New Deal Depth Study
Trade Unions
Women
African Americans
Native Americans
ND Benefitted NAs
ND Harmed NAs
People Responsible for Progress
Wheeler Howard Act 1934, gave NAs a greater role in running their reservations
Greater religious freedom, largely attributed to John Collier - appointed by Roosevelt as commissioner for Indian Affairs
Overthrew a 1883 law that banned ceremonial dances
IRA curtailed the sale of land to individual buyers, 1900-1930 Indians lost over 50% of land
Unallocated land lost during this period was given back
Actions of Collier
NA increasingly involved in BIA
still under direction of federal officials
IRA extended political rights to NA women
Gave them opportunity to train for domestic work, good intent but not what they wanted
Work stimulated national interest in Indian art, encouraged women's cooperatives to produce them as an economic venture
NA women encouraged to attend higher education
Gladys Tantaquidgeon studied at uni of PA, worked for Indian Bureau in 30s
Collier used agencies to build hospitals, schools, irrigation systems on reservations to improve conditions
Actions whilst good intent were misguided, didn't have support of NAs, IRA legal issues were alien to them
General Benefits
IRA protected Natives right to practice religion and culture
NA children allowed to attend local schools to learn their culture
IRA stopped sale of NA land, recovered many acres of lost tribal land
Farming training provided
Allotment policy abandoned
1938 census stats showed NA population increasing at faster rate than national rate
Poverty still an issue
Tribes still organised into tribal councils, 75/245 tribes rejected the measures
Secret ballot introduced among tribes to determine if IRA was accepted, BUT idea of democracy was alien
Post WW2 improvements weren't maintained, at best they were short term benefits
100,000 indians forced to leave homes in WW2, majority moved to urban areas to work in defence industries
Returning indian soldiers from WW2 forced back onto reservations, discrimination, prevented from taking advantage of educational opportunities as American war vets
those who stayed on reservatiions experienced hardship, no money or resources due to war effort
Federal Government
Wheeler Howard Act 1934
Does try and improve position of NAs but also pushes towards assimilation - theme of fed gov in this period
Sought to give NA greater role in administration of their reservations
ND saw efforts. of government to aid NAs in ways they wanted
IRA gives religious freedom, Social advancement!
Indian Arts and Crafts Act 1935 - recognised the importance of NA art, gave it protection
CCC - 1932-1942 NA men work on roads, forest management etc, provided decent income
Developed infrastructure on reservations, WPA and PWA funded
NAs themselves
NA more involved in BIA
100,000 left homesteads during WW2 - army and urban industry
After WW2, soldiers forced back onto reservations - factory workers driven back by discrimination (reversed progress)
No unity
Didn't have any strength to fight back against changes
Took people to court in some cases
Gladys Tantaquidgeon, worked with BIA, gave social service benefits to NAs under WHEELER HOWARD ACT
AMERICAN INDIAN FEDERATION and INDIAN RIGHTS ASSOCIATION
John Collier
instrumental in passing of IRA
Appointed commissioner of Indian Affairs in 1933
Helped Pueblo Indians retain some of their land
General Position
Politically
Socially
Economically
Influenced by media and newspapers, husband, union membership family etc
Influenced by friends, social class, Great Depression, birth control, education, religion, witnessed FLAPPER ERA so seen benefits of female integration
Influenced by unions, jobs, age and no. of children, single or married lives in country or city
Key Figures
Eleanor Roosevelt
'First Lady of the World'
fought against First Lady expectations, powerful, independent role model
involved in formation of national youth administration, founded 1935
Inspected ND programmes in the South. acknowledged discrimination to AAs
Despite her presence, still only 146 women in state legislatures and by 1939 only 2 female state governors
Mary Dewson
Brought large number of women into party politics
Placed many women in high ranking position in the Roosevelt administration
Helped enact first minimum wage law in MA
Major role in 1932 presidential campaign, persuaded people to vote Roosevelt
1934, served on advisory council to FDR's committee on economic security
Believed ND to be best hope to protect working women in industry
Frances Perkins
Served as US secretary of Labour during FDR term being the first woman to do so
Social worker after graduating from college in 1902
Studied further in social econ at uni of PA and Columbia
Advocate for unemployment insurance and close government
Pushed for minimum wage, limited employment of U16s, creation of the CCC
Supervised Fair Labour Standards Act 1938 and helped draft Social Security Act 1935 (aid for mothers and children)
Built the Department of Labour and strengthened Bureau of Labour Statistics
National Women's Party
Pre New Deal
Post New Deal
NWP used legal lobbying and mobilisation campaigns to advance equal rights
Following ratification of the 19th amendment, the NWP moved on to fight for full Constitutional equality for women through the ERA
1931 - NWP supported Congress to pass revisions to 1922 Cable Act, expanding naturalisation and citizenship rights
1932 - For only second time since ERA introduced in 1923, House Judiciary Committee holds hearings on ammendment
