Why has migration become increasingly complex? KQ2a
Economic factors
Complicating factors
Environmental factors
Demographic factors
Political factors
Interdependence
Economic globalisation
- new source / host countries
- south to south migration
- new bilateral corridors
Political factors:
- policy change
- conflict & persecution
Demographic characteristics of migrants:
- young people
- women
Environmental factors:
- climate change
Global interconnectivity - all of the varied economic, social, political, cultural and environmental linkages between people, places and environments that make up global systems
Global interdependence - the idea that many states, societies and businesses have become mutually dependent on one another due to the complex ways in which global systems have evolved over time; economic, social, political and environmental dimensions of interdependence.
Economic interdependence:
- TNCs growth, accelerates cross-border mutual exchanges of money & merchandise
- flows of migrant workers, countries economic success & send home remittances to source
- interconnected world, no longer self-sufficient in vital commodities, widespread relations of mutual reliance
Social interdependence:
- international migration builds extensive family networks across national borders, can strengthen friendships between states e.g. India & UK
- remittances sent home to a source can be as much as 40% GDP for poorer states (Tajikistan), helps fund education & health, also help health & education of host country e.g. NHS
Political interdependence:
- growth of trade blocs, complex international and global governance structures, co-create, legally bound
- governments of some countries depend on one another in times of economic or political crisis e.g. UK and USA
- WB, IMF, WTO work globally to harmonise national economic rules
Environmental interdependence:
- co-operate on global environmental threats like climate change, all countries depend on global commons, mutually felt need to share responsibility and help mitigate risks
- agreements or treaties only work if a critical mass of countries sign up, all states depend on others to build consensus e.g. Paris Agreement 2015
Inter-regional:
India - > USA
- 76% indian migrants moving into high skilled jobs VS 41% 'native' Americans
- immigration from India significantly higher educated, more likely better household incomes ($132,000 vs $66,000), more likely to be employed
- migration flow due to job opportunities and pay
- UN forecasts estimate anywhere between 25 million- 1 billion environmental migrants by 2050
- climate change (gradual) and natural disasters (sudden, mass)
- diverse factors such as population growth, poverty, governance, human security and conflict all interact with the climate change aspect
- amount of storms, floods and droughts in the US region continues to rise
- El Salvador alone is projected to lose 10-28% of its coastline before the end of the century
- global sea level rise could be worse than expected and this could result in land loss of 1.79 M km2, including critical regions of food production, and displacement of up to 187 million people globally
- Africa: climate change, land degradation and climate refugees
Professor Mastrojeni:
- "poverty trap" with poorest not afford to migrate
- climate change effects poorest more
- Maldives, sea level rise, buy another island in future
- mountains melting & sea level rise, cause huge displacement of people
- impacts ecosystems & food sources
- mass migration & climate change are linked
Lake Chad, environmental change:
- Lake Chad used to spread up to 10,000 square miles, but it has lost 90% of its surface area since the early 1970s
- Today, 4/5 of the wetland has been lost, - water table declined as much as 80 feet
- The Tiga Dam was finished upstream 2 decades before 1992 (1984), causing drying up of rivers, supplied a state irrigation project south of Kano (biggest city in Nigeria)
- In 1979 a state-owned rice company built the Maga Dam to divert its head waters in the Mandara Mountains to new paddy fields, and raise 60 miles of embankments, fish yields fell by 90%, water tables fell, hundred thousand people who had depended on the floods for their livelihood were left destitute
Impact on migration: - Local people depart the Badlands, while bad people move in
- Between 2013 and 2016, more than 2.3 million people were displaced due to environmental and social chaos, including 1.3 million children
- Youths in the Lake Chad Basin are joining the Boko Haram terrorist group because of lack of jobs and difficult economic conditions resulting from the drying up of the lake and extinction of its resources
Increasing numbers of women migrating:
- In some regions such as Europe, Latin America and the Caribbean, North America and Oceania, the number of female international migrants has now exceeded that of men
- increasing female independence and status, greater freedom and the growing importance of women as main income earner
- not the case for Africa and Asia where factors such as regulations governing female admission and departure from some countries and the status of women are restrictive
- growing trend is the migration of highly skilled, graduate women especially to countries where there is less discrimination in the labour market and where in general women’s rights are better respected
- almost half of all migrants are women
- migrants, especially migrant women, have higher labour force participation rates (72.7 per cent) than non-migrants (63.9 per cent)
- every sixth domestic worker in the world is an international migrant, and women make up 73.4 per cent of international migrant domestic workers
ASEAN gender-based migration bans:
- 2009, women from Myanmar permitted to work abroad
- 2012, Cambodian domestic workers required to have parental permission to extend contracts & renew passports
