Odysseus tells Telemachus to carry on to the next stage of their plan; taking away all the suitor’s weapons. Telemachus tells a slave to have all the women go to their rooms, and tells her his excuse about putting away the weapons because they are getting dirty from the smoke. Telemachus gathers the weapons, but notices a strange light, and thinks a god is in the house. Odysseus shushes him and sends him to bed, but Athena was there, so Odysseus was correct. Melantho yells at Odysseus again, thinking he is there to spy on the women, and insulting him for being a beggar. Odysseus retorts by saying he used to be wealthy, but now must beg, and tells her that her rudeness will be noticed; she can still lose her position. Penelope tells her off too, and then she and Odysseus begin their conversation. Penelope tells him that her beauty was ruined when Odysseus left, and that she does not want the suitors to court her. She misses Odysseus, and has been delaying making a decision through trickery. However, her parents want her to choose a husband, and Telemachus hates that the suitors are taking their fortune. Odysseus tells her he is from Crete, and it was there that he saw Odysseus, who was blown off course. He welcomed Odysseus, and after the winds keeping him there died off, Odysseus continued on his journey. Penelope asks him to describe Odysseus, his clothing, and his men to prove the truth of his story, and he passes the test. He tells Penelope that Odysseus is coming home with lots of treasure, but his crew died because they killed the Cattle of the Sun. Penelope hopes this is true, and orders a slave to wash him and make him a bed. Odysseus refuses fancy treatment, and instead requests that an old slave woman wash his feet. The old woman was his nurse when he was growing up, and she notices a scar he got when he went hunting with his cousins and a wild boar stabbed his foot. She reveals his identity, but Penelope’s mind is vacant because Athena did not want her to notice. Odysseus threatens her so she will not tell anyone, and she says she will not tell. She promises to tell him which slaves disrespected him, but he says he can do that himself. Penelope asks Odysseus what to do; pick a suitor to marry, or wait. Then she asks him to tell her what a dream meant. In her dream, an eagle killed her geese, and Odysseus tells her this means Odysseus will kill the suitors. Penelope is not sure this dream was true, and then tells Odysseus that she will make the suitors compete for her hand by shooting an arrow through twelve axes. However, Odysseus assures her that her husband will arrive before any have the chance to shoot. Finally, Penelope excuses herself and goes to sleep.