Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Who was to blame for the Cold War? Unit 4 - Coggle Diagram
Who was to blame for the Cold War? Unit 4
Why did the USA-USSR alliance begin to break down in 1945?
Yalta Conference
(February 1945)
Aims:
Winston Churchill - Free elections and democracy
Joseph Stalin - Soviet influence in Eastern Europe
Franklin Roosevelt: Soviet support in war against Japan
Agreements
Japan:
Stalin agreed to enter the war against Japan once Germany had surrounded
United Nations
: The Big Three (Churchill, Roosevelt and Stalin) all agreed to join the new united nations organisation which aimed to keep peace after the war.
War criminals:
As allied soldiers advanced through Germany, they were revealing the horrors of the nazi concentration camps. The Big Three agreed to hunt down and punish war criminals who were responsible for the genocide
Free and fair elections
: They agreed countries were liberated from occupation by the German army, they would be allowed to hold free elections and choose the government they wanted
Eastern Europe
: The Soviet Union had suffered terribly in the war. An estimated 20 million Soviets had died and Stalin was therefore concerned about the security of the USSR and specifically the risk of another invasion from Europe. The Big Three agreed that eastern Europe should be seen as a Soviet sphere of influence
Division of Germany:
They agreed that Germany would be divided into four zones: American, British, French and Soviet
Disagreements
Poland
Stalin wanted the
border
of the USSR to move westwards into Poland. He argued that in return Poland could move its border westward into German territory
Churchill did not approve of this but he also knew that there was not very much he could do about it because Stalin’s red army was in total control of both Poland and eastern Germany
Roosevelt was also unhappy about Stalin’s plan, but Churchill persuaded Roosevelt to accept it as long as the USSR agreed not to get involved in Greece where the British were attempting communists from taking over. Stalin accepted this.
Potsdam Conference
(July 1945)
Changes since Yalta
Stalin's armies were occupying most of Eastern Europe
- had left troops after liberating them, refugees were fleeing, had set up a communist government in Poland, ignoring wishes of Poles, insisted it was a defensive measure
America had a new president
- Roosevelt died, replaced by Truman (more anti-communist), saw Soviet actions as preparations for a Soviet take-over of the rest of Europe
The Allies had tested an atomic bomb
- Americans tests an atomic bomb in the desert site, at Potsdam Truman informed Stalin about it
Halfway through the conference Winston Churchill was defeated in the elections so he was replaced with Clement Attlee
Disagreements
Germany
: Stalin wanted to incapacitate Germany completely to protect the USSR against future threats - Russia had been invaded by Germany
twice
in the 20th Century - Truman did not want to repeat the mistake of the ToV
Reparations
: 20 million Russians died in the war + Soviet Union had been devastated. Stalin wanted compensation from Germany. Truman was determined not to repeat the mistakes at the end of the First World War and resisted this demand
Eastern
Europe
: At Yalta, Stalin had won agreement from the Allies that he could set up pro-Soviet governments in eastern Europe. However, Truman was unhappy about Russian intentions and soon adopted a ‘get tough’ attitude towards Stalin
Agreements
The Nazi Party was banned in Germany + war criminals would be tried in court (prosecuted) during the Nuremberg trials.
Germany and its capital Berlin, were to be divided into zones of occupation as agreed at Yalta.
Clash of ideologies
USA
Capitalist
- privately owned businesses
Democracy
Alarmed by communist theory, talked of spreading revolution
USSR
Communist
- state-owned industries
One-party
dictatorship
(elections but all candidates were party of Communist party(
Saw the USA's actions as selfishly building its economic empire and political influence
How had the USSR gained control of Eastern Europe by 1948?
Iron Curtain
Potsdam conference ended with disagreements. Next nine months, Stalin achieve the
domination
of eastern Europe he was seeking. By 1946, many countries had communist governments which owed loyalty to Stalin. Churchill described the border between Soviet-controlled countries and the West as an
“Iron Curtain”
Poland
: After WW2, communists joined a coalition government → then became outright leaders in 1947 when they forced the non-communist leader into exile
Hungary
: Communists became the largest single party in 1947 elections → they imprisoned opposition politicians and attacked church leaders
Romania
: 1945, communist was elected Prime Minister within a left-wing coalition → 1947 communists abolished the monarchy
Albania
: Communists gained power immediately after WW2 (there had been little opposition since during war, communist and nationalist resistance movements had opposed the Italian and later German occupational forces → As the war ended, the strong communist movement had the backing of communist Yugoslavia and the USSR
There was also a
Secret Police
that imprisoned anyone who opposed communist rule
Cominform
October 1947, Stalin set up the
Cominform
to coordinate the work of the communist parties of eastern Europe -> brought the leaders of each communist party to Moscow to be briefed by Stalin and his ministers
Allowed Stalin to keep a close eye on them, and if needed replace independent-minded leader to those who were completely loyal to him
The only communist leader who escaped this close control was Tito from Yugoslavia
How did the USA react to Soviet expansionism?
