Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
New Deal Depth Study - Coggle Diagram
New Deal Depth Study
Trade Unions
Positive Summary
-
-
Growth in membership after new deal, suggests gov had crucial role in union advancement
Roosevelt advocated for more recognition of the regular American, more willingness to embark on impact of Great Dep
Negative Summary
Many unskilled workers didn't have rights, workers in mass production missed out on gains that other workers recieved
Ethnic minorities, AAs, Mexicans all still in vulnerable position
Benefitted industrial workers more than farm tenants, men more than women and whites more than blacks
-
New Deal Legislation
Achievements of New Deal
-
-
-
Transformed fed. gov. role, gave relief to millions, constructed numerous public facilities
-
-
1935 Wagner Act
Established NLRB
-
Investigated reports of unfair labour practices, workers given rights to join unions elect own representatives
Act declared constitutional and recognised formation of unions, led to a huge sore in membership
-
-
Had Limitations as well
-
Made labour union monopolies legal, bigger ones discriminated against AAs such as the AFL
-
-
1933 NRA
-
Encouraged firms to agree to codes of practice, set bases for work rates, hours, wages
Section 1 focused on industrial recovery and establishing better workers rights, Section 2 was all about PUBLIC WORKS ADMINISTRATION
-
Had Limitations
Authorised separate and lower pay scale for AAs, whites got first dibs on new jobs
Many employers ignored right to join unions and collective bargaining, e.g. Henry Ford
-
-
1933-42 CCC
-
-
By end of programme, 3million had passed through $30/month
1935 Social Security Act
-
Unemployed insurance, old age pensions, aid to the young, elderly and disabled was all provided
-
-
-
-
Publics Works Project
contracted with other companies to build schools, hospitals and other public facilities
CWA hired 4 million for the project, dissolved due to the complaints that the ND created millions of Americans dependent on the government for jobs
Grande Coule Dam started in 1941, key to develping power near the Columbian river
-
Regional development promoted large economic growth, 80cents/hour largest in nation
-
Strikes
2000 strikes in 1934, Toledo SF general strike saw 200 injured and 2 killed over employers refusing to negotiate wages
1934 walkout of Longsure men shut down ports from San Diego to Bellingham for 83 days, shut down trade on the coast
Seattle newspaper strike of 1936, white collar workers, employer refuses to negotiate sees the walkout and shut down of work for 3.5 months
HOWEVER
not all workers benefitted, agricultural workers missed out on basically evverything
-
-
Lower paying jobs, those in the most need, didnt receive the benefits they needed
Women
General Position
Politically
Influenced by media and newspapers, husband, union membership family etc
Socially
Influenced by friends, social class, Great Depression, birth control, education, religion, witnessed FLAPPER ERA so seen benefits of female integration
Economically
Influenced by unions, jobs, age and no. of children, single or married lives in country or city
Key Figures
Eleanor Roosevelt
-
fought against First Lady expectations, powerful, independent role model
involved in formation of national youth administration, founded 1935
-
Despite her presence, still only 146 women in state legislatures and by 1939 only 2 female state governors
Mary Dewson
-
-
-
Major role in 1932 presidential campaign, persuaded people to vote Roosevelt
1934, served on advisory council to FDR's committee on economic security
-
Frances Perkins
-
-
-
-
Pushed for minimum wage, limited employment of U16s, creation of the CCC
Supervised Fair Labour Standards Act 1938 and helped draft Social Security Act 1935 (aid for mothers and children)
-
National Women's Party
Pre New Deal
-
Following ratification of the 19th amendment, the NWP moved on to fight for full Constitutional equality for women through the ERA
Post New Deal
1931 - NWP supported Congress to pass revisions to 1922 Cable Act, expanding naturalisation and citizenship rights
1932 - For only second time since ERA introduced in 1923, House Judiciary Committee holds hearings on ammendment
1933 - Elaborate memorial service attended by more than 1,000 women
1934 - Equal National Treaty, drafted by Alice Paul, signed into law by Roosevelt
-
African Americans
Positives Summary
By 1935, 30% of AAs were on relief benefits compared to 10% of whites (fair application to both)
-
-
legal challenges of the NAACP showed progress, though limited
Negatives Summary
Roosevelt relied on Southern Democratic support so his relief for AAs was limited, prioritised 'Saving America'
Success of NAACP was limited, despite vigorous campaigning by Walter White
No charismatic leader emerged after Garvey's imprisonment in 1925 and deportation by Coolidge in 1927
Exclusion of Black voting in the South, all white juries often didn't give AAs justice
Housing conditions very primitive in ghettos, De Facto segregation remained in the South
Roosevelt refused to have lynching debated in Congress in 1933, despite 1,886 occurring between 1900-1930
AA sharecroppers hit hard by depression, not covered by Wagner Act 1935, or Fair Labour Standards Act 1938
-
Native Americans
ND Benefitted NAs
Wheeler Howard Act 1934, gave NAs a greater role in running their reservations
Greater religious freedom, largely attributed to John Collier - appointed by Roosevelt as commissioner for Indian Affairs
-
IRA curtailed the sale of land to individual buyers, 1900-1930 Indians lost over 50% of land
-
Actions of Collier
-
-
Work stimulated national interest in Indian art, encouraged women's cooperatives to produce them as an economic venture
-
Collier used agencies to build hospitals, schools, irrigation systems on reservations to improve conditions
Actions whilst good intent were misguided, didn't have support of NAs, IRA legal issues were alien to them
General Benefits
-
-
IRA stopped sale of NA land, recovered many acres of lost tribal land
-
-
-
ND Harmed NAs
-
Tribes still organised into tribal councils, 75/245 tribes rejected the measures
Secret ballot introduced among tribes to determine if IRA was accepted, BUT idea of democracy was alien
Post WW2 improvements weren't maintained, at best they were short term benefits
100,000 indians forced to leave homes in WW2, majority moved to urban areas to work in defence industries
those who stayed on reservatiions experienced hardship, no money or resources due to war effort
Returning indian soldiers from WW2 forced back onto reservations, discrimination, prevented from taking advantage of educational opportunities as American war vets
-