Mind the gap: How to measure the relationship between socio-economic background and attainment in UK schools
Links
Ofsted Reports - Ama
Free school meals-Kate
click to edit
North South Divide- Tom
Parents background-Lily
Private schools and university entrance-BK
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
Ofsted overall quality ratings accounted for 4.4% of the differences in educational achievement at age 16.
Most of it could be attributed to family socioeconomic status and prior achievement in primary school.
In 2014, OFSTED revised it’s inspection to include how well schools were doing at increasing the attainment and progress of disadvantage children
click to edit
OFSTED did an inspection into the effectiveness of the pupil premium spending. It came up with the following characteristics for successful schools:
Ring fenced funding and didn’t confuse low-ability w/ pupil premium
Focused on low achieving students in core subjects (i.e maths and English)
Allocated best teachers to these low achieving groups
Used achievement data to see how effective their approaches were
Good communication and a designated Senior lead
In 2022, 47% of pupils eligible for FSM achieved a standard pass in both English and Maths GCSE compared to 75% of pupils not eligible. This was an attainment gap of around 28 percentage points. - Department for Education
More specific GCSE measurements - "standard pass" is 9-4 and "strong pass" is 9-5.
28% of pupils eligible for FSM achieved a "strong pass" compared to 55% of pupils not eligible.
Another measurement is progress 8 - the average progress that pupils make from the end of primary school to the end of year 11.
Progress 8: -0.59 for pupils eligible for FSM, 0.11 for those not.
Pupils eligible for FSM achieved higher than other regions. 60% achieved "standard pass".
24.9% of pupils on FSM achieved A-Levels compared to 29.1% pupils not on FSM (academic years ending 2002 to 2019).- Office of National Statistics (2022)
23.8% of pupils are eligible for FSM in 2023, up from 22.5% in 2022. (Gov 2023)
click to edit
)
click to edit
Sophie: GSCES and household income
click to edit
egional gap of more than 10 percentage points between top grades in the South (28%) versus the North(18%)
£900 less at nothern primary school compared to london
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-34778514 This has great map from 2015 showing the differnce in gardes
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
Parental education significantly influences a child's academic attainment, with years of parental education playing a crucial role in explaining variations in reading performance. Thorpe, G. (2006) Multilevel analysis of PISA 2000 reading results for the UK
click to edit
click to edit
Lenkeit, J., Schwippert, K. & Knigge, M(2017) Configurations of multiple disparities in reading performance: Longitudinal observations across France, Germany, Sweden and the United Kingdom
same study - In 2000, parental occupation and the number of books at home were significant factors contributing to a relative disadvantage in reading, particularly affecting boys
First-generation immigrant background students also faced disadvantages compared to their second-generation and native peers, as did students in schools with lower average parental occupational prestige.
n 2012, there were shifts in these patterns, with immigrant background becoming less predictive of reading attainment
A consistent interaction effect was observed across cycles between parental occupation and education, with the association between parental occupation and reading attainment being stronger for students whose parents achieved higher education degrees.
Gender gaps: Accounting for the gender gaps in student performance in reading and mathematics: evidence from 31 countries. compared the effects of mother and father occupational status on reading and mathematical attainment and found that fathers’ status had a greater effect than mothers in both reading and mathematics
Chance of attending uni influenced by parents education- State school students with highly educated parents are five times more likely to go to university than those from families with few qualifications, according to a study by the Institute of Education.
Even after academic achievement is taken into account, children with university-educated parents are still twice as likely to go into higher education themselves than their peers from families with no qualifications.
And they are also twice as likely to win places at the UK's 24 leading universities
according to a study by the Institute of Education.
'Achievement Motivation" Murray 1938
Parents with more education also have higher expectation for their children's education which facilitate the greater educational attainment for their children (Alexander, Entwisle &, Bedinger, 1994).
