Alawites in Lebanon

Alawite's in Lebanon, shifting identity (Goldsmith notes)

Alawites on Diads

Power Distance

Collectivism vs Individualism

High vs Low Context Communication

Avoidance of Uncertainty

Flexible Time vs Straight Time

Relationships vs Task Orientation

Religious beliefs

Make up about 3% of Lebanon's population (105, Goldsmith)


Alawites are ARABS, having come to the Levant from an Arab tribe in Iraq when fleeing persecution. Therefore, they are in the at least 90% majority of the Middle East when they identify as Arab. (Goldsmith)


Although they are a religious minority in the country of Lebanon, in their area of Tripoli they make up 60-70% of the population in their region. (Goldsmith)

Levant minorities are adept in "rapid and superficial assimilation" and "persevering in new forms, their old ways of living" (108, Goldsmith)

The Alawites also experienced pragmatism in periods of political change in the first half of the twentieth century, as power in the northern Levant passed from the Ottomans, to the French to the independent Syrian State. (109, Goldsmith)

Alawites assumed a Sunni Muslim Ottoman identity then Levantine sub-national identities promoted by the French (1920s-1930s), and finally to Syrian and Arab identities in the 1950s-1960s.

Cultural perscriptions

• Art

• Traditional dress

Food stipulations for Alawi adherents: careful what you eat because it could be a reincarnated soul. Ramadan is not about fasting from food but about fasting from speech (https://books.google.com/books?id=2bli4DyuHRIC&pg=PA89&source=gbs_toc_r&cad=4#v=onepage&q=food&f=false)

• Dance

• Religion

A syncretistic Religion

The fundamental doctrines of the ‘Alawites (also known as Nusayris) are the following:

1) ‘Ali was entitled to succession; they claimed that Prophet Muhammad, sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam, had pledged allegiance to ‘Ali thrice in secret and once in public.

2) The infallibility of the Imaams; they maintain that the Imaam is in a higher rank than the Prophet because even Prophets are liable to error and sin and that there is no verse in the Quran suggesting otherwise; however, the Imaams are infallible as explicitly stated in the Quran.

3) Taqiyyah - whereby a believing individual can deny his faith or commit otherwise illegal or blasphemous acts when he is in fear or at risk of significant persecution. They hold that concealing their beliefs (in that case) is an aspect of the perfection of their faith.

4) Esoteric knowledge; they believe that they (their Imaams) are solely endowed with esoteric knowledge and therefore their interpretation of the Quran is the absolute truth, and they are the only ones able to uncover its secrets, being infallible.

Based on these fundamentals, they claim a divine triad or trinity, which is the core of ‘Alawite belief. The triad comprises three emanations of the one God: the supreme aspect or entity called the "Essence" or the "Meaning" represented by ‘Ali, together with two lesser emanations known as his "Name" (Ism) or "Veil" (Hijab) represented by Muhammad, and his "Gate" (Baab) represented by Salmaan. They hold that ‘Ali is the Lord of the worlds, and that the Quran is from him and every Prophet who was sent, it was ‘Ali who sent him to speak on his behalf; and he was with every messenger embodied in the image of a guardian of his. They symbolize this triad with the symbol ‘A.M.S, (i.e. Ali, Muhammad and Salmaan).

They also hold that the acts of worship mentioned in the Quran including all the religious obligations and prohibitions therein are actually names of places. The names of the sacred months to them are Faatimah, Al-Hasan, Al-Husayn, and ‘Ali ibn Al-Husayn. They claim that the Day of Judgment is nothing but the return of the hidden Imaam, Saahib Az-Zamaan (the Lord of the Age).

This sect holds corrupt beliefs that have absolutely nothing to do with Islam, and myths and illusions that were never revealed by Allaah Who says (what means): {They are not but [mere] names you have named them – you and your forefathers – for which Allaah has sent down no authority. They follow not except assumption and what [their] souls desire, and there has already come to them from their Lord guidance.} [Quran 53:23]

Needs facing Alawite communities in Lebanon

"Alawi" is the term that Alawis usually apply to themselves; but until 1920 they were known to the outside world as "Nusayris" or "Ansaris". The change in name, imposed by the French upon their seizure of control in Syria, has significance. Whereas "Nusayri" emphasizes the group's differences from Islam, "Alawi" suggests an adherent of Ali and accentuates the religion's similarities to Shi'a Islam. Consequently, opponents of the Assad regime habitually use the former term; supporters of the regime use the latter.

