Nathan Bogle was once a beloved sports star and Leah's childhood crush, but now he leads of crime, pimping out women who run cons for him, squatting in abandoned houses, consuming drugs, and allegedly mugging and murdering Felix. Nathan once showed much promise for the future, but as he grew older, he claims that the world began to treat him cruelly, which presumably led to his addictions and crimes. Upon running into a distraught Natalie, Nathan is both a comfort and an instigator, as he praises Natalie, prevents her from attempting suicide, and reminds her of her worth while also accusing her of turning her back on her community, stalking her around town, and getting her high on mystery drugs. During this interaction, it is alluded to that Nathan is running from the police after murdering Felix.