feminism
origins
movement has four waves from the 1970s to present day
patriarchy common theme for explaining female oppression
liberals wish to reform society and patriarcal elements
socialist and radical society beyond reform argue for revolution to transform society
3rd and 4th wave argue that patriarchy constantly mutating and women face complex forms of oppression - intersectionality
liberal feminism seen some success in western democracies with legislation granting equal rights
waves
second wave 1960s-1980s
third wave 1990s-2000s
first wave 1790s-1940s
fourth wave 2008-present
liberal feminism
perkins gilman
suffragists
de beauvoir
socialist feminism
radical feminists
millett
liberal feminism
radical feminism
ecofeminism
sheila rowbotham
difference feminism
socialist feminism - revolutionary
post modern - bell hooks
liberal feminism
post modern feminism
post feminism
transfeminism
everyone's invited
post modern feminism
types
socialist
radical
liberal
post modern
influenced by ideas of individualism, foundational equality and equality of opportunity
wollstonecraft - political equality - womens votes
political emancipation would lead to greater gender equality and legal equality
charlotte perkins gilman - gender differences are not natural but are the creation of men
third wave - patriarchy constantly changing and adapting in ways that oppress women
reformist and disagree with radical feminists over the omnipresence of patriarchy - possible for discrimination to be reformed in both state and society
thinkers
sheila rowbotham - socialist
kate millet - radical
charlotte perkins gilman - liberal
bell hooks - post modern
simone de beauvoir - socialist
sex versus gender - gender roles assigned to women on the basis of their sex
'otherness' men are perceived as the norm and women as deviants from this norm
all roles in society should be gender neutral
rejected concept of motherhood and idea that women had predetermined nurturing instinct - societal indoctrination
women have internalised false sense of natural inferiority
equality of opportunity
sex and domestic economics go hand in hand - for women to survive need to depend on sexuality and body in order to please their husbands
societal pressure - young girls compelled to conform in society and prepare for motherhood by playing with toys that are specifically designed for and marketed to them
biological differences were irrelevant in modern society - women intellectually equal to men - rejected social darwinism
traditional role of women in the nuclear family was comparable to slavery - communal form of living whereby child rearing would be shared - allowing women wider role in society
capitalism - women forced to sell labour to survive - use their labour to support their family under capitalism system
the family - not just and instrument for disciplining and subjecting women to capitalism but a place where men took refuge from alienation under capitalist economy
women always been oppressed - marriage is like feudalism
capitalism worsened oppression
revolution within a revolution needed to restructure capitalism and patriarchy
family - undoing traditional family key to true sexual revolution
portrayal of women in art and literature - patriarchal culture produced writers and literary works that were degrading to women
family chief institution that reinforces society
patriarchy grants men ownership over their wife and children - entrenches sexism - marriage sees women loose their identity
women portrayed as possessions of men to be fought over and owned
critical of monogamous marriage, romantic love and family unit - this trinity reinforces patriarchy - need for sexual revolution
principles
sex and gender
patriarchy
personal is political
equality and difference feminism
intersectionality
women of colour - brought cultural concerns into mainstream feminist movement
intersectionality - mainstream feminist movement had focused mostly on white, educated, middle class women had no stake in the concerns of women of colour
children socialised in gender stereotypes from young age
need to recognise plethora of female experiences in order to construct genuine conclusive sister hood
racial and sexual discrimination
debate
sex
biological differences have observable physical attributes such as external and internal anatomy, chromosomes and hormone prevelance
most feminists equality feminists arguing that womens nature is socially constructed - determined by society not biology
refers to biological differences between men and women - assigned sex at birth
debate with difference feminism
gender
CPG argues that gender roles are socially constructed from young age, subordinating women to the will of men
KM and bh perceive social construction as beginning in childhood with family unit - women have multiple identities not based on gender alone
SDB wrote that biological differences had been used by male dominated state and society as justification for predetermining gender role of women
SR women's consciousness created by men as part of capitalist machine
most feminists argue that gender roles socially constructed and form gender stereotypes
gender used to explain roles society gives to men and women
liberal - patriarchy can be reformed by the state - female emancipation, access to education, workplace equality etc.