What Are Their Beliefs?
The Alawis believe that all people were stars in the world of light, but fell from there due to disobedience. They believe they must be reincarnated seven times before they once again return to the stars where Ali is prince. If they are sinful, they will be reborn as Christians until their atonement is complete. Infidels will be reborn as animals. The actual Alawi beliefs and practices are based on their book, the "Kitab al-Majmu".

https://books.google.com/books?id=2bli4DyuHRIC&pg=PA89&source=gbs_toc_r&cad=4#v=onepage&q&f=false


Early Theology: The biggest question surrounded the incarnation of Ali... Could be be both god and man? Wound up with a "complicated docetic conception" (40, The Nuṣayrī-ʻAlawī Religion: An Enquiry Into Its Theology and Liturgy)

“In Jabal Mohsen, you deal with one leader [Rifaat Eid] who has control over the population, so the army can come in quickly,” he told Al Jazeera on condition of anonymity, citing security concerns.


“In Bab al-Tabbaneh, every 100 metres there’s a different leader, and every month they change, so what takes a few hours in the Jabal will take at least three days in Tabbaneh.”


https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2013/6/17/syrian-war-intensifies-lebanons-divisions

Organized by Tribe

Large power distance - authoritarian decision making

click to edit

“We support the [Syrian] regime, yes, but it is also because the Lebanese state has done nothing over the years to help us,” said Abu Ali. “Our children today feel more Syrian than Lebanese.”


The Alawites in Lebanon number about 70,000, but have no political representation in the government.


https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2013/6/17/syrian-war-intensifies-lebanons-divisions

Rifat Eid led the party through the Bab Al-Tabbaneh-Jabal Mohsen clashes that have repeatedly happened from 2008 onwards, and has supported inhabitants of Jabal Mohsen financially when they could not go to work because of armed conflicts. THIS IS SIGNIFICANT as it shows the reciprocity/loyalty indicative of collective/honor/patristic societies... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rifaat_Eid

In reference to the conflict between Sunni and Alawite neighborhoods in Tripoli, an effect of the Syrian Civil War...


But for many, the conflict was more economic than
sectarian. In a poor area where many young men leave school before reaching their teens, the militias offered a paycheck.


“The root cause of conflict in Jabel Mohsen and Bab al-Tabbaneh or in other marginalized areas is not ideologically driven initially,” Baroudi said. “It is the poverty, the marginalization, the lack of hope in a better future.’”


https://www.good.is/articles/lebanon-cafe-bab-al-tabbaneh-march

Alawite youth look down onto Sunni-majority Bab al Tabbanne from a building in Jabal Mohsen. Tripoli, once Lebanon's greatest port city and a hub of trade in the north, never quite dug itself out of the sectarian conflict left by Lebanon's civil war. The Sunni-majority part of the city is nearly constantly in conflict with the Alawite area - a sect loyal to Syrias Bashar al Assad. https://www.newsweek.com/photos-me-against-my-brother-274000

This goes with photo inside Alawite mosque


Alawite worshippers in Jabal Mohsen attend a prayer service at the Mosque of Fatima al Zahra. As a Shia' offshoot, Alawites live much more liberal lifestyles than their Sunni neighbors in Bab al Tabbanne. Some drink, few women cover, and faith is viewed as much more of an inner pursuit than an outer show. Most in Bab al Tabbanne say they are not Muslims. For this reason, so many Alawites are loyal to Assad, despite his war crimes: the survival of their sect, as well as their very lives, depend on his success and survival.


