Foundations in International Relations Revision (Main)

two types of wars: wars of rivalry (wars between equals) and wars of inequality (wars between unequals)

wars in the 19th century- Afghan Persian war, American civil war, Spanish-American war, Boer war, Napoleonic wars.

women leaders in the 21st century- Jacinda Arden, Michele Bachelet, Helen Clarke, Portia Simpson Smith.

sovereignty gaps in weak states-> leads to bargaining failure

international organisations- have the ability to shape international politics, we want them to have their own agenda and not have states shape them.


examples-
congress of vienna
international telegraph union
league of nations
UN


UNSC- 5 permanent members, 10 elected members
5- UK, Russia, China, US, France


they:
maintain peace
solve any disputes with meetings
recommend methods of adjusting
regulate ammdendemnts


they also chapter 2-
apply economic sanctions
military action against aggressors
exercise trusteeship with UN
elect judges for CoJ
242 vetos 1946-90
68-1991-23

biological weapons- plague-infested corpses used by Mongols in Ukraine in 1937
biological weapons convention 1972


nuclear weapons- 1945 Manhattan project


chemical weapons- Sarin and Ricin are used today. Mustard gas used in World War 1
they contain toxic components


NPT- is an organisation that developed to stop the use of nuclear weapons
it consists of 3 elements

  1. those without nuclear weapons should not acquire them
  2. those with nuclear weapons should dismantle them
  3. states can access nuclear weapons only for peaceful purposes

191 countries joined in 2016
non parties- India, cuba, Pakistan, isreal
withdrawn- north Korea


sagan argues there are 3 elements as to why states uses nuclear weapons

  1. incase of forgein threats
  2. for domestic parties: military, politicians, nuclear energy establishments
  3. norms model: nuclear symbolism (France)

Doyle offers 4 criteria for democracy- 1. market economy, 2. recognition as sovereign, 3. citizens have judicial rights, 4. governments as representatives

Bueno de Mesquita- democracies tend to shift resources to winning wars
constructivists believe- some states create friends/ enemies by interfering aggression or defensiveness for their domestic structures.


Rosato- argues for imperial peace (peace achieved through hegemony)
Gilber- argues for territorial peace (land can prevent armed conflicts from reoccurring)


Wood and Ramirez- patriarchal structures & rapid gendee hierachies increase a country's propensity for conflict.


Goldstein- no biological reason whymen have been the fighters in history.

Status quo state- state that tries to maintain the international law and free market capitalism.
examples: UK, France, Japan


Revisionist state- states who's objective it is to change or put an end to the current system. term from power transition theory.
examples: Russia, North Korea, Iran.

Gross domestic product- measures monetary value of final goods and services


Human development index- measures health, knowledge and standard of living


good governance depends on two ideas

  • political leaders remain acountable
  • market enhancing to protect property rights

non state actors who remain a big concern today:
ISIS
IRA
Boko Haram

Congo- First Congo war: AFDL invades - rebel coalition backed by Rwanda
Mobutu flees
AFDL seizes capital in 6 months


Second Congo war-
Kabila turns on backers
Kabila offers resources to neighbouring countries
Kabila assassinated in 2001, replaced by Son Joseph
series of peace agreements developed


Post Congo-
proliferation of low level conflict in hinterland regions
10 billion spent on UN peacekeeping

common variable linked to conflict:


states- weak and difficult to govern
poverty, unemployment, poor education


variable associated with conflict:

  1. political and economic inequalities
  2. cenyralised- majoritarian system-> minorities excluded

case study- Congo
relentless population
armed militias
soill over from genocides in Rwanda


problems facing Congo-
illegal exploitation of minerals
congelse commit horrific violations of human rights
human index dropped 20

Gordon and Paterson found 3 possibilities cooperation/ condolidation
inhoherence
all come apart and conflict

Edinger- the expansion of Nato backed Russia into a corner
Got and Shaun- draws on constructivism, strategic culture specifically
Oksamyta- the invasion was driven by Russia imperliasm and the desire to re-establish control over Ukraine.

problems of state weakness-

  1. Arbitrary & fixed problems- competition of land (heightened)


    taxation (waging war)


    19c colonisation 18c decolonisation


    sovereignty equated


  2. unfavourable structural features


    large but low population density


    difficult terrain


    high costs (build infrastructure)

international conferences to help environment: UN conference on human environment 1972
Bruntland commision 1987
UN conference on environmental and development 1992
UN climate change conference 2015

we live in an Anthropocene era

4 phrases- recognition, negotiation, implmemt, amendemnets

Paterson argues to- destroy state systems, destroy capitalism, destroy scientific knowledge and destroy patriarchy and we will break suffering.

ozone layer regime led to- Vienna Convention 1985
Montreal protocol 1987
and a mutilateral system was set up
197 states joined

Wallerstein adds semi- periphery economic divisions of labour & exploitation:
core
semi- periphery
periphery

a taboo is a prohibitionary norm, for example producing pork in some religions is forbiden


nuclear taboo 2 dimensions:
objective: refers to danger, serious consequence expected if violated
intersubjective: it is a taboo because people believe it is

