Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
S&T - Coggle Diagram
S&T
Ethical Issues
-
Designer Babies
A baby whose genetic makeup has been purposely and artificially selected/created by genetic engineering, combined with in vitro fertilisation to ensure the presence/absence of particular genes/characteristics, or the optimal recombination of the parent's genetic material.
-
Issues
-
-
-
-
-
Drastically reduce human genetic variation, increasing vulnerability of human race
-
Raises the spectre of eugenics (the idea of improving humans by allowing only particular people to produce children)
-
GMOs
Living organisms whose genetic material has been artificially manipulated in a lab through genetic engineering.
-
-
-
Transgenic Animals
Against
Cruel and unnecessary experiments on animals without regard for the emotions and rights of the animal subjects.
The idea of human-animal hybrids is abhorred as "unnatural" as it violates/blurs the boundaries between species.
-
For
Helps scientists better understand the cause of diseases and how to cure them, thereby potentially saving millions of lives and alleviating suffering.
Human welfare should, arguably, take precedence over animal rights.
Biotech
The use & modification of living organisms for various purposes, especially in genetic engineering and cell & tissue culture technologies.
Uses
-
-
-
Fabrication of new materials for clothing, plastics & construction
-
-
-
-
Gene Therapy
-
Issues
Immune system interference, decreased effectiveness
-
Too specialised, hard to treat disorders affected by many genes
Insertional mutagenesis risk, risk inducing tumour growth
Short-lived, requires multiple treatments
Viability questioned, tampering with nature
-
-
For government funding
Private corporations' profit motives may obstruct the progress of R&D into new inventions/technologies
-
Against regulation
-
[UTILITARIAN 1000] If research can save lives and increase society's welfare, the process by which scientific regulation is conducted does not matter. (Animal testing)
Science should be about the pursuit of knowledge and satisfying intellectual curiosity, any regulation of science stifles discovery, innovation and progress that can greatly benefit mankind. (Andreas Vesalius)
For regulation
Slow down revolutionary scientific advancements till society can fully consider ethical impact of such discoveries
Some regulation of science need not necessarily stifle scientific progress as this can motivate scientists to look for alternatives.
Deter malpractices and fraud arising from selfish motivation [lose public trust --> reduced benefit]
-
-
Definitions + Aims
Definitions
Science
The systematic study of structure & behaviour of physical & natural world through observation & experiment.
-
-