KING LEAR CONTEXT
TRAGEDY
DIVINE RIGHT OF KINGS AND GREAT CHAIN OF BEING
GENDER AND THE FAMILY
JACOBEAN ENGLAND AND THE PLAY
HUMANISM
'IMITATION'
RELIGION
BODY POLITIC AND BODY NATURAL
- James I came into power in 1603
- Written between 1605/06 - and first performed in 1606 - Macbeth was the first Shakespearean play written during James reign
- It was banned in 1788-1920 because George III's madness and the play was too strongly related to the reality of the current monarch
- King Lear is the only play to have a sub-plot with a strong narrative
THE FOOL
- Usually clever peasants - use their wits to out do people of higher standing
- Shakespeare's fool was his way of speaking the truth about important issues in society, speaking the truth to other characters and the audience
- fools stood apart from the Renaissance social order
- often known as 'nautural' - mentally disabled people who couldn't adopt social conventions
THE RENAISSANCE
literally means 'rebirth' and was the age of new discoveries north intellectual and geographical
Five key issues:
- movement known as humanism
- literary doctrine of 'imitation' and the idea nothing is new
- the reformation
- significant changes taking place
- association with classical antiquities and dissasociation with the Middle Ages - still held certain beliefs and ideas
- strong ideas and beliefs in Roman and Greek ideologies seen in Gloucester's eye gouging which was the Roman and Greek punishment for adultery
Great Chain of Being
Aristotle's hierarchal view of nature and the universe was co-opted by theologians during the Middle Ages and remained influential throughout the Renaissance
The image of it from 1589 depicts a divinely inspired hierarchy in which all forms of life are ranked between heaven and hell
It is a form of social control
God is at the top, so to question it was to question God
- God
- Angels
- Men
- Animals
- Plants
- Minerals
Every existing thing in the universe had its 'place'
To act against human nature by not allowing reason to rule the emotions - was to descend to the level of the beast
Humans were made out four substances, the 'humours'
Divine Right of Kings
A political legitimacy in a monarchy
It stems form the framework of which the king is predestined to inherit the crown before their birth
Under this theory of political legitimacy, the subjects of the crown are considered to have actively rather than merely passively turned over the metaphysical selection of the king's soul - which will inhabit the body and rule them - over to God
As a king, you can't separate these two parts of a whole.
Tragedy is a form of drama based on human suffering that invokes in its audience an accompanying catharsis or pleasure in the viewing
ARISTOTLE'S POETICS - 'tragedy is enacted, not recited, and through pity and fear, it effects relief to such similar emotions'
- a great person who experiences a reversal of fortune (peripeteia) of good to bad, is better because it evokes sympathy
- this reversal of fortune must be caused by the tragic hero's harmartia - tragic flaw
- the misfortune is brought about "by some particular error or frailty"
- the reversal is inevitable and brought about by the hero not by higher power
- if the downfall is as a result of an external force, Aristotle said this was a misadventure and not a tragedy
- the tragic hero may acheive some revelation or recognition (anagnorisis) about human fate, destiny, and the will of the gods
HEGEL - 'it is the honour of these characters to be culpable'
- tragedy arises when a hero courageously asserts a substantial and just position but in doing to simultaneously violates a contrary and likewise just position and so falls prey to a one-sidedness that is defined by greatness and guilt
- tragedy is the conflict of two substantive positions, each of which is justified yet each of which is wrong to the extent that it fails either to recognise the validity of the other position or to grant it its true moment
- conflict can only be resolved with the fall of the hero
- the heroes nature is paradoxical in its acting for and against the good
- he is both great and flawed
- the heroes is both innocent and guilty
NIETZCHE - tragedy is a from of art that affirms presentness, the here and now. Tragedy is thus both a positive and constructive experience
- maintains that the greek knew well that life is terrible, inexplicable, non-transcendent and dangerous yet didn't surrender to pessism by turning their back on it
- instead they traumatised the world and human life through art
THE FOUR HUMOURS - makes up the body and health is achieved by balancing them. Each represents an element
- Blood - air and spring
- Yellow bile (choler) - fire and autumn
- Black bile - earth and summer
- Phlegm - water and winter
Too much blood makes you happy and cheerful
Too much choler made you bossy and argumentative
Too much black bile made you melencholic
Too much phlegm made you slow and unemotional
POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES
the Renaissance brought an end for the most part to feudalism and helped establish an effective central government
- placed a great emphasis upon the dignity of man and upon the expanded possibilities of human life
- shift from the 'contemplative life' to the 'active life'
- highest cultural values usually associated with active involvement in public life
- valued individual achievement, breadth of knowledge and personal aspiration
"following predecessors"
- contemporary critics believed great literary works that expressed definitive moral values had already been written in classical antiquity
- classical antiquity - newly rediscovered classics of literature, history and moral philosophy
- capture the spirit of the originals
- faithful depiction of human behaviour was paramount
- the golden age of theatre - led by theatre
PROTESTANT REFORMATION
- seemed to reject the medieval form of christianity
- Monk Martin Luther disagreed with church policy leading him to challenge some of the most fundamental doctrines of the church which led him and his followers to break away from the Catholic Church, forming the protestants
- rejection of the Pope as a spiritual leader
- rejection of the authority of the Church and its Preoests
- salvation was only granted through direct communication with God - achieved by reading the bible and was only possible through faith in God's grace
- some protestants believed after the fall of Adam, human nature was totally corrupted
- it set the individual conscious and not church authority at the centre of religion
Disputes between Protestants and Catholics fostered religious scepticism.
