Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
is subjectivity overly celebrated in the arts but unfairly condemned in…
is subjectivity overly celebrated in the arts but unfairly condemned in history? discuss with reference to art and history.
Unpacking by word/phrase
Subjectivity
The quality of being based on or influenced by personal feelings, tastes, or opinions
-
-
Solely based on an individual’s perspective , feelings and thoughts for a product
Overly celebrated; arts
Overly
-
More than is normal, necessary, or reasonable
-
-
-
-
Inquiries
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
are the histories of areas of knowledge equally important for the production of knowledge in the present?
-
-
-
if its difficult to establish truth proof in history, does that mean that all versions are equally acceptable?
-
-
Areas involved
-
History
-
-
-
methodology: the need to recognise the particular challenges of the subject matter (the gap between evidence in the presence and the ultimate object of study in the past)
-
-
historians are geared to only subset of the past that is traditionally considered appropriate for the discipline
-
Historians sometimes misinterpret evidence - they are not justified in asserting the inferences they draw about the past is true
an account of a historical subject might be justified and credible while the subject is unbalanced- unfair
general description of the past that implies facts which on the available evidence, are known to be false
-
-
-
-
possible arguments
for historical knowledge to be applicable to the present or the future, factual accuracy is a prerequisite (textbook)
-
-
History is fairly condemned because historical judgment is based on historian’s interpretation of the evidence and their own beliefs and values
subjectivity in arts is appropriately celebrated for its significance of objectivity in technical skills and art elements
history is unfairly condemned because every field of knowledge has a history and history itself are geared to only subset of the past that is traditionally considered appropriate for the discipline
-
Subjectivity in arts is overly celebrated because the artists lack of power in deciding the knowledge of the artist’s artwork
-
Writing stage
-
-
Uncertainty in arts - is where subjectivity comes in - does the uncertainty in arts give truth to the knowledge of arts
-
-
-
-
Certainty in arts
perspective first - what kind of knowledge do they gain - not known
known - if the skills is important, why do they opne for interpretation
knowledge in arts? Ada afcts ke?
experts je ada knowledge - audience ada knowledge tak? -
interpretation can improve the value
coproducer of knwo - audience
control, process of acquisition
how do they celebrate? Beyond reality ir facts
RLE IN arts, discipline critiues and knowledge produced, wheres the subjjectivity
How arts reach consensus?
-
-