Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN ROBINSON CRUSOE AND GULLIVER'S TRAVELS - Coggle…
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN ROBINSON CRUSOE AND GULLIVER'S TRAVELS
Author and Historical Background
Robinson Crusoe
Author: Daniel Defoe (1719)
Historical Context: Early 18th century, post-Glorious Revolution, British Empire expansion.
Focus on individualism, colonialism, capitalism.
Gulliver's Travels
Author: Jonathan Swift (1726)
Historical Context: Early 18th century, during George I's reign, political satire.
Critiques British politics, human nature, Enlightenment rationalism.
Themes
Robinson Crusoe
Survival and Self-Reliance: Individualism, colonialism, modern capitalist society.
Colonialism and Empire: Crusoe as a "civilizer" reflects imperial expansion.
Gulliver's Travels
Satire of Human Nature and Politics: Critiques political systems and human folly.
Relativity and Power Structures: Mocks imperialism, absolute power, and social norms.
Characterization and Ideology
Robinson Crusoe
Heroism and Individualism: Self-made man, reflective of 18th-century capitalist ethos.
Moral and Religious Overtones: Protestant work ethic, divine providence.
Gulliver's Travels
Critical of Authority: Gulliver as a flawed hero mocking human nature and political systems.
A Mockery of Ideals: Critiques Enlightenment rationalism, political and social ideologies.
Social Class and Economics
Robinson Crusoe
Economic Self-Sufficiency: Capitalistic spirit, resource management.
Social Mobility: Reflects the possibility of upward mobility, typical of merchant class.
Gulliver's Travels
Satire of Social Hierarchies: Critiques class systems and inequalities.
Inequality and Power: Exposes the arbitrary nature of power and social systems.
Relation to Enlightenment Ideas
Robinson Crusoe
Pragmatism and Rationality: Reason, problem-solving, and exploration.
Empiricism and Exploration: Reflects growing interest in empirical knowledge and exploration.
Gulliver's Travels
Criticism of Enlightenment Rationalism: Critiques over-reliance on reason, science, and progress.
Human Nature and Rationality: Questions Enlightenment ideas of human perfectibility.
Literary Style and Approach
Robinson Crusoe
Realism and Adventure: Straightforward narrative, survival and development.
Moral Lessons: Didactic tone, emphasizes personal growth and morality.
Gulliver's Travels
Satire and Fantasy: Uses fantasy to satirize real-world issues.
Complex Allegory: Fictional societies critique politics and human nature.
Impact on Society and Culture
Robinson Crusoe
Influence on the Novel Form: Precursor to adventure novels, individualism, survival, colonialism.
Reflection of Colonial Ideals: Mirrors British imperial mindset.
Gulliver's Travels
Political and Social Commentary: One of the greatest works of satire, critiques authority and human nature.
Challenge to the Status Quo: Questions governance, human rationality, and political systems.
Conclusion
Robinson Crusoe: Focuses on individual effort, survival, and capitalism in a colonial context.
Gulliver's Travels: Satirizes political, social structures, critiques Enlightenment and human nature.