https://www.newsweek.com/photos-me-against-my-brother-274000

The original habitat of the Nusayri is the massive mountain range in the northern Syria that bears their name: Jabal al Nusayriyyah (Nusayriyyah Mountain), the Bargylus of the Romans.[3] The ancient Syrians called them Ukomo (Black), following their Syrians’ practice, the Arabs called them Jabal al–Lukam (black mountain). The southern peaks of this range are called Jabal al–Summaq (Sumac Mountains) and Jabal Amil. The Nusayriyyah Mountains stretches from al Nahr al–Kabir (the great river, the ancient Eleutherus) on the south to a point north of the Orontes (al Asi) River and Antioch. The range extends from Mount Lebanon along the Mediterranean, facing the island of Cyprus. The Nusayri are not confined to this mountain region, however. They are also found in great numbers in the Syrian provinces of Latika, Hims, amd Hama; in the Lebanese district of Akkar, south of Latakia; and in the Turkish provinces of Hatay (formerly the Syrian province of Alexandretta, or al Iskandarun), Seyhan (Adana), Tarsus, Antioch. A small number of Nusayri live in Wadi al Taym, south of Mount Hermon, in two villages north of Nablus in the Israeli-occupied West Bank of Jordan, and in Banyas (the ancient Caesarea Philippi).[4] About thirteen Nusayri families live in Ana, a town in western Iraq near the Syrian border. Groups of Nusayri live in Damascus, Aleppo, and Salamiyya, south of Hama; in al Karak, Jordan; in Istanbul, Turkey; in Yemen; and in Brazil.[5] Until the thirteen century, a number of Nusayri lived in Sinjar, north of the city of Mosul, Iraq. These Nusayri from Sinjar, led by their Amir Hassan Yusuf Makzum (d. 1240), left Syria to help their coreligionists in their struggle against their oppressors, the Kurds and the Ismaili. One of these tribes was Mutawira, to which President Hafiz al Asad of Syria belongs.[6]

In his Syriac Chronography, the Syrian Maphrian of the East, Bar Hebraeus (d. 1286), includes a chapter entitled “The History of Those who are Called Nusiraye.”[11] He ascribes the name Nusiraye to an old man who appeared in the year 891 A.D in the country of Aqula (al Kufah, in southern Iraq), in the village called Nasariah. In his Tarikh Mukhtasar al Duwal (a compendium of the history of dynasties), written in Arabic, Bar Hebraeus mentions a village called Nasrana, from which came a certain Abu al Faraj ibn Uthman, who belonged to the extremist sect of al Qaramitah (Carmatians). And in a third place, Bar Hebraeus mentions the Nusayriyyah as an extremist Shia sect.[12] Silvestre de Sacy, who produced Bar Hebraeus’ statements about Nasariah and Nasrana, seems at first to be convinced that the name of the Nusayris derives from the village of Nasariah or Nasrana, where their alleged founder lived. But after further contemplation, de Sacy seems uncertain of this explanation.[13]


Other writers, like Wolff, maintain that the name Nusayris is a diminutive of the Arabic word Nasarah (Christians), and the Nusayris means “little Christians.” Wolff reasons that the adversaries of the Nusayris contemptuously called them by this name because of their many Christian’s rituals and practices.[14] Ernest Renan likewise maintains that Nusayris is a diminutive of Nasarah.[15]

Alawites (or Alawis) believe that the reincarnation of lives is one of the highest manifestations of divine justice on earth, viewing this concept of justice through more than one way.


For instance, they consider it unfair that a soul is not granted more than one life to do as it pleases ahead of God’s judgement. Even though God can distinguish believers from non-believers, they say His wisdom dictates that a soul experiences many lives ahead of judgement, so that they won’t have any excuses when the time comes.


https://raseef22.net/article/1080755-reincarnation-for-alawites-and-the-newborns-first-cry

The first dictates that a righteous soul does not immediately merge with the body. Instead, it ascends to heaven and remains for nine months in a place called “Ain Al-Hayat” – meaning the eye or essence of life – to enjoy the bliss of sweet paradise. The moment of birth of the body assigned to it by God, the soul descends from “Ain Al-Hayat” accompanied by angels to gently guide it into its new body, and its sadness for leaving paradise manifests in in the crying of a newborn the moment he comes out into life… Whereas a wicked soul is taken to hell to suffer, and nine months later angels retrieve it from hell to command it to enter the newborn’s body, which cries at the moment of birth in fear of having passed on to somewhere with more suffering.

Alawite history from Harvard

The Alawi creed originated in Iraq during the ninth century. Muhammad ibn Nusayr al-Bakri al-Numari (d. 883) was a disciple of the eleventh Shi’a Imam Hasan al-Askari (d. 873) but was reportedly denounced by the Imam for his unorthodox views. He did establish a wide following, however, and the community grew enough to develop into a faith and to train theologians. By the eleventh century, there were two Alawi centers; one in Baghdad, Iraq and one in Latakia, Syria. The Baghdad center was destroyed by the Mongols in 1258.

Alawi Muslims practice an esoteric form of Shi’a Islam. This complex faith includes an emphasis on a trinity (Muhammad, his nephew and eventual successor Ali, and Salman al-Farisi, an early Persian convert to Islam), a belief in reincarnation, and the celebration of a “mass” involving wine and bread. Alawis have their own unique religious texts, and recognize numerous Muslim, Christian, and Persian holidays.