KM granted men ownership over their wife and children - entrenching sexism with the idea of male superiority
patriarchy describes the social system enabling male domination and female subordination
radical - female consciousness created by men as party of capitalist machine
SDB this has happened throughout majority of human history
SR influenced by marxism when suggested that solution to female oppression was revolution that would destroy both capitalism and patriarchy
CPG exploitative nature of domestic roles
SR marriage was like feudalism with women akin to surfs paying feudal dues to their husband
radical - personal is political as patriarchy is prevalent in private sphere of family life
SDB championed contraception as it allowed women control of bodies and chance to avoid endless childbearing
liberal - focus on public sphere of society (equal pay, workplace conditions) state should not involved in private life of women
KM believed family was social construct and not natural arrangement
family socialised young into recognising M authority and F marginalisation in society
marriage saw women lose identity - taking husband surname
SDB dismissed idea of innate female characteristics as myth invented by men to confine women to suppressed state
equality - focus should be on pursuing equality between men and women
majority = feminists who believe that biological differences are inconsequential - gender differences socially constructed - no specific feminine traits
difference feminists = believe in essentialism whereby biological differences do determine gender differences
radical
socialist
liberal
postmodern
bh ideas inspired kimberlé crenshaw theory of intersectionality - challenged notion that gender is most important factor in understanding womens lives
bh criticised 2nd wave for conceptualising feminism from a white middle class educated perspective - R and L exclusion of concerns for minority groups
intersectionality suggests that women can be oppressed in multiple overlapping areas
every women has multiple identities so singular notion of sisterhood gives way to a more communal concept of solidarity
essentialism
idea that biological factors determine different characters and behaviour of men and women - certain behaviours natural and not socially constructed
society
state
human nature
economy
agree
disagree
agree
disagree
agree
disagree
agree
disagree
economics leads to gender inequality and capitalism causes patriarchy
claimed that women were complicit in reproducing workforce and socialising their children continuing the cycle of capitalistic oppression
engels argued that capitalism altered pre existing societal structures which meant women needed as unpaid helpers to enable male workers to be employed in workplace
SR adopted marxist theory of history concluding that women have always been oppressed
engels first to argue that economic caused gender inequality and that capitalism created patriarchy
SR argued that men do not fully understand the nature of oppression of women
women's alienation from capitalism and patriarchy meant that there needed to be a revolution within a revolution to restructure both sources of oppression
2nd wave argue that both the public sphere and private sphere of life must be addressed and claim that the personal is political
patriarchy is prevalent in the private sphere of life such as family - traditionally not a focus on this
all argue for fundamental changes to society's structure
by ignoring private aspect of women's lives oppression of women's domestic circumstance is ignored - personal has to be political if patriarchy to be challenged
all argue that society is purely patriarchal and is a system of oppression unconnected with any other ideology
examples of patriarchy and solutions
bunch argued that heterosexual relationships based on power - lesbianism was a political choice - dworkin argued that pornography was symptomatic of mens perception of women as sex objects
greer argued that patriarchy has socialised women to view sexual desires as unfeminine - women indoctrinated to believe they must retain eternal youth rather than embrace age and experience
pizzey analysis of personal is political focused on domestic violence in family life
firestone saw history as dialectic struggle relating to biological difference between men and women - patriarchy always existed as women always been enslaved by men
pizzey set up first women's refuge in london in 1971 offering women and children refuge from domestic violence
nuclear family should be abolished and replaced by lesbian communities
greer argued for sexual liberation and abandonment of traditional marriage - favoured communal living and childrearing - views similar to millett's
firestone's perfect society would eliminate gender distinctions and embrace androgyny - regarded childbirth as barbaric and advocated for artificial insemination men implanted with wombs and bear children? influenced by SDB took her ideas to next level
successive generations of women need to establish and construct what feminism meant to them
rejects generalisations inherent in other feminist traditions - numerous interacting factors affecting women
embraces complexity of reality and has diverse set of definitions for feminism and patriarchy given the multiple identities women posses
main themes
examples: genital mutilation and honour killings
bh critical of 2nd wave feminism for excluding minority groups - feminism dominated by concerns of white women
intersectionality
slutwalk - global movement who dress like sluts for protest marches after police officer argued that women should avoid dressing like sluts - patriarchal attitude that partially excused rape
technology = source of misogyny and patriarchy via social media
diane abbott received more abuse on twitter than any other MP in 2017 GE
BUT social media can also be used to call out and challenge sexism and misogyny in public sphere - metoo movement
status of women in society should not be affected by their biological status and that gender differences are artificially constructed by society
biological differences inconsequential
liberal, radical, socialist and post modern all agree - equality feminists
difference feminists believe in essentialism arguing that biological differences are important as they determine gender differences - not constructed by society
women must embrace distinctiveness - fundamentally different
patriarchy is pervasive and present in every facet of society
how to reform it and even its affect
friedan argued that society forces women into roles of housewife and mother - patriarchal society can be reformed via state and cultural action
socialist feminists SR society is economically determined by male capitalists and that a revolution is needed in order to change the status of workers and women
liberal and radical disagree on where to challenge patriarchy - liberals prefer public sphere of society - radicals argue that patriarchy must be challenged in both public and private
post modern argue that society is too multifaceted to be determined by one variable such as gender and that we need to look at intersectionality
socialist and radical feminists argue that patriarchal culture is so embedded in society and state - fanciful image that state can combat patriarchy
liberal feminists agree that state has been instrument to reinforce patriarchy BUT argue that function can change - state can be conduit for reform and the tackling patriarchy
PM argue that there is a complexity to state oppression that other branches of feminism miss because their tendency to generalise - bh argues that race is as important as gender
united in their belief that economic world discriminates against women
discrimination includes unpaid labour in the home and lack of equality of opportunity in the workplace
CPG argued that economic independence was fundamental part of female emancipation
engels argued that women are often reduced to being a reserve army of labour
socialist feminists maintain that revolution to overthrow capitalism is needed for true equality in society
SR argues that women must become political force to facilitate communist process
PM bh argues that race and class can be as important as gender in understanding economic oppression
black women from poor backgrounds face poverty and inequalities that middle class white women do not face