Evolution and the Fossil Record

Fossil Record

rocks dated from 542 to about 488 Ma include fossils representative of most animal phyla living today, such as...

crustaceans and other arthopods

onychophorans

sipunculid worms

segmented worms

mollusks

chordates

Confirms periods of rapid diversification, such as the Cambrian Explosion

demonstrates evidence of five episodes of mass extinctions

Methods of Formation:

  1. Amber and Freezing

least altered remains

provide the most information

rare

  1. Permineralization and Replacement

when structures are buried in sediments

original shape is preserved but composition is altered

comon

  1. Natural Molds and Casts

originate when remains decay after being buried in sediment

preserve information about surface shape but no internal details

  1. Trace fossils

record behavior instead of form

examples: dinosaur tracks, copralites

difficult to determine which species made it

Life on an Evolving Earth

life evolved on a world that was itself changing, driven primarily by plate tectonics constantly rearranging continents and oceans

Phanerozoic

Paleozoic: ancient life

Mesozoic: middle life

Cenozoic: recent life

Evolution

morphology is a critical source of info

DNA data is mostly unavailable

fossil species are recognized on the basis of their anatomy (morphospecies concept)

convergent or parallel evolution can be difficult to recognize

juveniles and adults can sometimes be confused for separate species

fossil record provides data on aspects of evolution that can never be studied or replicated in the lab

Ediacaran Biota

precambrian

first unequivocal evidence for macroscopic life

565-544 Ma; end of the Proterozoic era

difficult to classify

most preserved as impressoin

include forms of life no longer represented on E today

includes sponges, jellyfish, and comb jelly relatives

small in size (a few cm) and relatively simple morphology

fossilized embryos support the hypothesis that bilaterians evolved before Cambrian

Cambrian

Burgess Shale Fauna

is a Lagerstatte

records an astonishing variety of large and complex bilaterally symmetric animals

located in British Columbia, Canada

preserved even soft-bodied Cambrian fossils

provided an unparalleled view of the early diversification of life in the Late Cambrian ocean

most animal phyla alive today make their first appearance in the fossil record during the Cambrian

fauna includes:

wide array of complex and unusual arthropods, including trilobites

segmented worms

wormlike priapulids and sipunculids

diversity of mollusks

several chordates, including jawless vertebrates

Problematica

some species in the Burgess Shale Fauna are so unusual that they have been hard to classify

now grouped with living phyla, or at least with early Phanerozoic fossils of known affinity

Cambrian Explosion: Rapid appearance of many large and complex animals

an astonishing variety of body plans, cell types, and developmental patterns evolved

What caused this?

Sudden increase in seawater during Proterozoic and increase in atmospheric oxygen in mid-Cambrian

more oxygen -> bigger bodies are possible

larger size is a prerequisite for the evolution of tissues

higher metabolic rates are required for active movement

Mass extinction eliminated much of Ediacaran fauna at end of Proterozoic, making opportunity for the tiny deuterostomes and protostomes to evolve in response to the changed conditions

Major Transitions

Fish-Tetrapod Transition

leading up to it...

by Ordovician, terrestrial plants had evolved

insects began exploiting resources on land from the Silurian or earliest Devonian

Devonian is often referred to as the "age of fishes", with astonishing diversity displayed by aquatic vertebrates

past few decades have shed light on the sequence of character evolution associated with the first land living, limbed vertebrates: the tetrapods

includes...

fin turned into limb

structural changes to withstand the increased effects of gravity

Tiktaalik is a transition form, a "fishapod"

all sarcopterygians

Ichthyostega

Acanthostega had well-developed joints between consecutive vertebrae

Eusthenopteron, an aquatic taxa

enlarged rib attachments

Why?

classic theory is largely based on ecology of Australian lungfish, which moves between ponds that shrink during the dry season

late Devonian was substantially warmer than today

untapped foods available on land such as insects

Dinosaur-Bird Transition

Archaeopteryx has been famous for its position as the oldest definitive fossil bird

theropods

mix of avian and reptilian features

plesiomorphies include

teeth

long tail

three clawbearing fingers on the hand

synapomorphy is well-developed feathers

clade of bipedal, carnivorous dinosaurs that includes birds as its living descendants

early members have many features commonly associated with birds and flight

Paleontologists have found feathers from animals that clearly could not fly

Sinosauropteryx

bears fuzzy, filamentous integumentary structures

provided the first evidonce of a down-like covering in theropods

Why did feathers first evolve?

display: as sexual signaling devices

thermoregulation: for insulation or to aid in brooding eggs

Origin of Mammals

fossil record of synapsid lineage captures transition from reptile-like forms in the Carboniferous to the earliest mammals by the Early Jurassic

Cynodonts

include Procynosuchus ad Thrinaxodon

clade the includes mammals as its living representatives

evolutionary transition concerns middle ear

in early synapsids, modern reptiles, and birds, only a single element (the stapes) is present

in mammals this structure includes an air-filled cavity with three bones (malleus, incus, and stapes)

Extinction

Background Extinctions

affects limited number of species

Mass Extinction

96% of phanerozoic extinctions

result of a normal evolutionary process

ongoing extinction of individual species due to environmental or ecological factors

large scale

sudden extinction that is geographically and taxonomically widespread

ultimate fate of all species

about 4% of phanerozoic extinctions

A decline in rate of both origination and extinction across the Phanerozoic

seen in several studies of marine organisms

hypotheses:

optimization of fitness

energy input to E has been decreasing

has happened five times

Sixth mass extinction?

majority of recently extinct species inhabited islands, whose extinctions have usually resulted from human hunting or the introduction of nonnative predators or competitors

current concern is focused on habitat loss due to expanding human populations

current human pop is 7 billion, growing at 1.2% a year, resulting in 12+ billion by 2050

unless human population growth declines rapidly, threats to natural habitats will grow in intensity over the next several decades

Extinctions are now occuring at 100-1000x the background rate. If this continues and all rare species go extinct, it would take less than 100 years for 60% of living species to be wiped out

Three types of approaches to predict how continued habitat destruction will affect extinction rates:

  1. Multiply # of species found per hectare in different environments by rates of habitat loss measured from satellite photos
  1. Quantify the rate that well-known species are moving from threatened to endangered to extinct status in the lists maintained by conservation groups

click to edit