1933 - Elaborate memorial service attended by more than 1,000 women
1934 - Equal National Treaty, drafted by Alice Paul, signed into law by Roosevelt
How far it improved position of women
Positives
Negatives
1935 Social Security Act supported married women struggling to bring up children in the Depression Provided Aid
1930 to 1940, 300% rise in unionised female labour. More married women working in 1940 than 1930
Women appointed into politics to run new deal agencies
first female Appeal Court Judge Florence Allen
Overseas ambassador Ruth Brian Owen
Nellie Taylor Ross, first female director of US Mint
Roosevelt administration was sympathetic to reforming organisations
Federal Emergency Relief Act 1933 - financial assistance to women, refuge for homeless
Combated legislation that prevented work for married women
Fair Labour Standards Act 1938 and 1933 NRA put limits on working hours and supported womens minimum wage
Gender discrimination still normal, NRA 1933 lowered pay for women
Getting men back to work after great depression was prioritised
1936 Gallup Poll - 90% believed married women shouldnt have jobs if husband did
Women still restricted to stereotypical roles within gov. social policy, family matters etc
1937 Farm Security Act, improved conditions for poor Southern farmers, little to combat traditional unfairness of rural life for women
Northern urban women saw improvements, rural southern women still oppressed by damaging traditionalist attitudes
Positives Summary
Negatives Summary
By 1935, 30% of AAs were on relief benefits compared to 10% of whites (fair application to both)
Composition of SC began to change
Between 1937 and 1941, 7 out of 9 justices were replaced and verdicts became more favourable
Gaines V Canada 1938 stated that separate but equal facilities must be equal in practice
Court still didnt challenge Plessy V Ferguson 1896
Climate of North liberal opinion was now rejecting past discriminatory attitudes
legal challenges of the NAACP showed progress, though limited
Roosevelt relied on Southern Democratic support so his relief for AAs was limited, prioritised 'Saving America'
Success of NAACP was limited, despite vigorous campaigning by Walter White
No charismatic leader emerged after Garvey's imprisonment in 1925 and deportation by Coolidge in 1927
Exclusion of Black voting in the South, all white juries often didn't give AAs justice
Housing conditions very primitive in ghettos, De Facto segregation remained in the South
Roosevelt refused to have lynching debated in Congress in 1933, despite 1,886 occurring between 1900-1930
AA sharecroppers hit hard by depression, not covered by Wagner Act 1935, or Fair Labour Standards Act 1938
Black Stories and Culture
1935 FTP - federal theatre project
Aaron Douglas and Harlem Renaissance
CCC
1935 FWP - federal writers project
AAA 1933
Scottsboro Boys 1931
TVA - Tennessee Valley Administration
funded live artistic performances and entertainment
Sponsored by WPA
Had a specific "Help Negro" section
employment to black directors and actors - major help for black culture
Set up in 23 cities
employed black writers and playwritghts
Lasted until 1942
Produced publications: black community history
helped launch careers of AA writers e.g. Margaret Walker, Frank Kerby
Virginia negro studies project employed 16 AA writers, led to publication of The Negro in Virginia in 1940
influential visual artist in the Harlem Renaissance
Painted murals addressing social issues at the time around segregation
Harlem Renaissance golden age for black culture (1934)
Black pride movement - Du Bois worked to make sure they got credit for their contributions to society
Explosion of Black music, e.g. Jazz, Louis Armstrong
Set up and built dams along Tennessee valley
Covered parts of 7 Southern states
Gave jobs to unemployed AA men
Brought local industry to the South, set economic recovery in motion
Settlement built for RVA workers (Norris), AAs excluded
Racist employment - 12 counties around Norris, 1.9% of employees were AA, despite making up 7.2% of population
9 AA teenagers wrongfully accused of raping 2 white women
Southern railroad freight train, Alabama
AA boys arrested, 8 of them sentenced to death, poor defence for them in front of all white jury
Communist party and NAACP both appealed the case
One alleged victim admits fabricating story, jury still finds boys guilty
Another trial held, 4/9 found guilty and sentenced to 75years/death
Boys either spent whole lives in prison, hiding from police, or on death row
shows how racist the legal system was
sets up precedent for mixed juries - Norris V. Alabama 1935
Agricultural Adjustment Act
Authorised gov to set production quotas for crops, gov payed farmers to plant less to raise fair prices
1933 gov orders more than 6 million pigs slaughtered
ignored sharecroppers, Act encouraged eviction of thousands of poor tenants and sharecroppers
40% of AA workers were sharecroppers/tenants so hit them hard
AAA policies forced more than 100,000 AAs off farming land in 1933 and 34
Roosevelt needed Southern Democrat support, ignored positive race legislation
Product of Emergency Conservation Act 1933
Decrease unemployment by getting workers employed in conservation efforts, e.g. forests
Programme ran from 1933 to 1942, 3 million workers passed through
Gov wages, $30/month
Onlu 200,000 AAs served
1935, all CCC camps were ordered to segregate, 150 total
Leader of CCC (Fechner), lot of resistance to AAs in higher roles - little employment of AAs
