Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
US interest groups v UK pressure groups - Coggle Diagram
US interest groups v UK pressure groups
RIGHTS PROTECTION
US more effective
parties in the UK are more united than in the US and so civil-rights-based interest groups have more success in persuading legislative politicians in Congress
US civil rights groups have a greater choice of institutions to lobby while UK civil rights groups that fails to convince government will find it harder to achieve success in parliament
stronger levels of rights protections in the US means groups have greater prominence
UK
UK has a stronger tradition of respecting civil rights than in the US so groups have more success as there is more concern here for respecting minority rights
METHODS
similarities
both use lobbying
both use direct action and demonstrations
differences
in the US, legal methods are more attractive to interest groups than in the UK due to constitutional sovereignty and the power of the US SC
ACCESS POINTS
US
there are more access points in the US system because the separation of powers and federalism create a multitude of power centres
UK
because power is concentrated in the hands of the government, the only groups that gain power are those that can influence the government (insider pressure groups)
PARTIES
UK
Stricter party discipline in the UK means that MPs are strongly accountable to political leaders - Interest groups know it will be difficult to persuade individual MPs to vote against the party line
US
The lack of powerful party leaders (caused largely by the separation of powers and primaries) allows US pressure groups to influence legislative politicians more than those in the UK.
ELECTIONS
UK
In the UK it is highly unlikely that an environmental campaign group would be able to unseat any of their target MPs in a general election. It is also hard to imagine a UK version of the US League of Conservation Voters
US
Electioneering is far more intense in the US, where it can be a highly effective method