L + R: Sappho

Scholarly views

Themes

Context

Leftkowitz

  • Women poets are emotionally disturbed meaning their poems are psychological outpourings
  • These outpourings are not intellectual but instead ingenuous and concerned with their inner emotional lives alone

Freeman and Norton

  • Sappho is attacking the idea that women are a commodity to their future husband and should stay chaste
  • Brided virginity is a form of masculine oppression on younger women
  • Sappho displaying women as sexually liberal prior to marriage is reducing their value as a commodity in the eyes of the man

Burnett

  • The circularity of Sapphic love

Wilson

  • Poem designed to give comfort in a way that could be perceived as maternal if it not be for the lingering over erotic details

Bennett

  • Sappho openly writes about lesbian love, it can't have been shunned and suppressed during the period of her writing

Wilamowitz

  • Provided the idea of the theasos that Sappho was supposedly writing in and running

Topoi
Topoi are reoccurring features within literature and there are quite a few within Sappho

  • The pain of Love
  • The fertility of nature
  • Youth as beauty
  • Relationships with the gods
  • Nature as a metaphor for sex
  • A shift of narrator or focus within a poem

Sappho

  • Very wealthy and she would have been involved with only Aristocratic women in her Theasos
  • Not a feminist, mocks and undermines women that are a lot less wealthy than her
  • Apart of a theasos which is an institution that teaches women how to be good wives in marriage
  • Lack of religious and social sanctions for Sappho suggests lesbian love was accepted
  • Sappho herself was Aristocratic
  • Writing during a period of strife in Lesbos where no family held power

Important fragments

Loeb 1, Sappho Please for Aphrodites help

  • Kletic poem addressed to the goddess Aphrodite Burkett
  • Aphrodite is placed on a pedostool by Sappho, she loves and respects her
  • "Release me from this great distress" + "Whom Sappho is hurting you now" : Topos of love being depicted as painful
  • "Whom do you want me to bring back to you this time" : Burnett, represents the circularity of Sapphic love
  • Sappho appropriates love with war, Love is as dangerous as war itself

Burkett

  • Worship of Aphrodite finds its most personal and complete expressions in the poems of sappho

Loeb 15, message to her brother

  • Sappho has a brother (Charaxus) who was a merchant who traded abroad in Egypt where he met a prostitute who he fell in love with (Doricha)
  • Sapphos brother has returned to Egypt to Doricha because of his love for her
  • Sappho is not happy about this, calling on Aphrodite to punish Doricha probably because of her status
  • Sappho not a feminist, She shows prejudices to those in lower classes and actually only favours aristocratic women
  • Resembles again Sappho's view of love as a weapon

Loeb 16, Sapphos view of love

  • Believes the most beautiful sight in the world is the one that you love and not things like infantry or a fleet of ships (homeric)
  • Priamel, list of metaphorical comparisons made prior to the real subject of the poem is revealed
  • Shows how powerful love is through her mentioning of Helen, She left Menelaus "excellent of all men" because of love
  • Mirrors achilles' words to Odysseus in the underworld, She would rather see her lovely walk and her gleaming face than all the chariots+soildiers+men
  • Leftkowitz, Women psychologically disturbed, this is an outpouring of Sapphos inner thoughts
    105a, just like a sweet apple
  • Important Loeb as Sappho appears as a more maternal figure here, Wilson
  • Reasuring tone from Sappho towards one of her students that hasn't been chosen for marriage yet
  • Tells her they didn't completely miss her

Loeb 17, Sappho calls upon gods and goddesses, in particular Hera

  • Kletic poem
  • Calls upon Hera first even prior to zeus, shows her importance to Sappho, She's the goddess of marriage and childbirth
  • Sapphos relationship with Hera is Clear

Loeb 22, Abanthis and Gonglya

  • Sappho is instructing Abanthis on what to do with Gonglya, tells him to take up his lyre and sing to her through poetry just like Sappho herself does
  • Holy queen, Aphrodite, very good relationship
  • Burnett, Circularity of Sapphic love
    Loab 24a, thinking back on a memory
  • Very short and straightforward lobe showing Sappho thinking back on love
  • She often idealises memories taking them from their specific context
  • Most likely referring to a love affair she had in her theasos
  • Topos of youth being beauty "when we were young", she's no longer held by beautiful love now she's older

loeb 31, Sappho speaks of a husband with her previous student

  • Sappho talks about her previous student and lover with her husband (the point of the Theasos)
  • Girls perceived to be happy with her match "charming laughter" very rare
  • Sappho on the other hand is very upset and melodramatic "I think I'm on the point of death"
  • Topos of Love being being painful relevant

Types of Poem
Epithalamia

  • Performed by a chorus or group of people and were performances as weddings or religious ceremonies
    Monody's
  • One person performing the poetry
  • Associated with intimate and personal poetry

Loeb 39, Embroidered sandals

  • Sappho is materialistic and snobbish
  • Link to the farm girl poem, Sappho has a materialistic view of love
    Loeb 57, What farm girl
  • Sappho maintains the hierarchical structure of ancient Greece
  • She's not a feminist, she shows prejudice towards other women in lower classes
  • Her views of love appear narrow due to her socio-economic constraints and prejudice

Loeb 49, Atthis

  • Another short example of Sapphos jealousy and immaturity and the circularity of her love
  • Her love is superficial and flimsy: Immature

Loeb 94, I want to die

  • Most likely the student to Sappho, she does not want to leave Sappho, very smitten and in love
  • Shows the strong relationships Sappho was building within these theasos' with the girls
  • Juxtaposition of Loeb 31, Sappho appears professional and tells the girls to go: A role reversal
  • Burnett, Circularity of love
  • Topos, Nature and beauty+sex, Uses numerous natural things to describe their love "Flowers, wreaths, violets and roses"
  • Contradicts fifth century Athens, the opinion of women was to be locked away however Sappho here says "There was no sacred space from which we stayed away"
  • Sexuality portrayed differently to societal standard 100 years later

Loeb 96, girl in Sardis

  • Speaks of one of her students who has most likely been married of to an Aristocrat somewhere in Lydia recollecting her times at the Theasos
  • Topos, nature and beauty, she is beutiful
  • She wants to return to Lesbos, the longing consumes her soul
  • Supports the idea that the women are free within Sapphos theasos until they are suppressed by their husbands, Freeman + Norton