Nothing is more exciting than fresh ideas, so why are areas of knowledge often so slow to adopt?
Discuss with reference to the human science and one other area of knowledge.
FRESH IDEA
Prescribed Tittle: Nothing is more exciting than fresh ideas, so why are areas of knowledge often so slow to adopt ?
Fresh Ideas:
Areas of Knowledge:
Slow to Adopt:
"Fresh ideas" is a term that generally refers to new, innovative, and novel concepts or proposals that deviate from established norms or existing knowledge. These ideas are characterized by their originality and creativity
Originality: Fresh ideas are unique and original, breaking from the norm.
Creativity: They stem from creative thinking and new perspectives.
Innovation: Fresh ideas drive innovation and change.
Excitement: They inspire enthusiasm and passion.
Knowledge Expansion: They expand knowledge and push boundaries.
Problem Solving: Fresh ideas offer new solutions.
Diversity of Thought: They encourage diverse viewpoints.
Risk and Uncertainty: They may involve risk and face resistance.
Resistance to Change: Established practices may resist fresh ideas.
Progress Catalyst: Fresh ideas drive progress and shape the future.
"AOK" refer to distinct categories or domains of human understanding and inquiry. These areas represent the different branches of knowledge that encompass a wide range of subjects, disciplines, and fields of study
Categorization of Knowledge: They categorize human understanding into distinct domains.
Examples of Knowledge Domains:
Interdisciplinary Nature: They are interconnected, and insights from one area can influence another.
Assessment in TOK: In TOK, students critically evaluate knowledge claims within these areas.
Cultural and Historical Context: Knowledge within these areas is influenced by cultural and historical contexts.
Evolution of Knowledge: Knowledge in these areas evolves over time with new discoveries and changing perspectives.
Application in Real-Life Contexts: Knowledge from these areas is applied in various real-life contexts, shaping our understanding and decision-making.
Mathematics: The study of numbers, patterns, and mathematical concepts.
Natural Sciences: The systematic investigation of the natural world, including physics, chemistry, biology, and astronomy.
Human Sciences: The study of human behavior, society, and culture, encompassing fields like psychology, sociology, anthropology, and economics.
History: The examination of past events, their causes, and their impact on societies and individuals.
The Arts: Creative expressions, including visual arts, music, literature, drama, and more.
"slow to adopt" refers to the tendency of established or traditional knowledge domains, institutions, or systems to be hesitant, resistant, or cautious when it comes to incorporating or accepting new and innovative ideas or concepts
Conservatism: Being slow to adopt is often associated with conservatism, which is the inclination to preserve traditional values, norms, and practices. Conservative attitudes can lead to skepticism or resistance towards ideas that challenge the established order.
Risk Aversion: Slow adoption can be driven by a fear of risk. Embracing new ideas may involve uncertainty, potential failures, or unforeseen consequences, which some individuals or organizations may be unwilling to accept.
Lack of Awareness or Understanding: Sometimes, slow adoption is a result of a lack of awareness or understanding of the potential benefits or implications of fresh ideas. People or institutions may not fully grasp the value of these ideas.
Resistance to Change: Being "slow to adopt" implies a resistance to change. It suggests that there is a reluctance to deviate from existing practices, beliefs, or established methods, even when fresh ideas may offer potential benefits or improvements.
human sciences and art
HUMAN SCIENCE
ARTS
fresh ideas in the human sciences encompass a wide range of innovative approaches, theories, and methodologies that aim to deepen our understanding of human behavior, society, and culture. These ideas are driven by a desire to advance knowledge, address pressing issues, and challenge existing paradigms in the pursuit of a more comprehensive understanding of the human experience
Original Research: Fresh ideas in the human sciences often emerge from original research and studies. Researchers may propose new hypotheses, experimental methods, or analytical frameworks to explore aspects of human behavior, cognition, social interactions, or cultural phenomena.
Theory Development: Fresh ideas can involve the development of new theories or models that provide novel explanations for human phenomena. These theories may offer alternative perspectives on topics such as psychology, sociology, anthropology, or economics.
Interdisciplinary Insights: Fresh ideas in the human sciences can draw from interdisciplinary approaches, integrating knowledge from multiple domains to address complex issues. This might involve combining psychology and neuroscience, sociology and economics, or anthropology and linguistics to gain new insights.
Challenging Conventional Wisdom: Fresh ideas often challenge conventional wisdom or established theories. They may question existing paradigms, assumptions, or prevailing beliefs about human behavior, society, or culture.
Social and Cultural Innovation: Fresh ideas can extend to social and cultural innovation, where new concepts, practices, or policies are introduced to address contemporary social challenges or cultural shifts. For example, fresh ideas might lead to innovative approaches in education, healthcare, or governance.
Ethical Considerations: Fresh ideas in the human sciences may also involve exploring ethical considerations related to human research, experimentation, or intervention. They can raise questions about the ethical boundaries and implications of new approaches.