Shakespeare's plays are remarkable free from direct religious sentiment, leading to the questioning of where his sympathies lie.
King Lear is set in a pre-Christian Britain
Any property of the monarch was regarded as part of the royal states and not owned by the monarch as an individual
The Kings body politic included the body natural and are incoporated into one, indivisible
The politic was the father of the nation
Lear divides the indivisible for in dividing the kingdom, he acts in the body natural, doing what is not permitted in the body politic, and so divides not only his lands but himself
He can not stop being King, yet gives his power away
Filial gratitude - love and grateful emotions towards the parent
Cordelia's actions show filial ingratitude which a Jacobean audience could have seen as a sin which Shakespeare mocks
This is the same for Edgar and Edmund - their actions would have shocked the Jacobean audience and portrayed them as villainous
More modern readings of the play put more emphasis on Lear as a bad parent
Edmund as a MACHIAVELLIAN character
- cunning, scheming, and unscrupulous, especially in politics.
He is the bastard, illegitimate son of Gloucester, and thus has no claim to land or power due to the nature of primogeniture, which is why he strives for it so intently
Edmund and Edgar's relationship has parallels to the Biblical story of Cain and Abel
Primogeniture - the eldest son inherits
Goneril could be seen as rightfully angry as she is cheated out of her full inheritance
- Sycophantic court
- Corruption - James I would give power to his friends rather than who earned or deserved it
- Courtiers are frequently figures of fun whose unmanly sophistication is contrasted with plain-speaking integrity: Oswald set against Kent
- Direct criticism of the monarch was not tolerated which is why Shakespeare's plays were set in the past or abroad
Marxism - re-distribution of wealth. A criticism of the king having too much material wealth and he is blinded by this
Delany suggests that the tragedy is that of a traditional feudal society being challenged by a more modern outlook that is rational and individuality and has no respect for their values
Feudal characters - Lear, Gloucester, Kent
- the ruling nobility were of a higher genetic order than the mere labouring commoners.
- subservient behaviour will be rewarded in the afterlife
- there was a natural and theologically ordained order of rank with prescribed social roles
- the loss of power is directly linked to the loss of land
Capitalist characters - Edmund, Regan and Goneril
Elizabeathen Nostalgia
'The king is dead, long live the Queen' - People saw James as weak
Paganism - a diverse encompassing of religious beliefs. It worships many gods and goddesses but is rooted in nature
The ambiguity of this combined with Christian references diminishes the power of the Gods in the play
Nihilism - the rejection of all religious and moral principles, in the belief that life is meaningless which is seen in the death of Cordelia and Gloucester's desire to die furthered by Edgar failing to reveal himself in the face of suicide
King James VI of Scotland and I of England
Guy Fawkes and the Gun Powder Plot in 1605 and the plague in 1606
- The daughter's role was to honour her family
- A daughter was the property of her father and worth her dowery
- Women's role was to perpetuate an heir
- Women were politically and economically excluded
The perfect son was recreated in the father's image - arguably Elizabeth was created in the image of Henry VIII even though he didn't want her as he needed a son
The discovery of America showed that the world was a larger and stranger place than had been thought - gave rise to uncertainty and the unknown
New arguments that the sun not the earth was the centre of our planetary system challenged the centuries-old belief that humans were at the centre of the cosmos
Performers were regarded as the base of society. Those employed by nobility such as Lear's fool were the fortunate exceptions
Significance of the map - a symbol of wealth and land but also vulnerability as it can be torn up easily suggesting a weakness
Kathleen McCluskie sees King Lear as an 'anti-feminine' play.
The play shows female self-assertion and sexual desire as a source of evil, and male control of society as natural
There is still Avery rigid class structure which is seen through Edgar as despite his disguise, he can always return to power and always gives off the air of authority and status where as Edmund can never rise
Idea of a means and a mode of production
King Lear is situated at the juncture between the old feudal form and the emerging capitalist form of society
THE SIGN
- Anything made up of both the signifier (physical existence) and the dignified (mental concept)
- The relationship between the two is arbitrary, there is no logical connection between the two yet they are inseparable and coincide to create the sign
- Speech is an act of reciprocity and repition
- sometimes signifieds change as there is a semantic shift
- words meanings change over time but only ever as a result of agreement within in a particular speech community
- the process, the crown, the map and the king and his people are visual signs suggesting stability which is undermined by linguistic insability
- the connection between the signifier and the signified is loosened and exposed as arbitrary in dividing the land
- 'speak what you feel not what we ought to say'