The Truman Doctrine
A policy that commits the US to helping to contain the spread of communism
Seen as the “
official
declaration
” of the Cold War
America was agreeing to
send
money
, weapons and advisers to any country in the world that felt threatened by communism
Policy of “
containment
” - USA wasn’t turning countries that were already communist, but containing it and preventing it from spreading
USA wasn’t going to return to its policy of
isolationism
like it did after WW1
Outlined the “
Domino
Theory
”: if one country is allowed to become communist, then others will follow
E.g.
The Greek Civil War
- 1944-1949 (1947-when Truman took action)
Communist
forces
had been battling against the
Greek
royal
government
since the end of WW2
1945
- Churchill sent
British
troops
to Greece to help restore order and supervise free elections
1946
- The USSR protested to the UN that British troops were a threat to peace in Greece - the UN took no action so communist forces tried to take control of Greece by force
A civil war quickly developed and
1947
, British announced they could not afford the cost of war and
withdrew
their troops
Truman then
stepped
in
and paid for the British troops to stay in Greece
1950
- the royalists were in control of Greece, although they were a weak government
The Marshall Plan
American plan to provide massive
financial
aid
to help the governments of Europe
recover
from the damage that WW2 had done to their economies -> Economic arm of
Truman
Doctrine
Why?
To help
Europe
recover
post WW2 - rebuild war-devastated regions, remove trade barriers, modernise industry, make Europe prosperous once more
To prevent the
spread of communism
To help the
American economy
- removal of tariffs on US goods was a condition of Marshall Aid
How?
A total of
$13 billion
was evenly distributed in Europe in 16 countries over a period of 4 years
Any country accepting aid was assumed to be
friendly
to the USA - America offered aid to Iron Curtain countries as well as to to the USSR (but expected, rightly, that it would be turned down)
Marshall Plan opened up market for US good, helping the US economy avoid post-war slump
80%
of aid came in the form of
grants
not loans + in the form of money, food, fuel and machinery (helped against the post-war problems in Europe)
In
Dec 1947
put his plan to the Congress, but for a short time, the congress refused to grant this money
Czechoslovakia
-
1948
- when attitudes changed
American attitudes changed when communists took over the government of Czechoslovakia
It had been ruled by a
coalition
government which although it included communists, was independent of Moscow
However in 1948, non-communist were purged - all other parties were banned and Czechoslovakia became a
one-party state
Congress immediately approved the
$37 billion
for the Marshall Plan
Stalin objected to the Marshall Plan by declaring it “
Dollar
imperialism
”
claimed the USA was throwing its economic weight around and using it to
gain
influence
in Europe
forbade
the Eastern Bloc countries under its control to apply for Marshall Aid
felt that the USA was trying to dominate as many states as possible, especially those who were at weaker circumstances after WW2 and were more vulnerable by making them dependent on dollars)
USSR's response: Comecon
Stalin wanted to reduce any possible economic influence the USA could have on eastern Europe's communist countries by creating his own version of the Marshall Plan.
method of controlling the satellite states in eastern Europe by tying them into close trading relationships with the USSR and each other.
The Berlin Blockade: causes and consequences
Cause - Germany
Germany had been divided into
4 zones
- US first planned to remove all German industry and make it an agricultural country (wouldn't be able to go to war)
However, Truman got concerned about USSR - wanted strong Germany as ally + + it was clear that if German industries did not recover, millions of Germans would starve -
1947 Bizonia US and UK
, 1948 Britain, France, US combined their zones (
Trizonia
) ->
1949 became West Germany
Response -
Berlin Blockade
June
1948
- Stalin blocked roads, railways and canals connected to the western areas, stopping the Western Powers reaching their zones in Berlin → if the US tried to ram the roadblocks or railway blocks, it could be seen as an act of war
Stalin expected Truman to announce a
withdrawal
from Berlin, which would give Soviets control of Berlin and a propaganda victory
Response -
Berlin
Airlift
Truman knew that if they gave in to Stalin, the western zones of Germany might fall to the
communist
USSR
lead to the
BERLIN AIRLIFT
- for the next 10 months West Berlin received all the supplies it needed this way (from food to clothing to building materials and oil) → Stalin eventually lifted the blockade in May
1949
Introduction of
Deutchsmark 1948
- Deepened the division between East and West Germany, reinforcing the separation of the two German states and contributing to the consolidation of blocs during the Cold War. The currency reform symbolized the economic and ideological divide between the capitalist West and the communist East. (excluded USSR)
Consequences
Permanent
division
of Germany
Ended the four-power administration of Germany and Berlin and set the permanent division of Germany into two blocs for 40 years
Cold war patterns
Despite mistrust shown, suggested there would not be a direct war between them → would fight “proxy war”
NATO + Warsaw Pact
NATO 1949
was formed by the western powers (works under the principle of collective security
Stalin was very critical of NATO but took no action →
1955
when NATO allowed East Germany to join,
Khrushchev
created defensive alliance
Warsaw
Pact
- main communist states (also included
collective
security
)
10M Conclusion: While it can be argued the USA is to blame for the cold war because it used the Marshall Plan to influence countries not to become communist + ignored soviet security concerns and make moves to combine occupational zones, it is more convincing to argue the USSR is to blame as these were not genuine threats to the security of USSR and it was Stalin’s paranoia which meant these were perceived as such. This combined with the violent and coercive nature of Soviet control of Eastern Europe means the USSR is more to blame.