- Mid-late 2014, Myanmar ban on migration for any domestic work to any country
Young workers:
- most economic migrants, seeking greater employment opportunities, higher wages and the possibility of sending remittances, are young
- young workers, mobile, seek job opportunities
- approx 8.5 million Indians live and work in the Gulf, the vast majority of them semi-skilled or unskilled workers
- regional variation in the age characteristics of migrants. E.g. older migrants outnumber younger migrants in the ‘Global North’, younger migrants outnumber older migrants in the ‘Global South’
- In the South, 21% of all international migrants are under the age of 20 whereas in the North this is 9%
Globalisation:
- since 1980s, trend towards laissez-faire economic policies
- lifted economic barriers
- increasing trade, investment and communication, reinforcing migrant links
Internal:
EDCs such as China, India, Mexico & Brazil
- driven by foreign investment created agglomerations of economic activity near large urban centres
- rural to urban migration, reinforced
China - rural Henan province had biggest exodus of 10.25 million
- 90% China in urban areas
- urban Guangdong province received 20.5 million migrants
- central regions to coastlines since 1978
Technological globalisation & advancements:
- revolutions have radically reduced the costs of (air) travel and communication over increasingly long distances
- threshold levels of wealth required to move, by bringing down costs of travel and communication
- strengthened migrant networks and transnational ties (stay in touch, go back home often, remittances)
- increased literacy and education alongside improved access to “global” information
Reduced migration: - technology can also allow people to stay at home e.g. work from home, easier long distance commuting
- technology has made the world more mobile, it has not necessarily made the world more migratory
- human resources and economic activities have become increasingly concentrated in a relatively low number of countries or, more precisely, metropolitan areas within a few countries
Bilateral corridors:
- develop as a result of economic, social and political factors
- 1990-2000, 7/10 bilateral corridors with the largest average annual increase in the number of international migrants had a country in the North as destination
- USA destination of 5/10, Mexico USA largest, 500,000 migrants 1990-2000
- 2000- 2010, however, the ten largest bilateral migration corridors were equally split between North & South
- Mexico-USA still largest, 280,000 additional migrants per year
- 2010- 2017, migration patterns shifted significantly with only one country in the North, namely the USA - largely decrease due to greater border control
- 2010-2017, the three largest bilateral migration corridors consisted of refugee movements e.g. Syria -> Turkey
South-South migration:
- world’s 82 million South-South migrants forming about 36% of the total stock of migrants
- 87% of refugees are located in countries in the south
Proximity - 80% continuous borders, costs, lack of travel documents
Networks - ethnic, community, and family ties reduce the costs and uncertainties involved
Income - middle income from nearby low income (e.g. Zimbabwe -> South Africa), low income to less low income (e.g. Niger -> Ghana), 38% of South-South migrants come from countries with higher incomes
Conflict & disaster - escape war, often first step in asylum to go to neighbouring country
ASEAN:
- Intra-regional migration in ASEAN increased significantly 1995-2015, turning Malaysia, Singapore, and Thailand into regional migration hubs with 6.5 million migrants – 96% total number of migrant workers in ASEAN
- approx $62B in remittances were sent to ASEAN countries in 2015, 10% GDP in Philippines
- ASEAN migrants are often low-skilled and undocumented who are compelled, economic migration
- The ASEAN Economic Community has taken steps to facilitate mobility, but only certain professions e.g. doctors, these professions just 5% jobs in region
Policies:
- ACs, more protectionist measures, immigrants may only be accepted if certain skills requirement e.g. point system Australia
- developing countries, benefit higher levels of emmigration where remittances sent home
- policies can change overtime
- USA immigration focus on family reunification, Canada & Australia points based system, Trump did want more points based
Venezuela: emigration controls:
- UN estimates by June 2018, 2.3 million people (7% countries population) left
- people leaving due to collapse of economy, oil prices fell $112 to $62 in 2014 ; poverty rate now nearly 90% population, 33% unemployment
- Vice President announced police "immediately" take control of countries 72 entry/exit points
- Rodriguez also announce several major changes to countries passport fees, making ti harder, new amount 4x monthly minimum wage
Increased refugees:
25.4 million, 2.9 million more than in 2016 (biggest increase in a single year)
- 68% from 5 countries, Syrian Arab Republic 6.3 million, Afghanistan, 2.6 million, South Sudan 2.4 million, Myanmar 1.2 million, Somalia 986,4000
- refugees due to: effects of conflict (e.g. damage to infrastructure), political persecution, discrimination, violation of human rights, economic hardship and persecution as a result of fried labour and modern slavery
- Sub-Saharan Africa saw the largest increase in refugee numbers for any UNHCR region in 2017 with the population increasing by more than a fifth to 6.3 million by the year’s end. This was driven in the main by the crisis in South Sudan which led to 1 million people fleeing their homes.
- refugees move to countries nearby their country of origin
- refugees come from N.Africa & W.Asia region, currently conflicts in DRC, Yemen, Syria, Afrganisatan etc