Please enable JavaScript.
Coggle requires JavaScript to display documents.
OTHELLO THEMES
By showing us fictional characters wrestling with their…
OTHELLO THEMES
By showing us fictional characters wrestling with their consciences, deceiving their opponents, and paying the price for their sometimes disastrous decisions, Shakespear holds a mirror up to human nature - affirms Renaissance humanist value
appearance vs reality - danger of manipulation Shakespeare warns his audience about the nature
of human frailty, that humans are gullible/easily misled by appearances and have difficulty distinguishing appearances and reality, which can be easily manipulated by others.
purpose
by demonstrating the consequences of taking things from face value using dramatic irony, he warns his audience to be careful of trusting outward appearances or being too trusting
textual evidence
'I am not what I am'. - Iago, paradoxical statement
Iago reveal his deceitful nature by confessing "", emphasising the dangers of manipulation
Iago uses “shows of service”, facades and performances to pretend to serve Othello whilst serving himself - people play roles for self-gain
Shakespeare juxtaposes Iago’s private image, where he is characterised as self-interested and duplicitous, where he appears to be loyal, considerate and courteous Iago
-
-
Othello: Othello returns to see Iago, furious at the idea of his wife with Cassio demands "‘ocular proof"
-
-
critical reading:
parallel's Francis Bacon's description of Machiavellian villains that 'cunning men who pass for wise.'
reason vs emotion - danger of jealousy/revenge prompts the audience to reflect on the nature of jealousy/passion and revenge, and its ability to distort one's perceptions of truth/ one’s ability to reason/clouds one's judgement, and how this leads to the play’s tragedy.
Purpose:
emphasises how continual vengeance will leave an individual dissatisfied and is extremely destructive
-
Prompted by Shakespeare's play, which holds up a mirror to human condition, to obtain self-knowledge, affirming the importance of this Renaissance humanist value
-
Critical analysis:
-
Shakespeare affirms Renaissance writer Ludovico Ariosto's assertion that jealousy poisons one's mind and threatens their ability to reason.
-
Aristo: jealousy is "a wicked poisonous wound which steeps the victim in the very absyss of suffering and brings him to despair and death"
Renaissance Humanist philosopher, Erasmus, wrote ‘know yourself; do not allow yourself to be led by the passions, but submit all things to the judgement of reason’ - Shakespeare aligns with this, emphasising the importance of self-knowledge and tempering passions with reason
-
Othello: “When I have plucked thy rose I cannot give it vital growth again, It must needs wither. - Othello - metaphor
-
corrupted his moral values, feels morally convicted to take her life - He has deluded himself that this is the right thing to do
-
racial stereotypes: invite audience to reject the racist ideologies and rigid stereotypes and the chaos they create
textual evidence:
“Barbary horse", “devil” - bestial imagery
Iago emphasises and manipulates Othello's difference as a stranger to Venetian society - high status is incompatible with is race, highlighting the insecurity of his position
-
Othello’s name is omitted and instead he is perceived merely through dehumanising racial stereotypes - affirms contextual values
"yet nature erring from itself" - Othello - doubtful tone - “rude am I in my speech”- apologetic tone
Othello falls victim to racial ideology because initially is confident of his position and his own integrity but he succumbs to the racist stereotypes himself and becomes insecure internalising the racism against him and prejudice
echos the racist attitude of the other characters of the play - accepts without question that a white woman could not truly love a black man
-
In many ways, Othello is merely conforming to a narrative already written for him by his society - doomed from the start, destiny was already determined.
Shakespeare’s characterisation of Iago as a Machiavellian villain and Othello as a tragic man who falls from grace enables him to critique the power structures of his own society and explore the extent to which racial ideologies lead to Othello's downfall
Othello’s transformation is almost instantaneous, because he was in a place nobility and out of his depth.a
Context
dehumanising remarks reflects Jacobean concerns of race and further reveals Iago’s deceitful nature as he manipulates the
insecurities of his victims .
Reflects the context in which anxieties about race were prevalent
- exploits this by characterising Othello as a vicious and sexual beast
reflects the context in which Shakespeare’s play was written in, in which Black people provoked feelings of suspicion
occupying a high ranking position in the army, which was not typical of a black person in Jacobean society.
purpose:
stereotypes are subverted by the character of Othello whose calm and dignified demeanour contradicts/contrasts the bestial language used to demean him. - people are too complex to be classified by racial stereotypes.
patriarchy/women
textual evidence: men are Imperfect, flawed - tragedy of play and the defamation of character within the play is at the hands of men
-
-
Desdemona: “my noble Moor/is...made of no such baseness/as jealous creatures are”-* Desdemona - juxtaposition
-
-
Unquestionable submission and loyalty that leads to her tragic death - remains helpless, vulnerable at the hands of Othello and submissive until her death - ideal Jacobean woman
purpose:
play offers a critique of patriarchal ideologies because the portray of Desdemona as unswervingly faithful contradicts these ideologies and because it is Othello's acceptance of these beliefs that leads to his downfall
-
Shakespeare reinforce the patriarchal narrative of Shakespeare’s time through Desdemona whilst offering a counter narrative to the dominant national narrative of Renaissance England through the character of Emilia.
Audience experiences a sense of frustration at Desdemona's unquestioning obedience - highlighting the futility of the patriarchal ideologies that con-train women
Context: **
-
preoccupation with cuckoldry – a man being betrayed by his wife’s adultery with another man - man’s honour was dependent on his wife’s chastity.
"Villainy, Villainy,Villainy!" - Emilia - repetition
Emilia defying Elizabethan expectations as she publicly challenges and disobeys her husband. - active defiance of patriarchal contraints
-
-
-
Ironically, it is the women who are the most steadfast, courageous and loyal at speaking out against Iago
Emilia speaks the truth, that she stole the handkerchief in submission to Iago, that costs her her life
reputation
textual evidence:
-
Othello believes his manhood and reputation have been destroyed by her infidelity as he bids “farewell” to his contentment, reputation and occupation
Lodovico tells Othello ‘Your power and your command is taken off and Cassio rules in Cyprus’,
loss of reputation - downfall of Othello - pursuit of redeeming his reputation has led to his loss of reputation
Love for reputation/self-mage/ honour - arrogance, self-righteousness causes destruction
-
Contextual values:
preoccupation with cuckoldry – a man being betrayed by his wife’s adultery with another man - man’s honour was dependent on his wife’s chastity.
In the Jacobean era, men would define their honour through their ability to secure the faithfulness of their women (wives and daughters)
16th century - a person's job reflected their character and reputation - General in the army were thought to be logical, loyal, brave, trustworthy and courageous were promoted to this position.
‘an honourable murderer…for naught did I in hate, but all in honour” (p.215). - Othello - paradoxical statement
-