Schizophrenia: Risk Factors, Explanations + Prognosis

Prognosis:

  • ~ 45% schizophrenia cases recover after 1/more episodes
  • ~ 20% show constant symptoms + increased disability
  • ~ 35% display varied degrees of progress/deterioration
  • Extremely high suicide rate:
    Nannerz et al (2001) - 30% schizophrenic patients attempted suicide at least once during lifetime
    Radomsky et al (1999) - 10% of schizophrenic people die by suicide

Genetic/Familial Factors

Stress + Pregnancy

Recreational drug use

Life Expectancy:

  • Worse than smoking
  • Years lost = 15-20 years
  • Unknown cause
  • Risk of developing schizophrenia <1% in general population
  • Risk of developing schizophrenia 2-9% if first degree relatives
  • Risk of developing schizophrenia 1.5-3% if second degree relatives
  • Rudin (1916) - Schizophrenia tends to cluster in families

Twin Studies:

  • MZ twins = ~ 50% concordance rate
  • DZ twins = 4% concordance rate
  • Suggests genetic link, but also other factors involved (e.g. environment)

Environmental Factors

  • Similar representation + prevalence worldwide = widespread environmental factors
  • Typically develops in early adulthood = environmental role during development

Retrospective studies:

  • Ask parents/family about child's early life
  • Compare patients to control ppts
    Follow-back studies:
  • Use objective evidence (e.g. medical records) to find out about child's early life
    High risk studies:
  • Select sample of ppts at high risk of developing schizophrenia
  • Follow them prospectively before they develop schizophrenia
  • Compare those who do develop schizophrenia with those who don't + controls

Retrospective studies limitations:

  • Selective + incomplete recall
  • Search after meaning - Look for particular instances to explain condition
  • Expensive to conduct widescale study
    Follow-back studies limitations:
  • Objective evidence often sparse/missing/lost/not detailed
  • Can interfere with foetal brain development
  • High risk of child developing schizophrenia in women:
  • Whose partner died during pregnancy (Huttunen, 1989)
  • Affected by battle/war during pregnancy (Van Os + Selten, 1998)

Perinatal Complications:

  • Babies experienced birth complications = 2x as likely to develop schizophrenia (Cannon, 1997; Jones, 1998)
  • Birth complications lead to hypoxia (lack of oxygen in organs + tissues)

Drugs inducing psychosis include:

  • Amphetamine (speed)
  • Cocaine
  • LSD
  • Ketamine
  • Cannabis (associated with schizophrenia)

Eve Johnstone et al (1999) High risk study:

  • Followed up 155 ppts aged 16-24 at risk of getting schizophrenia
  • Compared to 36 controls
  • Estimated risk of developing schizophrenia = 10-15%

Miller et al (2001):

  • Compared cannabis use in ppts who developed schizophrenic symptoms + ppts who didn't
  • Cannabis is a risk factor for developing psychotic symptoms in vulnerable young people
    Di Fortio et al (2015):
  • Compared 410 patients with 1st psychotic episode with 370 controls between 2005-2010
  • 2.9x higher risk of developing psychotic disorder for cannabis users
  • 5.4x higher risk of developing psychotic disorder for skunk users
  • ~ 1/4 of 1st psychotic episodes due to skunk use

Psychosocial environment

Urban upbringing

  • Being socially isolated increases risk of developing schizophrenia

Kirkbride et al (2014):

  • Incidence of non-affective psychosis affected by inequality, absolute deprivation, population density
  • For Black Caribbeans + Black Africans, risk was associated with ethnic separation, ethnic density

Dysfunctional families
Gregory Bateson

  • 'Double Bind' (say something but expect the opposite)
    E.g. Complain about lack of affection but push away child when trying to hug

Dysfunctional families: Hirsch + Leff (1974)

  • Compared parents of schizophrenic patients with parents of people with other disorders
  • More communication deviance in parents of schizophrenic patient
  • Small no. of parents spoke much
  • When communication was controlled, no difference between groups

Leff + Vaughan (1976)

  • Recruited patients on admission + followed up on discharge
  • Observed families in naturalistic settings
  • Recorded + transcribed communication
  • Rated each for expressed emotion
  • Found: Patients in high expressed emotion families showed high relapse rate 1 year after discharge
  • Strength: Replicated many times
  • Limitation: Direction of causality unknown

Miller et al (2001)

  • Compared life events of schizophrenic ppts + non-schizophrenic ppts
  • High risk ppts with more life events = greater risk of developing schizophrenic symptoms
  • Minor life events not significantly associated with schizophrenic symptoms
  • Limitation: Causation problem - life events = symptoms, or vice versa?

Dopamine

Original dopamine hypothesis:

  • Excessive dopamine activity = positive symptoms of schizophrenia
  • 'Typical' anti-psychotics block dopamine receptors
  • Explains Parkinsonian side effects of treatment + psychotic side effects of treating Parkinson's Disease
  • Limitation: Doesn't explain negative symptoms of schizophrenia

Revised dopamine hypothesis:

  • Overactivity of dopamine Mesolimbic pathway = Positive symptoms
  • Both typical + atypical anti-psychotics:
  • Block dopamine
  • Reduce mesolimbic activity
  • Reduce positive symptoms


  • Underactivity of dopamine mesocortical pathway = Negative symptoms

  • Atypical anti-psychotics:
  • Block serotonin
  • Reduce inhibition of mesocortical pathway
  • Increase mesocortical activity
  • Reduce negative symptoms