Well educated parents are involved more in their children's education than less educated parents. (Grolnick & Slowiaczek, 1994; Stevenson & Baker, 1997 . )Richard and David (1967) argued that parental level of education influences parental involvement, support and expectation for their children. In turn these parental involvement, support and expectation influence achievement motivation of adolescents.
click to edit
Klebanov, Gunn and Duncan (1994) found that both mother's education and family income were important predictors of the physical environment and learning experiences in the home
Acharya, Neha, and Shobhna Joshi. "Influence of parents' education on achievement motivation of adolescents." Indian Journal Social Science Researches 6.1 (2009): 72-79.
Higher education participation in the most selective institutions by type of school or college attended:https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/social-mobility-indicators/social-mobility-indicators#higher-education-participation-in-the-most-selective-institutions-by-type-of-school-or-college-attended
Attainment of good A levels and choice of A level subjects (may not be qualified for certain courses)
Independent funding schools have access to high quality career advice, leading to greater ambition to apply to top universities
Private schools often have better resources and facilities. Students from wealthier backgrounds more likely to attend private schools and have ability to afford additional resources
smaller class sizes - more personalised and supportive learning environment
wider range of extracurricular activities
additional support - tutoring, career guidance
have better networking opportunities
The reginal gap between north and south grow between 2022 and 2023 Schools in the north east are performing the worst in the uk
click to edit
Also attendence figures in the north are worse compared to london
81% of pupils with household income >£78,000 achieved 5+ GCSE's at A*-C
Lots of graphs on pages 21/22:
Figure 7: Attainment 8 scores vs income
Figure 8: English baccalaureate entry and achievement rates compared to household income
Figure 9: Achievement of 5+ A*-C grades by income
There are bigger increases seen towards the highest income groups, although there are smaller numbers of children in these groups. This is particularly evident for the English baccalaureate
Two in five pupils (38%) from the poorest one-third of postcodes fail GCSE maths
Just 13% of the poorest pupils attain either a 7, 8 or 9
children in the 10% richest families are more than twice as likely as those in the seventh decile to earn at least one A or A* grade at GCSE.
despite decades of policies and attention, the disadvantage gap is not getting any better
Disadvantaged students are making slower progress through secondary school with only 40% of disadvantaged pupils who achieved the expected level at the end of primary school go on to achieve good GCSES's in maths and english; compared to 60% of non disadvantaged pupils
Graph showing the percentage of young people achieving 5 good GCSE's and the percentage getting at least 1 A or A* compared to the decile of equalised household income
More than 70% of children from the richest 10th achieve 5 good GCSE's while only 30% from the poorest 10% do
click to edit
Private school pupils admitted at Oxford in 2022 accounted for 31.9 per cent of UK undergraduates, up marginally from 31.8 per cent in the previous year but down from 41.8 per cent in 2017
In 2013 state-school students made up 57% and 61% of those admitted to Oxford and Cambridge respectively.
Independant school pupils are 7 times more likely to gain a place at Oxford or Cambridge compared to those in non-selective state schools, and over twice as likely to take a place at
Russell Group institutions. 60% of those from independent schools in higher education attend a Russell Group university, compared to just under a quarter of those from comprehensives and sixth form colleges.
Applicants from non-selective state schools were less likely to receive and accept an offer from a Russell Group university compared to independent schools (44% compared to 71%).
Proportion of A level students who progress to the most selective universities (top third ranked by UCAS tariff score) by age 19.
Graduates leaving the most selective universities have a greater chance of quickly moving into a graduate job and experience higher labour market returns. There has been little change over the past 15 years in access to the most selective universities.
2006-2007: only 25.9% from public school, 62.8% from private schools.
The "gap" between these figures slowly increased over the years but only slightly
Data that can be used for a graph
More useful links
example chart from link
https://explore-education-statistics.service.gov.uk/find-statistics/widening-participation-in-higher-education
(scroll down to "A Level Students - School Type")
High A level attainment by age 19 by school or college type:
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/social-mobility-indicators/social-mobility-indicators#high-a-level-attainment-by-age-19-by-school-or-college-type