Unit 2: Mind Map
Living the (post) Feminist Dream?
Intersections of Race and Influencer Culture
Failure, Deception, and Accountability
WEEK 8: Methodological Approaches
Types of methodological approaches
Instagrammatics
Highfield and Leaver propose this method, which looks at a particular collection of Instagram posts (hashtags) to gain more insight into its content or activity.
Foucauldian Discourse Analysis
This approach to visual analysis emerges from a poststructuralist perspective. Poststructuralists believe that images have no accurate meaning, there are numerous interpretations of an image.
Entrepreneurial Femininity: Resulting from neoliberalism and postfeminism, careers in content creation are framed as the ideal way modern women can "have it all."
'It all' being a husband, children, desirable/glamorous life, and financial independence that comes from successful content self-branding and content creation.
Authenticity Double-Bind: Female online content creators are expected to be visible while also being vulnerable and authentic.
Fakery and Legitimacy: Through this scrutiny the women are judged against unattainable standards that question their femininity, moral character, and labour. Labelling an influencer as 'fake' detracts from their image.
Horizontal Digital Violence: Through hateblogs and other sites of call-out culture, (ostensibly) women critique (almost exclusively) other women as not being feminine in the right way or appropriate role models.
Visibility/Scrutiny: Being a content creator comes with the increased visibility, as well as the simultaneous understanding that the influencer is agreeing to increased scrutiny of their character and life
Authenticity: A key tenet of this idealized online entrepreneurial femininity is being perceived as authentic.
As soon as that appearance of authenticity is lost the women incur the wrath of their fans and others
Gendered Authenticity Policing: Snark and call outs act as mass expressions of frustration with the patriarchy and the ways that women are limited. However, these spaces end up critiquing individuals more than systems.
Callout Campaigns.Campaigns by audiences to force responses from influencers and brands who engage in scandalous acts (racism, sexism, ect.,). Call out campaigners use SM affordances to organize and strategize their campaigns. Collection of receipts by audiences and drama channels = curating a scandal. Engage in labor of curating receipts and cultivating narratives (Lawson, 2021).
Race is a socially and historically constructed category that relies on power imbalances.
"Woke capitalism" highlights the corporate or surface-level/insincere attempts to recognize systemically oppressed groups.
Hollow representation
click to edit
Sobande (2021) discusses one example of appropriating Blackness with virtual/digital influencers.
Cultural appropriation can be defined as those with inherent cultural power taking and adapting "cultural elements" from those who are kept from power. It allows for the continued exploitation of Black people and culture.
Whiteness becomes the norm that everyone else is compared against. To be White is to exist outside any racial category and as such is seen as pure and innocent.
click to edit
click to edit
Wellman (2022) discusses that one way of establishing credibility/authenticity in highly visible field of content creation is to relate to trending "woke" politics. Navigating audience expectations allows for further "impression management in the attention economy."
click to edit
"Platform activism" is algorithmically encouraged aesthetic content that superficially engages with political or social justice topics. They prioritize engagement and optics over genuine analysis or actively challenging any power structures. Hashtag feminism acts as an example.
click to edit
click to edit
Memeification of BLM and Black out Tuesday as an example.
Spectacularizing Black representations and Black pain by decontextualizing Black content.
click to edit
feminist media studies +influencer culture
click to edit
click to edit
- Feminism= being an advocate for women's rights and gender equality.
- Feminist media studies and influencer culture intersect to make sense of and describe the relationship between postfeminist sensibility and feminized digital media cultures.
Femininity
-Femininity and gender are identities that can be performed.
-Femininized aesthetics involve beauty, fashion, ect.,
- Performance of femininity in media contexts, which is an area of study in the intersections of feminist media studies and influencer culture. Through media texts, gender performances of femininity ad mascilininity are produced and reproduced.
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
Post Queer and Gay male beauty influencers.
Post Feminism.
Post Feminist Nirvana
Post feminism is a sensibility that constructs hegemonic ideas about femininity. Assumes all women are motivated by common desires. In terms of digital contexts, lifestyle influencers engage in insta labour that is highly gendered and aligns with post feminist sensibility/ feminized aesthetics of beauty (Psarrrass, 202). Celebrates women who succeed at neoliberalism
The ultra-feminized aesthetic that produces the notion that women can “have it all” in their career, relationships, family, while still conforming to hegemonic standards of female beauty. “Postfeminist nirvana manifests on Instagram through the women’s depiction of their interpersonal relations, explicit branding endeavors, gendered forms of instalabor” (Psarrass et al., 2020).
