational thought as primary tool for advancement
Departure from medieval mindset
Impact
Advancements in science, technology, and governance. Tangible improvements in living standards
Context
Linked to the Enlightenment period (late 17th to early 19th century)
POST-MODERN
Scholars and Main Ideas
Jacques Derrida
Introduced deconstruction. Questions stability and coherence of texts. Emphasizes multiple interpretations and challenges single, definitive truth
Michel Foucault
Explored power and knowledge. Revealed power dynamics in defining truth. Concept of 'epistemes' dismantles notion of objective knowledge
Jean-François Lyotard
"The Postmodern Condition." Critically examines transformation into postmodernism. Argues for plurality of localized narratives over grand modernist narratives
Examples
Literature
Use of metafiction, pastiche, and non-linear storytelling. Challenges traditional narrative form and authority of narrator
Philosophy
Embraces localized, contextual, and fragmented knowledge. Critically examines power dynamics in knowledge production
Architecture
Departure from modernist design towards complexity, eclecticism, and irony. Integration of historical styles in unexpected ways
Meaning and Explanation
Characteristics
Pluralism and skepticism
Truth and knowledge as constructs shaped by social interactions and cultural contexts
Critique of Modernism
Questions absolute truths and reliability of singular narratives
Departure from Modernity
Challenges foundational principles of progress, objective truth, and rationality
META-MODERN
Scholars and Main Ideas
Robin van den Akker, Alison Gibbons, and Timotheus Vermeulen
Introduced metamodernism as dynamic interplay between modern enthusiasm and postmodern skepticism. Emphasized oscillation between earnestness and irony
Jason Ānanda Josephson Storm
Advocated for pragmatic and pluralistic approach to knowledge. Critiqued postmodern rejection of grand narratives
Examples
Visual Arts
Integrates traditional techniques with digital media. Artists like Olafur Eliasson merge past and future artistic practices, reflecting nostalgia and innovation
Architecture
Blends historical influences with futuristic designs. Architects like Bjarke Ingels honor traditional architectural elements while incorporating innovative concepts
Literature
Juxtaposes earnest narratives with postmodern skepticism. Authors like David Foster Wallace blend sincere storytelling with reflective critique
Music
Blends classical genres with contemporary sounds. Composers like Max Richter create compositions that resonate with emotional and intellectual experiences
Meaning and Explanation
Balance Between Modernism and Postmodernism
Bridges cynicism of postmodernism and quest for truth of modernism
Characteristics
Oscillation between sincerity and irony, hope and melancholy
Synthesizing complexity without succumbing to despair
Comparing Modern and Post-Modern
Similarities
Products of their eras, influenced by modern science and technology
Continuation and rebellion against tradition
Differences
Social Background
Modernism: Emerged from industrial civilization in late 19th to early 20th century Europe and the US
Postmodernism: Arisen from contradictions in post-industrial society since the 1960s
Philosophical Basis
Postmodernism: Irrationalism, deconstructionism
Modernism: Rationalism, realism
Ideology
Postmodernism: Opposes rational supremacy, questions science, relative truth, personal narratives, deconstructionism, pluralism
Modernism: Emphasizes rationality, science, universal truth, grand narratives, structuralism
Human Subjectivity
Modernism: Self-centered, pursuit of individuality and ego
Postmodernism: Opposes centers, emphasizes centerless consciousness
Impact on Social Development
Postmodernism: Questions traditional structures, emphasizes decentralization, diversity, promotes social pluralism
Modernism: Favors centralized, standardized organizations, promotes urbanization, and modernization
Culture and Art
Modernism: Pursues simplicity, functionality, rationalization, abstract and minimalist styles, deep meanings, cultural sophistication
Postmodernism: Emphasizes complexity, hybridity, diversified forms, cultural mobility, flat culture without depth, opposes deeper meanings, reduced uniqueness
Relativism as a Challenge
Philosophical and Humanities Impact
Influenced existentialism and constructivism, emphasizing subjective human experience and meaning construction
Controversy and Criticism
Criticized for eroding objective truth and moral values, but also fosters multiculturalism and social tolerance
Impact on Understanding
Einstein's theory of relativity subverted Newtonian mechanics, revolutionizing understanding of time and space
Scientific Methodology
Challenges objective facts, emphasizing subjective nature of observations and experimental results
Introduction
Relativism challenges traditional cognitive methods and worldviews
Conclusion
While challenging, relativism fosters humility, openness, and respect for diverse perspectives
Tradition/Religion as a Response to Postmodernist Relativism
Interfaith Dialogue
Engages in dialogue and cooperation to address common concerns while respecting diversity
Flexible Spirituality
Embraces personal experience and spiritual autonomy, drawing from diverse sources
Assertion of Absolute Truths
Religion asserts absolute truths or divine principles transcending individual perspectives
Social Justice and Ethical Activism
Demonstrates commitment to universal principles of justice and compassion beyond religious differences
Tradition/Religion as a Response to Postmodernist Relativism
Interfaith Dialogue
Engages in dialogue and cooperation to address common concerns while respecting diversity
Flexible Spirituality
Embraces personal experience and spiritual autonomy, drawing from diverse sources
Assertion of Absolute Truths
Religion asserts absolute truths or divine principles transcending individual perspectives
Social Justice and Ethical Activism
Demonstrates commitment to universal principles of justice and compassion beyond religious differences