Theme: suffering/tragedy
Key Quotes
Lear tells Cordelia, ‘I am bound / Upon a wheel of fire’ (IV.7.46–7). Still half asleep, he believes that he is in Hell, tied to an instrument of torture; we can take this as a metaphor for his suffering in this world.
A03
It is important that you can identify what causes the intense suffering in King Lear. Gloucester thinks that the gods are sadistic; Lear wants to know why nature has given him two malignant daughters. However, you might feel that all the agony can be traced back, not to nature, but to human acts. Characters suffer for their own sins or because they are sinned against, even if they suffer disproportionately. At the end of the play the state too is in disarray, signified by the word ‘gored’ (V.3.320) and the storm can be seen as a metaphor for England’s suffering as well as Lear’s.
Learning through suffering
Is anything learned through suffering? The good endure and help each other. Lear and Gloucester become more perceptive and compassionate. Edgar becomes stronger and fit to rule. Through suffering, these three male characters achieve heroism. In King Lear Shakespeare seems to suggest that it is man’s fate to suffer and we must make the best of it.
A01
Many of the characters suffer almost beyond endurance, reflected in the imagery of the play. Lear tells Regan that her sister has ‘struck’ (II.4.158) him with her tongue and ‘tied / Sharp- tooth’d unkindness’ (II.4.132–3) around his heart. His daughters are ‘a disease that’s in my flesh … a boil / A plague-sore, or embossed carbuncle, / In my corrupted blood’ (II.4.221–4). Even when his senses are restored, Lear continues to suffer. He has been ‘cut to th’ brains’ and finds
it impossible to recover (IV.6.191). ‘Burning shame’keeps him from Cordelia (IV.3.46). Despite their companions’ efforts to help, Gloucester dies of a broken heart and Lear’s moment of greatest agony comes when Cordelia dies. By now Kent too welcomes death. His line ‘Break heart; I prithee, break’ might refer to Lear’s suffering or his own (V.3.312).
"I am a man more sinned against than sinning" 🚫
Lear (act 3, scene 2): This is Lear's claim to the storm that rages around him as he wanders on the heath with his Fool and Kent. Lear believes that he is the victim of his daughters' cruelty and injustice, but he does not acknowledge his own faults and mistakes that have contributed to his misery. 🚫
"Thou shouldst not have been old till thou hadst been wise." ✅
Fool (act 1, scene 5): This is the Fool's remark to Lear, who has foolishly given up his crown and kingdom to his daughters. The Fool implies that Lear has acted like a child instead of a wise ruler and that he has wasted his old age on folly and vanity. ✅
"How sharper than a serpent's tooth it is To have a thankless child!" 🔥
Lear (act 1, scene 4): This is Lear's lament to Kent, who tries to defend Cordelia from Lear's wrath. Lear compares his daughters to venomous snakes that have bitten him with their ingratitude and treachery. He fails to see that Cordelia is the only one who truly loves him and that Goneril and Regan are plotting against him. 🔥
"Nothing will come of nothing: speak again." 🏴
"Who is it that can tell me who I am?" 👥
Lear (act 1, scene 4): This is Lear's question to his Fool, who mocks him for giving away his power and authority to his daughters. Lear begins to lose his sense of identity and sanity as he realizes that he has been deceived and rejected by his own flesh and blood. 👥
Lear (act 1, scene 1): This is Lear's response to his youngest daughter Cordelia, who refuses to flatter him with words of love like her sisters Goneril and Regan. Lear interprets Cordelia's silence as a sign of ingratitude and disowns her, setting in motion the events that will lead to his downfall and death. 🏴
"The weight of this sad time we must obey, Speak what we feel, not what we ought to say. The oldest hath borne most: we that are young Shall never see so much, nor live so long." ‼
Edgar (act 5, scene 3): This is Edgar's speech at the end of the play, after Lear dies holding Cordelia's dead body in his arms. Edgar expresses his grief and sorrow for the tragic fate of Lear and his family, and acknowledges that the older generation has suffered more than the younger one. He also suggests that honesty and sincerity are more important than conformity and duty in times of crisis. ‼
In Shakespeare's King Lear, tragedy is a recurring theme, with no distinction between good and evil. The play depicts the suffering of King Lear's daughters, who are all ultimately killed. Despite the brutal events, hope remains subtly present through the development of characters. King Lear's suffering begins with his unnatural division of the land, where he satisfies greed from Goneril and Reagan. The fawning responses of these characters, such as Cordelia's loyalty, further exacerbate the suffering. Goneril and Reagan's flattery and Cordelia's departure further exacerbate the situation. The brutal beating of King Lear and his knights further deprives him of power, leading to his downfall into madness and mental instability.
However, the protagonist, Lear, shows that redemption can lead to personal growth. Before his sufferings, he was a violent and narcissistic King who punished his loyal people. After suffering, Lear declares to Cordelia that he will "kneel down and ask thee forgiveness," promoting his character flaws and personal growth. Edmund also shows that we still have morals to regain, highlighting the good nature of people. Thus, hope remains present in King Lear's world, as redemption reveals the good nature of people.
In King Lear, hope is presented through the directors' staging of characters on set. In act 1 scene 1, Lear is solitary with Gonerill and Regan, highlighting the growing age of the Kings and the manipulative power of Gonerill and Regan. The gap between Cordelia and Lear increases, illustrating their growing relationship and love. After this distancing, Cordelia is positioned front stage with Kent, The Fool, and France, implying that she is not alone in her banishment. The Fool, Kent, and France side with Cordelia, implying that they may also support her in her banishment. This dramatic interpretation of the play highlights the characters' allegiances and the notion of hope. Overall, the directors effectively stage the characters on set to convey the characters' growing age, manipulation, and love for each other.
‘a disease that’s in my flesh … a boil / A plague-sore, or embossed carbuncle, / In my corrupted blood’
A05
“The suffering in tragedy is not an end but a product and a means” Robert Heilman
“Is wretchedness deprived that benefit,/To end itself by death?”
“Pray, do not, sir: I have watched and travell’d hard;/Some time I shall sleep out, the rest I’ll whistle.”
“And with presented nakedness out-face/The winds and persecutions of the sky.”