What are the tolerance limits of plants to a particular stimuli

Controlled Variables

Dependent Variables (How will tolerance be measured?)

Independent variables (What impacts plant growth? - Stimuli)

Other Factors to consider

What plant species is used?

Temperature

pH

Nutrients

Nitrogen (N)

Plants cannot accept nitrogen that is in the air because they cannot break down the strong triple covalent bond and instead use nitrogen in the form of nitrate (NO3) and ammonium (NH4). If too much of these compounds are present in the soil or water, it can be toxic causing leaves to discolor and veins in leaves to collapse. Excess nitrogen past the plant's tolerance limit

Enzymes are crucial to the function of any living being however, exposure to temperatures that are too high or too low beyond the enzyme's optimal temperature will cause it to denature or become inactive. As such when a plant is grown in temperature that is too high or too low the enzymes that perform vital functions for the plant's growth and survival will no longer be able to do their job leading to a slowing of growth and eventual plant death.

Temperature is hard to control in the lab because, would require a lot on energy to keep consistent high temperatures, high enough to see an effect on the dependent variable and exceed the tolerance limit. High temperatures for hydroponic plants also means the risk of bacteria and the error of evaporating water is exceeded hard to keep consistent for both the plants in cooler temperatures and hotter temperatures increasing possibility for systematic error.

Light Intensity/Time Exposed to Intense Light

O2 concentration

Too much light not only dries out the plant as the heat will evaporate moisture but can also cause bleaching and pale leaves that can no longer photosynthesize. This leads to a lack of glucose and if too far beyond the plant's tolerance limit for too long, eventual death.

Too little light means photosynthesis cannot take place and the plant will not be able to produce glucose and as a result energy (ATP) necessary for biological processes and chemical reactions crucial to the function of the plant. Because plants are autotrophs photosynthesis is the only way they can access this energy and without sufficient light the plant will die.

Salinity

How is it grown?

Measure Daily for more accuracy, at the same time each day

Hydroponic Planters

Pros: nutrients are completely controlled, plants grow quickly, roots can be measured easily, water availability is not a factor.

Cons: Harder to set up (equipment must be water proof), water can evaporate creating possible inconsistencies for different trials, still water may attract bacteria and insects changing variables, any necessary nutrients must be sourced externally which requires more time

Soil

Plant must be: fast growing, able to grown hydroponically, cheap and accessible.

Mint

Signs of plants living in environments outside of their optimum (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33797719/)

Height of plant

discoloration (browning at leaf tips indicating too little water or too much sunlight, necrotic leaves/yellowing on leaves indicating nutrient deficiencies)

.

shorter and thinner roots

Root length may decrease or increase based on the availability of necessities as the plant searches for water or nutrients as opposed to the health of the plant. Not only this but the length and width of roots is very hard to measure and has a high risk of error.

Plant Maintenance

Distilled Water

Distilled water must be used to keep the minerals and nutrients the plants are exposed to consistent for every following trial. Water directly from the tap may contain slight impurities or minerals that are not measured which have a chance to impact plant growth.

Time exposed & intensity of light (growth lamps)

Keeping the plants next to a window may ensure consistent light exposure for all the plants in the trial on that day, however, depending on the day there may be different periods of varying intensities of light, making the calculated growth rate per day hard to compare to other applications and making it harder to accurately recreate the experiment .

.

What is the optimum level of nitrogen for spearmint plants?

Depending on the season or climate of the area uncontrolledly factors like humidity or pollution may impact the growth of the plants

Regular addition of Phosphorus and Potassium

Cleaning out water once each week

Sunlight

Temperature (the lab temperature is kept the same at room at 22 degrees)

Without the addition of other necessary nutrients like phosphorus and potassium the mint seedlings cannot access these necessary nutrients as they are being grown hydroponically. These nutrients also cannot be substituted with more nitrogen as each nutrient is used for different but still crucial functions in the plant. If there is no available phosphorus and potassium each plant would be limited by this factor and die out rather than being effected by the concentration of ammonia available to it and the experiment would not work.

Refreshing the water that the mint is grown in regularly is important because the still water becomes a hotspot for algae and bacteria . By refreshing the water this insures sterility of the plant and . Leaving water for too long can also affect its pH which if too high or low will denature enzymes in plant cells leading to less efficient reactions, slower growth and eventual death.

If the pH is too far acidic or alkaline from the functional pH of the plant's enzymes, the enzymes will denature and their unique 3D shape will unravel/change. Because a proteins function is dependent on its unique structure this change prevents the enzymes from performing its function causing cell death for the plant.