As a result of their beliefs, Alawis were considered to be heretical since their inception by most Sunni and Shi’a practitioners and recognized scholars. Their marginalization was formalized through a series of fatwas issued by Ibn Taymiyya in the 14th century that declared Alawis “more heretical than the Jews and the Christians and even more heretical than many of the polytheists and their harm to Muhammad’s community is greater than the harm of the infidel fighters such as the Mongols, the Crusaders, and others.”

The fate of the Alawis took a dramatic turn in the 20th century beginning with the period of the French Mandate in Syria (1920-46). Employing a strategy of divide and rule, the French created a separate jurisdiction for the Alawis as part of a larger strategy to counter efforts by the majority Sunni populations to strengthen Arab nationalism. One of the early actions that the Alawis pursued from this position of relative strength was to change their name from Nusayri (imposed upon them by opponents and signaling their outsider status) to Alawi (people of Ali and a clear association with other Shi’a Muslims). They also began to promote themselves as a credible sect of Shi’a Islam through a series of declarations and pronouncements.

The most dramatic turn of all, however, took place in 1936 when the Sunni cleric Muhammad Amin al-Husayni (a pan-Arab nationalist and the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem) issued a fatwa declaring the Alawis as Muslim. The timing of this declaration coincided with negotiations among factions of Alawis regarding whether to remain as a jurisdiction within Syria or to work to establish a separate independent state. It is unclear whether the fatwa impacted these negotiations in a significant way, but the Alawis remained as a specially designated jurisdiction within Syria until this status was withdrawn by Sunni leaders in the early years of independence.

There were two more fatwas issued in support of the Alawis as legitimate Muslims, and these were issued by Shi’a clerics to specifically affirm that Alawis were credible within this main arm of the faith. The last fatwa was issued in 1973 by Imam Musa al-Sadr who established the Supreme Islamic Shi’ite Council in Tyre, Lebanon in 1969 and was one of the most well respected religious leaders in the region. Sadr issued the fatwa in support of the legitimacy of Hafez al-Assad’s role as President which was being challenged by members of the who claimed that he could not serve as President due to the clause in the Constitution asserting that the President be a Muslim. Sadr reasserted earlier pronouncements that Alawis and Shi’a Muslims are “one” and that claims to the contrary were in keeping with the long line of persecution suffered by Shi’a Muslims throughout history.

Alawis comprise roughly 11% of the population in modern Syria and prior to the French mandate they were primarily concentrated near Latakia where the majority served as peasants to wealthy Sunni and Christian landowners. The French provided opportunities for them to fill the ranks of the military and many Alawis experienced military service as a pathway toward increased social and economic mobility. At the time of independence, Alawis controlled the rank and file of the military and had significant representation in the officer corps. Hafez al-Assad seized power as a military officer in a bloodless coup in 1970 and served as President until his death in 2000 when he was succeeded by his son Bashar al-Assad. Today the Alawis of Syria are the only ruling Muslim religious minority in the region.

Info from Asis Ibrahim

Alawism is a non-missionary religion. You cannot convert to Alawism. You must be born into it.

Alawites put up Christmas trees and fast during the Christmas season. They believe that God manifested himself in Ali. They believe in reincarnation and sometimes one person will claim to remember being shot in a certain village and go visit his parents there... "a really strange thing"...


They dress like the Christians around them, no abaya or hijab.


They celebrate all the feast days of Christians.


They have many feast days and they love bulgur wheat with chicken. :) called "nidr", something holy to them.


Abu Taqa - a village in Syria. If two people argue, and go to the sheikh, the sheikh can say "Go to Abu Taqa" where they can get the decision.


Secret religion. Women do not participate. Men are initiated at 18 if they want to - they gain status in this way.


They have alcohol/a "mass" at their feast days.


Some fast during Ramadan, some don't. Really, they are not Muslim.

feast days - usually bulgur and the sheikh will sacrifice a chicken or a calf or a lamb

women younger than 40 don't usually wear a hijab, but if they do then its any color. Older women will wear a white headscarf.

Alawites identify as a separate ethno-religious group. HOWEVER, when I asked Asis Ibrahim this question he said it was only a religion. He did mention Alawites are Arab. Interesting how official statements don't necessarily reflect people's perceptions.