Diverse Perspectives: Fresh ideas encourage the exploration of diverse perspectives and voices, recognizing that human phenomena are complex and multifaceted. This may involve considering the influence of culture, identity, and historical context on human behavior.
Application to Real-Life Issues: Fresh ideas in the human sciences are often driven by a desire to address real-life issues and challenges, such as mental health, social inequality, globalization, or cultural identity. They aim to offer innovative solutions or insights.
fresh ideas in the arts represent a constant exploration of new possibilities and creative horizons. Artists strive to innovate, challenge, and inspire through their work, contributing to the dynamic and evolving landscape of artistic expression. These fresh ideas play a crucial role in shaping the arts and their ability to resonate with and captivate audiences.
Innovative Artistic Forms: Fresh ideas in the arts often manifest as innovative artistic forms, genres, or styles that break away from traditional artistic conventions. These can include new approaches in visual arts, music, literature, theater, and more.
Experimental Techniques: Artists may experiment with unconventional techniques or materials to create fresh and unique works of art. This might involve using new digital tools, mixed media, or unconventional materials to push the boundaries of artistic expression.
Narrative and Conceptual Innovation: In literature and storytelling, fresh ideas can involve the development of new narrative structures, themes, or storytelling techniques that challenge established literary norms. This can lead to the creation of groundbreaking literature and narrative forms.
Avant-Garde Movements: Fresh ideas in the arts are often associated with avant-garde movements that aim to disrupt traditional artistic practices and introduce innovative concepts. Avant-garde art can be provocative, experimental, and boundary-pushing.
Cultural and Social Commentary: Some fresh ideas in the arts are driven by a desire to provide commentary on contemporary cultural, social, or political issues. Artists may use their work to engage with and critique societal norms and values.
Exploration of Identity and Diversity: Fresh ideas can also involve the exploration of identity, diversity, and inclusion in the arts. Artists may challenge existing representations and stereotypes to promote greater inclusivity and representation in their work.
Transcending Boundaries: Fresh ideas in the arts often transcend traditional artistic boundaries, blurring the lines between different art forms. This interdisciplinary approach can result in hybrid forms of artistic expression.
Audience Engagement: Artists may experiment with new ways of engaging with their audience, such as immersive experiences, interactive installations, or participatory art, to create fresh and engaging artistic encounters.
Contemporary Relevance: Fresh ideas in the arts frequently aim to remain relevant to contemporary society by addressing current issues, concerns, or cultural shifts. They reflect the ever-evolving nature of human experiences.
Critical Reflection: Fresh ideas in the arts may prompt critical reflection and discussion about the nature of art, aesthetics, and the role of art in society. They challenge viewers to think differently about artistic expression and its impact.
Human Science
The Arts
fresh ideas in the human sciences encompass a wide range of innovative approaches, theories, and methodologies that aim to deepen our understanding of human behavior, society, and culture.
fresh ideas in the arts represent a constant exploration of new possibilities and creative horizons.
ARGUMENT
SLOW TO ADOPT
The Arts
"slow to adopt" means a reluctance within the artistic community or institutions to accept and integrate new artistic ideas, styles, or forms. This hesitation often stems from a preference
Human Science
"slow to adopt" means the tendency for established theories, research methods, and academic practices to resist embracing new, innovative ideas or approaches.
Human Science
CENTRAL INQUIRY
"How may collaboration between different disciplines contribute in the adoption of fresh ideas, and what effects does the combination of knowledge from many fields have on the development and evolution of knowledge both within and between Areas of Knowledge?"
what is COLLABORATION BETWEEN DIFFERENT DISCIPLINES?
Refers to the interaction between individuals or teams from different fields of expertise to conduct research that cannot effectively addressed by a single discipline alone
In the realm of human sciences, the cautious adoption of fresh ideas is both a safeguard against potentially harmful or incomplete theories and an acknowledgement of the ethical and complex nature of studying human behavior and societies.
CAUSE
EXAMPLE
Artists strive to innovate, challenge, and inspire through their work, contributing to the dynamic and evolving landscape of artistic expression
WHY?
These fresh ideas play a crucial role in shaping the arts and their ability to resonate with and captivate audiences.
WHY?
These ideas are driven by a desire to advance knowledge, address pressing issues, and challenge existing paradigms in the pursuit of a more comprehensive understanding of the human experience
Combination of knowledge
refers to the cooperation and interaction between individuals or teams from different academic disciplines or fields of expertise to address complex problems, conduct research, or tackle challenges that cannot be effectively addressed by a single discipline alone
study of human behavior
The Arts
An artistic community reluctant to accept constant exploration of possibilities and creative horizons
consequences?