Paul finds nuclear weapons a tradition rather than a taboo- he gives 5 reasons

  1. issue of explicitness and unthinkiness-
  2. deliberate use wasn't 'beyond the pale' out of the ordinary in crises such as Korea against china and vietnam
  3. if there were a taboo nuclear weapons wouldn't be a reasonable reaction
  4. taboo is a social response to other states
  5. taboo is rigid and cant capture evolution

extras

the unipolar era- is a system in which one state is significantly more powerful than any other waltx expected bipolarity-. cold war- US v USSR


in 1992 US spent $592 billion in defence and $1.2 trillion globally


Wohlforth- unipolarity is likely to be both peaceful and durable


Monetrio- argues unipolarity isn't peaceful and offers a theory only on unipolar politics

Model 1- Geo-economic competition (regional economic blocs)


model 2- return of multipolarity (c21st looks like c18 and c19)


model 3- a new bipolarity (US & China shape politics)


model 4- democratic peace (liberal order expands)


model 5- clash of civilians


model 6- global frature (pre modern, modern and post modern states emerge)


model 7- global social crisis (struggle to cope problems and try prompt new social movements)

Modernisation- relates to understanding issues of economic and social development and in creating policies that would assist economic and social transitions in poorer countries


optimistic- states of development towards industrialisation and democracy (modernity)


psimistic- difficult to maintain order in countries undergoing social transformation -> authoritarianism


enduring relevance- economic development-> democratisation


states were supporting military dictatorship against communist interventions




COUNTER ARGUMENT-
Dependency theory- its the idea that resources flow from a 'periphery' of poor and exploited states to a 'core' of wealthy states

Foundations in international relations (not main)

states: ' a political entity with territorial boarders and political authorities who enjoy sovereignty'.


sovereignty: the capacity to govern residents within a given territory to establish relationships with governments that control other states.


imperialism: a state strategy in which one country conquers foreign lands to turns them into colonies



Grieco- argued that 4 factors made European states successful imperalists:


a) superior technologies
b) economic base
c) europe as a competitive environment
d) temperature climate (resistance to disease)



Habermas- two pathways

  • evolution of nation - states within existing territorial sates
  • establishing a nation THEN a state

The treaty of Westphalia- the treaty of Westphalia brought to an end the 30 years war between protestant and catholic powers in Europe


it is argued to be seen as representing a movement from the religious to the senior


Krasner argues that the westphalian sovereign state model is based on principles of 'autonomy, territory, mutual recognition and control


there has ben critiques such as:
its failure to account properly for difference and placing the word other in understanding questions of sovereignty


while westphalia is establishment of sovereignty and political equality of states
European states exerted power over territories and populations elsewhere and rarely addressed literature.



krasner points to EU and Andorra as examples of how the sovereign states model is violated in territorial terms


Anthony Anghie argues that within the model, sovereignty is seen as to be the primary concept in eterming the nature of relations among states and the fact of being a modern nation state. However, it ignores the exercise of power of these states over societies






theories- Realism- assumes that interests are to be maintained through the exercise of power and that the world is characterised by competing power base. they argue the nation-state is the relevant agent


positivism- based upon positive knowledge and empirical sciences verify their characteristics


interpretivism- emphasises the importance of subjective views, emotions, values and opinions


pragmatism- focuses on conversational implicature which is a process in which the speaker implies and listener infers


rationalism- is the idea that knowledge can be acquired through reason alone


post modernism- are skeptical of explanations which claim to be valid for all groups, cultures, traditions, or races and instead focuses on the relative truths of each person.

constructivism- learns conduct knowledge rather than just passively taking in knowledge


Piaget- indicated that humans create knowledge through the interaction between experiences and ideas


post-colonialism- the political or cultural conditions of a former colony.


imperialism- state policy, practice or advocacy of extending power and dominion by direct territorial acquisition

increase in non-state violence: illegal exploitation of resources is the main cause of sexual abuse and violence


privitisation


many challenges emerged from expanding human activities:

  • population increase
  • extinctions
    -destruction of habitats
    -pollution
  • pandemics
    -destruction of ozone layer


earths temperature must stay below 1.5 if not:
glaciers melt
sea levels rise
disappearance of islands
droughts
migration


climate chnage- greenhouse gases are needed to make planet habitable since 19thc there has been a rapid build up from 280-399 in 1991

Goertz two rival categories
positive peace- warm peace and security communities
negative peace

Deterrance theory argues that peace is kept through maintaining credible threats against one opposition. Wars occur due to lack of credibility


Waltz gives 6 reasons for cautious nuclear proliferation


  1. call states obtaining nuclear weapons won't change US and USSR's superiority


  2. US and USSR behaved with nuclear weapons


  3. bipolar world


  4. nuclear weapons make miscalculations due to the amount of damage they cause


  5. used for defernce


  6. new states will feel constraints that old states have done