If salinity is too high due to the difference in solute concentration in the environment and in the plant roots water will exit the plant and into the soil. As plants rely on osmosis for the uptake of water without the solute concentration being lower in the environment little water can be taken in by the plant despite a possible abundance of water surrounding it. Without water the plant cannot function and so will eventually die out. If salinity is too low na+ ions are not present and the plant cannot

If oxygen concentrations are too low the mitochondria in the plant cells cannot perform aerobic respiration and cannot convert its glucose into usable energy. This means that functions in the cell that require energy cannot take place and the plant will eventually die out.

Light intensity is hard to quantify with the limited equipment available in the lab and so it would be difficult to produce accurate and specific data points relevant for future research.

Changing the level of nutrients is chosen because it is easily quantifiable and measurements are universal and easily comparable even outside the scope the experiment. Because of this, the results of the experiment can be better analyzed as other literature can be directly referenced. Finally the tolerance limits of most plants is quite narrow and so should be evidence of slower growth at both ends which ensures a more thorough exploration of the main question.

CO2 Concentration

If carbon dioxide concentrations are too low the chloroplast in plant cells are unable to perform photosynthesis as one of the reactants is not available. [6CO2+6H2O -> C6H12O6+6O2] This means that glucose that is used in the mitochondria to produce ATP cannot be created, leading to eventual plant death.

Controlling carbon dioxide concentrations requires a well sealed system to prevent any gas from escaping, and makes checking up on and maintaining the plants' need much more complicated as well. Because this process would not be possible in the available laboratory it would not be a feasible independent variable to investigate.

Controlling oxygen concentrations requires a well sealed system to prevent any gas from escaping, and makes checking up on and maintaining the plants' need much more complicated as well. Because this process would not be possible in the available laboratory it would not be a feasible independent variable to investigate.

Pros: Easy to buy soils already containing all necessary nutrients, bacterial, microbes, etc., increasing the likelihood of successful growth. A wider range of plants can grow in soil even after germination and until maturity.

Cons: Nutrients are hard to isolate if using soil as a growing medium. Roots are visually obscured and soil type and quality can vary greatly depending on brand introducing potential for random error. This is because depending on the attributes of the soil it may absorb water, nutrients, toxins, etc., differently.

Germination in Cotton

Pros: Many seeds can be tested at once/many trials can be completed in the experiment very easily, improving the reliability of results. By testing so many seeds the impact of random error is reduced as results are not as relent on the behavior of one or two plants. Seeds also only require minimal maintenance and
tend to germinate quickly increasing the chance of a successful experiment unaffected by human error.

Cons: To test how tolerance limits impact plant growth is difficult if only the germination period is considered. While it is an important part of plant growth, seed germination often has slightly different parameters to actual plant growth such as --. This means that determining the tolerance limits of certain plant species would not be as accurate.

To be able to photosynthesize to have energy for cell function some form of light is required. Without this, cells cannot sustain themselves and undergo cell division, leading to a slower growth rate. To avoid this an equal amount of sunlight is provided to all plants in the experiment.

Consistent amount of water for each plant and consistent topping up of water (each weekl)

While discoloration is a clear sign of nutrient deficiencies similarly to difficulties when measuring the surface area of leaves, measuring the amount of plant impacted by discoloration can be hard due to the unusual shape of leaves and the fragility of dead leaves. Some amount of personal say may also go into what would be considered discoloration, leading to potential differences each time the experiment is repeated.

less seed germination

To test how tolerance limits impact plant growth is difficult if only the germination period is considered. While it is an important part of plant growth, seed germination often has slightly different parameters to actual plant growth such as --. This means that determining the tolerance limits of certain plant species would not be as accurate.

Nitrogen is chosen as the nutrient that will be used as the independent variable because of its larger impact on plant growth. Outside of nutrients plants obtain through photosynthesis nitrogen is the nutrient taken up by plants in the largest quantities and therefore should have the largest impact on a plant's mass. This means that the impact of this IV should be easier to observe and measure which may lead to more accurate data.

The optimum level of nitrogen for spearmint plants is 3/100 grams per Liter (30ppm) or approximately 1.6 grams per liter.

Hybrids of spearmint species/ variations (e.g. mentha spicata var. crispa) may result in slight differences in tolerance limits as the gene pool has been changed. Care should be taken when choosing plants of the appropriate species.

Spearmint

While other species of mint such as peppermint generally require cooler temperatures to thrive, spearmint can more comfortably grow in warmer temperatures and as the lab is likely to lean towards warmer temperatures spearmint is chosen to minimize the risk of any plants dying due to external factors.