Girlfriendship
Surveillance and discipline play a role in post feminist media texts, which can be understood as Girlfriendship. Girlfriend surveillance is also noted in post queer gay male beauty influencers. “Dynamics in the role of girlfriend culture in intensifying ideals of beauty, compounded through girlfriend surveillance” (Chen & Kanai, 2022).Girlfriendship in the context of these feminized aesthetics performed by gay male influencers and female influencers is the concept that “many women watch many women.” Also referred to as the gynaeopticon, girlfriend influencers are meant to pressure and discipline girlfriends into feminine bodies, psyches, characteristics, lifestyle choices, and overall conform to hegemonic feminine beauty standards (Chen & Kanai, 2022). Girlfriends who fail to maintain “the conditions of the gynaeopticon are ostracized and punished” until they conform to the beauty industrial complex (Chen & Kanai, 2022).
click to edit
Gay males who conform to these feminized aesthetics have been granted visibility online. The acceptance of these identities is understood in the media that quality for queer identities has been achieved. Gay male beauty influencers who perform femininity can be considered subjects of the intersections of postfeminism and post queer. Feminized aesthetics have been a means for gay men to build their status in mainstream consumer culture as spectacular tastemakers (Chen & Kanai, 2022).
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
Affordances Vs. Vernacular. Affordances → how our interactions online are dictated by the functions and limitations of the app. Vernacular → The social conventions of how apps are used.
click to edit
Risky Content. Risky content can be seen by influencers who speak out against brands.
Often this task is left to women of color to “take on the labor of calling out racism in a variety of digital contexts, labor that is often unwanted and labeled toxic by other members of the community” (Lawson, 2021)
click to edit
Explaining, apologizing and reframing. “In response to critique, influencers and brands used platform affordances to reframe their mistakes. These reframing strategies redefined, explained, and/or tried to atone for past actions.” (Lawson, 2021).“Audiences overwhelmingly read these apologies as insincere and inauthentic, more driven by crisis control and a desire to mitigate the visibility and severity of the damage rather than atonement” (Lawson, 2021).
click to edit
Silence. Many influencers and brands chose to be silent in the wake of a scandal.Silence can be seen in using the platform affordance of disabling comments and likes. This can also mitigate the scandal's visibility (Lawson, 2021).
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
The privilege White people have of opting out of discussions surrounding race and other politics, and engaging with (read: coopting) them uncritically.
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
WEEK 6: Influencer Kids and Children's Digital Labour & Legitimate Labour
Sharenting: when parents share intimate or sensitive moments of their children’s lives on social media without their consent. This isn't unique to influencers alone, regular parent do it, but the problem arises when the child is exploited.
Gay Girlfriendship: Gay males take on feminine traits in order to align or appeal with and to females. It comes from a shared proximity to femineity.
Post Feminism and Post Queer: These sensations are past the point of labeling non-conforming subjects, instead, there is a widespread affordance of gay males to be feminine within the spaces where identity is formed. This affordance given to gay males stems from their relation to femineity
Gay Men and Feminity: Queer culture revokes labels that ground an individual with one social construct (for example, gender). It also breaks the links that connect gender and sexuality. Gay male's relation to femininity is held up by the ideals of neoliberal sensibilities (they are successful solely because of the work they've put in to be more feminine).
click to edit
Labour and Legitimacy
This extends to other spaces with creator and influencer cultures, not just the queer space. Jeffree Star, male drag queens, etc can pose explicitly, but female Twitch streamers can't afford such because it is seen as delegitimizing or using one's body for attention in a masculine space.
Twitch's Legitimacy: "titty streamer" is used to describe a style that females use to present themselves on Twitch. Using their bodies as props, the games they play, and their setup, all these work to make the woman excel in the attention economy. (Ruberg, Collen, and Brewster 2019)
In a media text, certain questions persists. What discourses are implied? What is produced from these implied discourses? What power relations does the given knowledge uphold?
This is so because of Susan Sontag's 1970s theory that photography was a key device in experiencing something, for giving an experience once of participation" according to Highfield and Leaver
Visual social media is most commonly associated with approaches of studying images.
Visibility and Privilege also add to the level of authenticity gay males have within the beauty space reserved for females traditionally. Chen and Kanai argue that "wokeness" afford gay males more visibility than females, and their sameness to females, but the difference to those same females gives them novelty.
Labour and Meritocracy: The attention economy exists based on a merit system, where some are more desirable than others. Gaming has been revered by men and has been seen as delegitimate, so when "titty streamers" take attention, it further delegitimizes this profession dear to men. If the hardest-working streamers should be the most successful, then females shouldn't be the most successful. The author makes us understand that that belief also undermines the work of "titty streaming." This trend of undermining responsibility continues when the men who pay the streamers are not blamed for empowering women. Men knowingly or not, contribute to "delegitimizing" Twitch as a place for men alone.
Calibrated Amateurism: Abidin explains that family influencer use "filler" content that depicts their kids everyday lives as a form of calibrated amateurism. This practice and aesthetic depicts the children as authentic everyday children despite being exploited
Children's Digital Labour
Justifying: The labor produced by these children is presented as fun and not work. The kids are also presented as being fully in control or awareness of their "consent".
Legal Protection exists for children in the entertainment industry i.e Coogan's Law, but social media and influencing is not traditional entertainment. This causes influencer kids to remain unprotected despite the hours of work they put in at a young, unconsenting age.
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit
click to edit