Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Descartes, Locke, Kant, Hume, Leibniz, Berkeley - Coggle Diagram
Descartes
-
Free Will
-
-
If I can always make the right choices that is true and good, I am entirely free without being indifferent
God
-
Existence of God
-
-
There must be at least as much formal reality as objective reality, and only God can cause this many formal reality (first idea/final cause)
God is perfect, existing is a perfection, so God must exist
-
-
Locke
-
-
Quality
Primary Quality
Idea does resemble objects. The quality is within the objects themselves, it exists with or without being perceived
-
Secondary Quality
Idea does not resemble objects. The quality is the power within the objects that cause people to have resemblance of the objects
Identity
-
Same person
Same consciousness (memory), not soul, not body, makes the same person
-
Power
Active Power
Power to cause changes, comes from reflection
Passive Power
Power to be changed, comes from experience
-
Knowledge
Knowledge is perception, perception of the agreement and disagreement of two ideas. Without perception, we can only have faith and fancies.
-
Degree of knowledge
Demonstrative: need intervention of other ideas to perceive. As certain, but not so clear as intuitive knowledge
-
-
-
Kant
-
Understanding
-
Not a faculty of intuition, but of the connection of intuitions in an experience
-
-
Knowledge
What we can never know
Freedom
The world of experience is deterministic (physical laws), but it is the soul that determines if one is free or not
-
-
-
Free Will
Whether someone is free is determined by if he is the faculty of starting something (Be the certain cause of appearance)
-
-
-
Skepticism
Dream Scenario
What distinguishes truth and dreams is the connection to the rules which determines the coherence of the representations in the concept of an object
Causality
Agree with Hume that we cannot comprehend by reason that the reference of one thing can infer another
-
Our understanding does not derive experience, rather, the experience derives our understanding
Hume
Causality
There is no actual causation. We cannot find any power or necessary connection, we can only find one follow the other
Body to body causation
No, there could be succession or conjunction, but not causation
Mind to body causation
No, when we are sleep, our minds cannot direct our bodies even if we want to
Mind to mind causation
No, we cannot immediately aware of the power of the mind
-
-
Habits
-
It is actually habits that we formed from former experiences give us the impression of necessary connection
All cause/effect reasoning is based on habits and customs, rooted in experience of regularity
-
-
-
-
God
Not the final cause
-
We are ignorant, so we cannot actually know what God is capable of
If God is the final cause, then either there is no evil, or God is the cause of evil
Existence
-
Useless
Our knowledge is inferred from the nature, we cannot use those knowledge to return back from the cause and draw new inferences
-
Skepticism
Two kinds
Cartesian Skepticism
Incurable, once you know, you would not have assurance for anything
-
-
Leibniz
-
God
Definition: God is Omniscient, Omnipotent, and Benevolent (Perfect).
God does not allow any disorders, and he knows every truth in the past and the future
-
Extraordinary
Miracles: though miracles are extraordinary, it is not out of order
What God does
God creates the best of all possible worlds, which is this world
-
-
-
-
Inesse
-
Concept
Individual concept
The concept that only this individual has. Every truth about the individual subject can be derived and extracted by pure thoughts
-
-
External world
Nothing comes from the external world, because all the appearances are not been caused by anything external. They are unfold inside you
If everything external is annihilated except you and God, you would not notice any differences
Monad
Everything is made of Monad, every monad perceives. They do not perish
Spirit
The only monad that acquires will, memory, and apperception (self consciousness)
-
-
-
Soul
Body belongs to soul, together, they constitute living beings (animals)
-
-
Knowledge and Definition
Knowledge
-
Clear and distinct
Intuitive knowledge: mind understands at once, true, very rare.
Definition
Real Definition: no contradiction, Must be possible
-
-
-
-
Berkeley
External World
-
Matter
-
The common sense is that there is no matter, because things that are immediately perceived cannot exist outside of mind
-
-
Real existence
The real existence of the things must depend on a mind. It cannot be my mind, but the mind of an infinite, omnipresent spirit, God.
Ideas
-
-
Ideas must come from minds. Ideas I perceived must come from another mind other than mine. It is from the mind of God
-
God
Infinite, Omnipresent, and perceives all things
-
God's mind is wise, powerful, and good beyond comprehension which affects me every moment with all the sensible impressions I perceive
-
God only immediately cause actions, but sins do not consist in actions, so God does not cause things
Knowledge
Real things are those what we see and feel, and perceive by senses
I, a thinking being exist
I know the meaning of myself intuitively. I am a thinking, active principle that perceives, knows, wills, and operates about ideas
-
-