PROCHASKA'S SIX STAGE MODEL

overview

change occurred through a subtle and often complex progression

emphasises the gradual nature of change, occurs through a fixed series of six discrete stages

recognised that overcoming addiction was rarely the result of one single decision to change

individuals move through these stages in order, but may, on occasion, relapse and revert to an earlier stage before repeating the cycle again

the six stages of change

stage 3. preparation - action is taken in the form of planning and preparation, small behavioural changes 'i am changing next month so i need to plan how i will do it'

stage 6. termination - no longer tempted to revert to the former behaviour and is completely confident that they are able to maintain the change - relapse cannot occur 'i will never do it again'

stage 2. contemplation - show an awareness, have not yet made a commitment to do anything about it, do not act on it 'i will change tomorrow'

stage 4. action - plan is put into action, the person actually makes a change in their behaviour. relapse can occur in this stage 'i have stopped'

stage 1. pre contemplation - unaware that their behaviour is unhealthy and becoming problematic, do not have an intention to change their behaviour - 'i am ok right now'

stage 5. maintenance - consolidate the gains attained during the previous stage to prevent relapse. maintenance strategies are employed, relapse can still occur 'i have still stopped'

research support

there was also no demographic differences in success (gender, age) suggesting that it suits all groups

however that success was dependent on the smoking habits (eg frequency) of the individual

velicer et al 2007 conducted a meta analysis of 5 studies and found that there was a 22-26% success rate - smoking cessation

weakness

baumann et al 2015 randomly allocated problem drinkers, to either an experimental group, who received an intervention tailored to their motivational stage or a control group, who received minimal intervention only

found no significant difference in beneficial effects between the staged intervention group and the control group

research challenges the effectiveness of the model

the advantages of Prochaska's model may have been overstated

social norms

eg Arab smokers - 62% in pre contemplation, 14% in preparation stage

daoud et al 2015 - found that in arab cultures, cigarettes are distributed during social events such as weddings - making it more difficult to quit

uk smokers 40% in pre contemplation, 20% in preparation stage

social norms and pressures that limit the effectiveness of therapeutic interventions

fails to acknowledge the importance of social norms in changing behaviour