It can limit the acceptance and recognition of innovative artists and their groundbreaking concepts within the artistic landscape.
study of societies
resistance to embrace the understanding and studying human behavior, societies, and cultures.
why?
due to the persistence of existing theories, resistance to change in methodologies, peer review processes, cultural influences, and the complexity of human behavior.
prove it
what makes the
apa impact on the production
apa dia punya impact, kena dia amik masa, jgn cerita impact banyak sgt, takut nanti tak link to slow adoption
It can hinder the integration of fresh, groundbreaking ideas into the field of human sciences, impacting its development and evolution.
resistance or reluctance to accept fresh ideas or innovative concepts
why?
persistence in adhering to established theories and practices
cause?
can hinder the integration of new knowledge and innovative ideas into the field.
It can act as a barrier to the acceptance of fresh ideas within the discipline
evidence
human science
Cultural Psychology and Indigenous Knowledge
The Art
Digital and New Media Art
With the advent of digital technology, new media art forms, such as digital art, interactive installations, and virtual reality experiences, emerged. These fresh ideas faced resistance and a lack of understanding within traditional art circles.
impact
As digital and new media art gained traction, they challenged traditional notions of art, expanding the possibilities of artistic expression. Their slow adoption paved the way for innovative and immersive art experiences.
Psychology
examines the role of culture in shaping human behavior and cognition, has been slow to adopt indigenous knowledge systems
Indigenous
well-being, healing, and community have often been marginalized.
impact
The slow adoption of indigenous knowledge within cultural psychology has hindered the recognition and incorporation of fresh ideas that could contribute to a more holistic understanding of human behavior and well-being in diverse cultural contexts.
An artistic community reluctant to accept constant exploration of possibilities and creative horizons for several reasons, impacting the development of knowledge and creativity in society.
To what extent does the correlation between the cautious adoption of fresh ideas in area of knowledge contribute to an understanding of the human experience, and how does this influence the development of knowledge and creativity in society?
how the tension between the conservative approach often seen in human science, the innovative spirit of the arts, and the resistance to change impacts the holistic understanding of the human experience
cautious adoption of fresh ideas in AOK
influence on the development of knowledge and creativity in society
Vigorous research and ethical concerns can occasionally obstruct innovative solutions to complex societal problems and constrain a comprehensive grasp of the human experience.
slow to adopt
Researchers may be hesitant to explore unconventional or untested approaches due to concerns about the validity and ethical implications of their work.
similarities and differences, boleh je come out with our own definition of something (eg: fresh idea)
arise from Resistance to Change, Complexity of Ideas
Complexity of Ideas
Resistance to Change
Fresh ideas can sometimes be complex..
cause?
difficult to understand and hence making the adoption of the fresh idea challenging
what happen next?
may take time to fully grasp the new concepts Before embracing them
RLE #1
“Jackson Pollock No. 1 Poster, 2016” by Jackson Pollock sell at $50
artistic community reluctant to embrace constant exploration because they fear that art may be driven more by financial motivations than artistic expression
what cause the community to reluctant?
when art is heavily commercialized with some works fetching exorbitant prices, it can create a perception from society that the art world prioritizes monetary value over artistic expression
arises because of the fear of the unknown, the desire for stability
why?
because artists may not know what to expect, how it will affect them, or what challenges it may bring
what happen next?
This fear of uncertainty can lead to resistance, even if the change is ultimately beneficial.
why?
market demand
The art market can exert significant influence on the artistic community.
why?
Art that sells well often conforms to established norms and expectations
consequences
artists may be reluctant to explore fresh ideas and creative horizons for fear of commercial failure.
Established conventions, styles, and traditions may be upheld due to their familiarity and perceived reliability, even if they limit the exploration of new creative horizons.
central inquiry tak jadi
use a familiar artistic styles, techniques, and themes
Artists, critics, and audiences may prefer the security of the known over the challenges of the new.
impact
can lead to resistance against new and unexplored creative avenues
counter-argument
Artistic communities should actively encourage and embrace constant exploration of possibilities and creative horizons as it is essential for the vitality and evolution of the arts.
Sandro Botticelli’s ‘Young Man Holding a Roundel’ Sells for $92.2 Million at Sotheby’s
One example that demonstrates an artist's reluctance to sell their art due to concerns about market demand and compromising the integrity of their artistic expression is the case of Jackson Pollock, a renowned American abstract expressionist artist. ------------------------------- Pollock is famous for his "drip painting" technique, where he would pour and drip paint onto large canvases in a seemingly chaotic and uncontrolled manner. He was a pioneer of abstract expressionism, and his work was deeply rooted in the idea of spontaneous, emotional, and unbridled artistic expression. ------------------In his early career, Pollock struggled financially, but he was committed to his artistic vision and did not want to compromise his unique style to cater to the art market's demands. He was known for resisting commercialism and was hesitant to sell his work because he didn't want to water down or commercialize his artistic expression for the sake of making a profit. His focus was on the act of creating, rather than the act of selling. ---------------------------------- Over time, Pollock did start selling some of his work, but he remained true to his avant-garde style. Eventually, his art gained recognition and value, becoming highly influential in the world of contemporary art. This example illustrates how some artists prioritize their artistic vision and creative integrity over immediate financial gain, often taking the risk that their work may not be readily accepted or understood by the market.