Other macro and micro nutrients

Macronutrients like potassium, phosphorus, sulfur, calcium or magnesium and micronutrients like iron or zinc, etc., all are crucial for the growth of plants. For example, potassium and phosphorus are used in plants in their vascular systems and in vegetables and fruits, as well as for root and seed growth and nucleotide production.

While important, micronutrients are used by plants in such small quantities that performing different trials with varying levels of these nutrients would be difficult to complete accurately. And, while macro nutrients like potassium and phosphorus are used in larger quantities and necessary for plant survival are not quite as impactful on a plant's biomass as nitrogen is.

Without nitrogen plants have reduced stalk growth and ability to grow fruit. Nitrogen is also required in the synthesis of amino acids, proteins, and in the formation of nitrogenous bases, making it crucial in the growth of any plant.

The disposal of fertilizer in bins or down sinks should be limited and disposal should be done appropriately based on the type of fertilizer. Careless disposal of chemical and biosolid fertilizer waste may result in the contamination of water leading to environmental consequences. Instead spare fertilizer should be used elsewhere or placed in a bag and transported to a hazardous waste facility.

While mint does grow primarily vertically depending on variables such as light location (plant leaves and stems will generally grow towards the closest light and unless this light is directly above the plant this will cause a perceived decrease in the vertical height of the stem.,

Mass of plant

Measuring the mass of the plant includes growth of the roots, stem and leaves and takes into consideration growth through height but also width as well. This ensures to a better ability that any growth, even if not visible to the eye, is measured. And therefore, a more accurate image of the impact the ID has on the plant can be formed.

Legumes

Bugs, bacteria and fungi in the still water may slow plant growth and decrease plant mass.

The trials will consist of a control with none, too little (0.8 g/L), too much (2.4 g/L) and the optimal amount of ammonia sulfate to get a wide spread of data and hopefully illustrate the nitrogen tolerance limits of the seedlings.

How will nitrogen be made available to the plants

To ensure control of the independent variable nitrogen will be provided through a nitrogen fertilizer.

Urea/ Organic Fertilizers

Ammonia Sulfate

Although natural and easy to dispose of safely, urea contains many other nutrients and even disregarding this can have varying amounts of ammonia/nitrogen depending on the source leading to a less accurate experiment

Ammonia sulfate is made of only ammonia and sulfate and so ensures that no other unaccounted for nutrients are being provided potentially changing the plant's growth rate. Sulfate is also non-toxic to plants and has little impact on its growth provided an excess amount is not provided.

Surface area of green leaves,

Number of leaves, fruits, flowers, vegetables, etc.

Depending on the temperature of its environment, plants will react in various ways due to different rates of reactions, activity levels of enzymes, denaturing etc. As such, unless all the plants are kept under the same consistent temperatures, unaccounted variation may occur leading to errors in the data.

While understanding the salt concentration tolerance limits of plants can be relevant and useful information, often times this information would only be used by larger commercial farms, soil testers, etc., and may not be as applicable as the tolerance limits of ammonia sulfate. This is because nitrogen fertilizers are often added by hand and understanding the limits could directly influence the actions of many gardeners.

When disposing of ammonia sulfate care must be taken so it does not end up in water ways. This is because as a concentrated fertilizer it can cause many negative impacts such as eutrophication, ruining ecosystems and the environment.

Simply counting the number of leaves, etc., does not take into account the size and health of these parts of the plant. It also may not be very specific as all the plants may only grow one or two flowers each, providing little data to analyze. Fruits, flowers and vegetables can also be very dependent on the season or the fertilization of the plant's gametes restricting the experiment quite significantly.

While a healthy plant will have a higher number of larger leaves when compared to an unhealthy plant of the same species, surface area of a biological organism can be very hard to accurately calculate because of its unique shape, and other simpler measurements can be just as insightful.

% Rate of Growth

Measuring the rate at which each plant is growing ensures that initial differences in mass do not influence results and all plants have a level playing field. It also provides some flexibility

Rate of Growth

While looking at the rate of growth does eliminate discrepancies in the initial masses of the plants, it fails to take into consideration the fact that smaller plants with smaller leaves and roots would

Water is required for photosynthesis but also required for the transport of nutrients to cells. Without ample water this limits the plant's growth and would result in a decrease in mass regardless of the concentration of ammonia sulfate.

Plant cannot have nitrogen fixing bacteria or else the independent variable will change (e.g. peas, beans and other legumes which are commonly contain these bacteria)

Mint generally takes only two weeks to grow to full height and has a fast growth rate ensuring that a clear impact should be clearly visible in the data. Mint also thrives when grown hydroponically, is cheap and easily accessible.