Thesis
Concern
Does it differ from country to country? City to City?
Criteria for an urban green space?
Complication: Air quality in urban spaces
situate: Environmental processes regarding air
Impact on people's health (diseases, death toll)
Common ground
Urbanisation today and in the future
Green spaces
city life with climate change
Definition of an urban green space
Impact on environment
What is the target audience?
things to look up
How is air quality measured
Airflow in cities/rural
Indicators
Tresholds
Climate system
Map brussels and air quality (QGIS) Dries
Factors which reduce/improve air quality
Impact of vegetation on air quality
Evapotranspiration
Solar radiation
Brussels environmental setting
Air quality in brussels
Waterflow
Urban heat island circulation
Urban boundary layer
Albedo
humiditiy
Percipitaiton/ runoff
AIr quality in brussels/ belgium (Densely populated country with lots of fragmentation)
Come into contact with
Runoff
Urban heat Island
park breeze phenomenon
Go to lectures about air quality in BE/EU?
Talk to experts in air quality in brussels?
BUGS Benefits of Urban Green Space
Limitation
Only air quality
maybe not optimised for
Noise
Accessability
(Temperature)
Recreation
economic efficiency
Micro Vs mesocale
URBAN GREEN AREA/ WATER
QUESTIONS for professor
"Brussles is too narrow"
What methodology are we using? measurements of indicators? Are we analysing data?
What will the subject be around water/UGA and that in different cities?
Try to Compare other cities
or try to say why it's only tied to brussels/ because every city is unique? the factors contributing to air quality are very dependant geography etc?
QGIS
Map of urban green areas
Map of Brussels Waterways
UGA
Definition
Green areas
Parks
Green roofs/terraces
Forest area
Brussels city or Brussels Capital Region
Effects on Health (air and water or effects on happiness and wellbeing
Look at brussels attitude concerning
green areas cfr Schaerbeek green area gets replace by social housing
Purpose of Green
Economical
Ecological
Socio cultural
Eco services
What type of vegetation species
Characteristics of the water
species living in waters
Should I try to get information on species of flora in brussels/ Species in the water
green walls
More trees = more pollen = more repiratory diseases. Look into gender of trees that are placed in cities (I think female trees don't pollinate as much)
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/may/16/how-urban-planners-preference-for-male-trees-has-made-your-hay-fever-worse
VITO
IRCEL
Limitations of thesis Dries
Lack of data on tree species
need for research on green roofs/teraces/walls
Papers Immersing in literature
Statistics of air quality in brussels/ Belgium
How many people have health implications due to air pollution in belgium
MILIEUCOMPARTIMENT LUCHT
Bronnen van luchtverontreiniging
Energieproductie en gebouwenverwarming
Verkeer en vervoer
Industrie
Landbouw
Aard en ontstaan van belangrijkste luchtpolluenten
Zwevend stof
Prim en sec deeltjes
Aerodynamische diameter
Gasvormige polluenten
CO2
POV
CO
PAK
B(a)P
Dioxine
Seveso dioxine 2,3,7,8 tetrachloordibenzo-p-dioxine
Zwaveldioxide
Stikstofoxiden
NOX
Distikstofoxide
VOS
Methaan
NMVOS
Verzadigde alifatische kws
Vertakte alifatische kws
Olefenische kws
Aromatische kws
Gehalogeneerde kws
Ammoniak
Gedrag van gasvormige polluenten
CO2
SO2
NOx
NH3
CFK, HCFK, HFK
COMPARTIMENT WATER
De rivier als ecosysteem
Abiotische factoren
Stroming
Licht
Temperatuur
Chemie
Substraat
Biotische factoren
Bacteriën
Primaire producenten
Invertebraten
Vissen
Waterverontreinigende factoren en hun effecten
Zuurstofbindende stoffen
Organische verbindingen
Ammoniakale en organische stikstofverbindingen
Oxideerbare anorganische stoffen
Nutriënten
Vermesting
Gedrag van N
Gedrag van P
Eutrofiëring van water
Toxische stoffen
PCB's
Zware metalen en metalloïden
Pesticiden
Hormoonversotrende stoffen
Andere factoren
Thermische verontreiniging
Verzurende stoffen
Zouten
Zwevende stoffen
Ziekteverwekkers
Oppervlakteactieve stoffen
Hydromorfologische veranderingen
Waterverontreinigingsparameters
Opgeloste zuurstof
Zuurtegraad
Elektrische geleidbaarheid
Zwevende stoffen, droge stof, gloeirest en gloeiverlies
Bezinkbare stoffen
Biologisch zuurstofverbruik
Chemisch zuurstofverbruik
Total organic carbon
Stikstof
Fosfor
Metalen
Ziekteverwekkende organismen
Oliën vetten en minerale olie
Fenolen
Adsorberende organische halogeenverbindingen
MAK, PAK, PCB
Deaths due to air quality
Economic cost of healthcare for issues
How vegetation purifies air (stomata etc)
Green in cities to combat rising surface temperatures
Green roof research
It is estimated that 2000 m 2 of uncut grass on a green roof can remove up to 4000 kg of particulate matter (Johnson and Newton, 1996)
Regarding specific pollutants, Clark et al. (2005) estimate that if 20% of all industrial and commercial roof surfaces in Detroit, MI, were tradi-tional extensive sedum green roofs, over 800,000 kg (889 tons) per year of NO2 (or 0.5% of that areas emissions) would be removed
In Singapore, sulphur dioxide and nitrous acid were reduced 37% and 21%, respectively, directly above a green roof (Tan and Sia, 2005).
