Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
Family, Children, Educaiton Rights, family based on marriage, natural…
Family, Children, Educaiton Rights
family rights
surrogacy
R(M) sister acted as surrogate mother, wanted to record sister as genetic mother on birth cert - SC held - the birth mother is the mother - any issue arround surrgegocy should be legislated
-
constitutional basis
article 41
family unit, inalienable rights, protect it against attack
-
right to marry
-
-
O'Shea v Ireland prohibition on marrying sibling of divorced spouse unconstitutional as infrignes right to marry
-
-
-
-
spousal equality
unless married man has no automatic right to child, once married equal
BB v AA married couple couldn't decide what school, held both parents equal so judge made decisio
-
position of grandparents
-
RX v Minister for Justice grandparents rights not always excluded, if can demonstrate ties of dependence and inter-connection can be in definition - have to be living under same roof - reaffirmed by O'Leary
-
-
Education
-
-
Campaign to Seperate school and state v Minister for education - child can opt out of religious instruction but no obligation to change general ethos
Sinnott v Minister for Education severely autisitc child, only right to free education up to 18
DPP v Best home=schooling children forced to go to school if not given suitable education at home - held - home school parents not required to teach national curriculm and absence of irish not fatal
recent cases
Sherry minister cancelled leaving cert, using calculated grades, the past performance of schools criteria dropped - held not for courts to intervene up to executive
-
Carter v Minister for Education calculation error missed out on college because of it - lower court said unenumerated right to 3rd level education - CA shouldn't have said this, not argued in case and AG should have been put on notice
Children Rights
-
-
CFA v A minor entitled to confidentiality (HIV status) mother right to be involved in litigation involving son
-
-
natural father no rights, natural mother rights
-