E.g. LA - 150 AA men worked in high intensity construction labour whilst white workers got less intense special projects appointed to them
Positive Summary
Negative Summary
More government legislation
reduced clashes between workers and bosses and thus maintained production levels
gave workers right to take part in union and take up collective bargaining
allowed closed shops and established minimum wage
prevented companies from using blacklist or company unions
reduced power of employers and therefore limited the restrictions they could place on workers
Growth in membership after new deal, suggests gov had crucial role in union advancement
Roosevelt advocated for more recognition of the regular American, more willingness to embark on impact of Great Dep
Many unskilled workers didn't have rights, workers in mass production missed out on gains that other workers recieved
Ethnic minorities, AAs, Mexicans all still in vulnerable position
Benefitted industrial workers more than farm tenants, men more than women and whites more than blacks
Roosevelt reluctant to increase the power of workers
New Deal Legislation
Achievements of New Deal
Resettlement Administration
Federal Housing Administration
Ratification of 21A which repealed prohibition
Transformed fed. gov. role, gave relief to millions, constructed numerous public facilities
Public employment rescued millions of Americans from the Great Depression
10million/20% workforce remained unemployed when 1934 ended
1935 Wagner Act
1933 NRA
1933 Agricultural Adjustment Act
1933-42 CCC
1935 Social Security Act
1938 Fair Labour Standards Act
1935 WPA (Works Progress Administration)
Publics Works Project
recognised workers rights to join unions and collective bargaining
Encouraged firms to agree to codes of practice, set bases for work rates, hours, wages
Section 1 focused on industrial recovery and establishing better workers rights, Section 2 was all about PUBLIC WORKS ADMINISTRATION
S2 - funding for states to try and reduce unemployment
Had Limitations
Authorised separate and lower pay scale for AAs, whites got first dibs on new jobs
Many employers ignored right to join unions and collective bargaining, e.g. Henry Ford
SC declared it UNCONSTITUTIONAL in Schechter v. US in 1935 so all gains were reversed
gave too much power to executive branch, violated constitutional separation of powers
Set unemployed men to work on projects such as flood control
Major contribution to AA enhancement
By end of programme, 3million had passed through $30/month
Payed farmers to plant less crops in order to raise better prices, set production quotas
Encouraged the eviction of sharecroppers and tenants as it prioritised economic value of farm land owners rather than those who worked on it
Invalidated in 1936 by SC case US v. Butler, declared an unconstitutional exercise of executive power over economic problems
Established NLRB
Negotiated on behalf of unions and prevented large companies from creating their own unions
Investigated reports of unfair labour practices, workers given rights to join unions elect own representatives
Act declared constitutional and recognised formation of unions, led to a huge sore in membership
3.7 million in 1933 to 9 million in 1938
Sit in Strike in 1936 recognised the United Automobile Workers Union
Had Limitations as well
Steel workers organising committee recognised by US Steel in 1937
NLRB didn't give same rights to farm workers as it did to others
Made labour union monopolies legal, bigger ones discriminated against AAs such as the AFL
Drafted with aim to prohibit racial discrimination but AFL lobbied against it
Excluded job categories that AAs typically filled
Unemployed insurance, old age pensions, aid to the young, elderly and disabled was all provided
represented massive departure to how the government usually functions
Hybrid of local and national funding and eligibility
Gave workers a minimum wage
Didn't apply to domestic and agricultural workers, WOMEN & AAS EXCULUDED
Employment and infrastructure budget, $5 billion
Put 8.5 million Americans to work building schools, hospitals and other public services
Employed mostly unskilled men
Built more than 4000 new school buildings and 130 new hospitals
Also oversaw the FWP (See AA section)
contracted with other companies to build schools, hospitals and other public facilities
CWA hired 4 million for the project, dissolved due to the complaints that the ND created millions of Americans dependent on the government for jobs
Grande Coule Dam started in 1941, key to develping power near the Columbian river
Transformed American landscape and economy
Regional development promoted large economic growth, 80cents/hour largest in nation
TVA - public works initiative
series of damn along the Tennessee river to prevent flooding
hopes for large economic growth
improved life of Southerners and spurred economic development out west
Strikes
2000 strikes in 1934, Toledo SF general strike saw 200 injured and 2 killed over employers refusing to negotiate wages
1934 walkout of Longsure men shut down ports from San Diego to Bellingham for 83 days, shut down trade on the coast
Seattle newspaper strike of 1936, white collar workers, employer refuses to negotiate sees the walkout and shut down of work for 3.5 months
HOWEVER
not all workers benefitted, agricultural workers missed out on basically evverything
workers in mass production missed out on gains made
Lower paying jobs, those in the most need, didnt receive the benefits they needed
Attempt to aid farm workers had to wait until the 60s in California with the work of Cesar Chavez