Currie and Bass (2008) studied the effects of green roofs on air pollution using the Urban Forest Effects (UFORE) dry deposition model developed by the USDA Forest Service
Yang et al. (2008) also utilized a dry deposition model to quantify the impact of green roofs on air pollution in Chicago.
Which Factors influence air purification of plants? Temperature, Sunlight time, Humidity, Plant pollination season, Percipitation, etc....
Morikawa etal.(1998)tested217species including Kalanchoe blossfeldiana, a succulent in the Crassulaceae family, for their potential to remove NO2. Sedum, the most common plant species for traditional extensive green roofs is similar to Kalachoe in that they are both members of the same family and both exhibit Crassulacean Acid Metabolism
If 20% of all existing “green roof ready” buildings in Washington, DC, installed green roofs, the resulting plantings would remove the same amount of air pollution as 17,000 street trees (Deutsch et al., 2005).
A green roof will eventually reach a carbon equilibrium (plant growth ¼ plant decomposition), but initially this man-made ecosystem will serve as a carbon sink. Getter et al. (2009b)
The components of a green roof likely have a CO2 ‘cost’ in terms of the manufacturing process over and above those of a conven-tional roof (Kosareo and Ries, 2007)
Definiton of a green roof/ types/ how does the system work (visually)
Search for a carbon equation
click to edit
Akbari and Konopacki (2005) simulated many different HIR strategies for a variety of climates and building types in the U.S
CO2 emissions= + making of the roof - plant sequestration - Insulation provided by roof - Heat island reduction
Calculate savings of energy for campus brussels
green roofs are estimated to last 45 years or longer in terms of mechanical lifespan (Kosareo and Ries, 2007).
if 20% of buildings in Washington, DC, had green roofs, they could store approximately 958 million liters (253 million gallons) of rainwater in an average year (Deutsch et al., 2005).
Czerniel Berndtsson et al. (2006) analyzed metals and nutrients (Cd, Cr, Cu, Fe, K, Mn, Pb, Zn, NO3eN, NH4eN, Tot-N, PO4eP, and Tot-P) present in runoff from extensive sedum-moss roofs and non-vegetated roofs and showed that with the exception of N which was retained by the vegetation, green roofs were a source of pollutants.
Van Renterghem and Botteldooren (2008, 2009) studied the effects of intensive and extensive green roofs on sound pressure.
Many factors determine survival of green roof plant species including substrate depth (Dunnett et al., 2008a; Durhman et al., 2007; Getter and Rowe, 2009), solar radiation levels (Getter et al., 2009a), and climate with the limiting factor usually being substrate moisture (ASTM, 2006; Durhman et al., 2006; Emilsson, 2008; Monterusso et al., 2005; Wolf and Lundholm, 2008). Also, fertilization often promotes biomass accumulation which in some cases makes the plants more vulnerable to drought (Rowe et al., 2006). There is evidencethatevapotranspirationratesinfluencestormwater retention and energy conservation (VanWoert et al., 2005b; US EPA, 2009; Voyde et al., 2010)
Green roof/walls
Structure (layered setup)
Intensive v extensive
Advantages
Runoff red
Habitat
Grreenery
Nutrient absorbtion
Heatisland reduction
Carbon reduction?
Disadvantages
Upkeep
Initial cost
Carbon cost of instalment
Sound absorption
5C model
Common ground
Concern
Contribution
Course of action
complication
Read limitations in papers to decide contributuion
click to edit
Species of plants in belgian climate? Plants need to be evaluated in various locations and climactic regions, as well as for management and maintenance practices
There is also a need for plant research on combinations of plants as there is some evidence that green roofs perform better when designed as ecosystems to promote biodiversity instead of monocultures
Additional research is needed to substantiate claims regarding water quality of the runoff from roofs with various substrates and types of vegetation. Also, can grey water be used or will there be a buildup of salts in the substrate that will harm vegetation
https://vimeo.com/122354242 min 1:30 ex of how to use green roof (carbon absorption, water usage, species protection all in one project
How green walls deal with runoff
Lifecycle assessment of living walls: air purification and energy performance
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2014.01.041
Plant-based remediation of air pollution: A review https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2021.113860 Has some sources of air quality statements, also data of absorption of different pollutants in plant species (can put into a graph and find plants in same family)
Plant-based remediation of air pollution: A review
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2021.113860